Kate O’Brien: A Life of Loss and Achievement
Kate O’Brien: A Life of Loss and Achievement

Kate O’Brien: A Life of Loss and Achievement

Available Only on StudyHippo
Topics:
  • Pages: 6 (1581 words)
  • Published: December 23, 2017
  • Type: Research Paper
View Entire Sample
Text preview

Born into a prominent family in Limerick in 1897, Kate O'Brien had nine siblings and was tragically orphaned at the age of five following her mother's death from cancer. She subsequently attended Laurel Hill, a convent school in Limerick as a boarder for fourteen years. The school's education system, which was centered on European thought, would later be depicted in O'Brien's book The Land of Spices. It wasn't until 1937 that Ireland's constitution was formally established.

Kate O'Brien's novel, The Land of Spices, was published in 1947 and caused controversy for its exploration of gay and/or lesbian themes throughout the novel, specifically in regards to female sexuality. The novel was banned in Ireland due to its controversial content. The Land of Spices is divided into three books with chapters labeled numerically. O'Brien portrays her characters in a unique way, skillfully and realistically ad

...

dressing the themes of love, homosexuality, and religion. Within the novel, the disintegration of the family is witnessed, along with failed relationships despite initial promise, and the narrow-mindedness of those advocating for Irish Nationalism.

In spite of the failures depicted in The Land of Spices, the novel offers promising and radical alternatives for various situations. It emphasizes the strengths found within family institutions, dependent relationships, and Irish Nationalism. Helen and Anne both face significant loss and grief throughout their lives - Helen is traumatized by witnessing her father with another man while Anne copes with her alcoholic father. However, they manage to overcome their problems and grow stronger through their grief, which enables them to handle their futures more efficiently. Although Helen heads a French teaching order called Compagnie de la Sainte Famille that runs

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

an all-girls boarding school in rural Ireland, it's evident from the outset that she never had any intention of becoming a nun.

Although attending a school under the same order, Compagnie de la Sainte Famille, Helen's intention was not to become a nun. Instead, after touring Italy, she looked forward to attending university. Despite her father's uncertain attitude towards religion and his previous disapproval of her becoming a nun, Helen changed her mind when she discovered a family secret that shattered her idealized view of life with him. Although aware that becoming a nun would upset her father, it was not his hurt and offense that Helen sought. Rather, for her, becoming a nun was a way to turn away from human love altogether.

Helen, disappointed by her father's love, decides to become a nun and distance herself from human love. The novel depicts the parallel growth and maturation of Helen and Anna. Their evolving characteristics and personalities can be closely examined throughout the book. Over time, Helen's heart opens up and she develops deep affection for Anna. Although Helen has a noticeable impact on Anna, their relationship could have been more meaningful and strengthened further.

It is evident that Helen's impact on Anna's future strengthens their bond and relationship. Helen's feminist approach towards shaping Anna's future aligns with everything that Anna aspires for in her life. As the leader of the convent, Helen detaches Anna from the narrow forms of nationalism prevalent in Ireland, rescuing her from the pitfalls of financial dependence on her family. Although Anna's family is willing to finance her elder brother's university studies, they do not support women's higher education, which puts

Anna at a disadvantage.

Despite the obstacles faced by the main characters in the novel, they find support in each other. Mother Mary Andrews impedes Anna's progress while Helen encourages and facilitates her desire to attend university, despite opposition from the Murphy family. In fact, the two characters may not have been able to overcome their challenges without each other. After discovering her father's betrayal, Helen initially struggles to process her emotions until she sees Anna's attentive expression. Anna's recitation of Vaughan's poem "Peace" helps Helen break down the emotional barriers she had erected and recognize her younger self in Anna's tear-filled eyes.

While admiring the young girl, Helen is transported back to her own childhood and realizes how similar Anna is to her at that age. This understanding and concern for Anna becomes the driving force for Helen to fight for her place in university. "The Land of Spices" takes place in Ireland just before the 1916 Rising, during a time of cultural and political nationalism. The novel's action is situated in a convent, which stands apart from the surrounding culture in every aspect.

The convent of Sainte Famille was home to nuns and girls who belonged to the upper-middle class. Despite the problems in Ireland during that time, they were not bothered by the issues related to their nationality or culture. The lifestyle they led was quite luxurious and far from austere. On the other hand, after analyzing the novel The Land of Spices, it becomes clear that it critically attacks the themes of the Constitution of Ireland. The Constitution's definitions of "natural" and "special" are questioned in the novel, attacking everything from the State

to the family dynamic. The novel presents alternative viewpoints to each of these ideas, such as an outward-looking European perspective instead of Irish nationalism. Moreover, women in the novel seek independence and agency beyond their roles in marriage and the home, which poses a challenge to traditional Irish values.

The author discusses how the female lead characters, Helen and Anna, in the novel portray a sense of detachment and independence. This portrayal emphasizes the link between individual growth and national progress. Edna O'Brien was an Irish writer who was born on December 15th, 1930 in Tuamgraney, County Clare. She worked as a pharmacist when she was younger and resided in London and Dublin. In 1960, she wrote about the journey of Irish girls from childhood to adulthood while living in rural areas for the first time.

Edna O'Brien's novel, The Country Girls, begins with Cait's perception of her familial home after becoming an orphan and departing for boarding school with her companion Baba. Although their expulsion ensues from bad conduct, the bildungsroman depicts the girls' difficult transition from childhood to adulthood as they migrate to Dublin for work. Regrettably, due to explicit sexual content and Irish tradition, the novel and its sequels were prohibited in Ireland. Descriptive minutiae and flashbacks characterize the mother figure in the typical guise of an Irish woman.

Edna O'Brien employs various literary techniques and a knowledgeable approach throughout The Country Girls to highlight that Cait's maternal role is not entirely appropriate. The fact that Cait's Christian name is never mentioned highlights her lack of representation in the social order and her limited options to achieve status through marriage or motherhood. In

turn, the author portrays women as victims of physical and psychological violence and economic hardship. The character of Cait's mother symbolizes the intersection of national identity and Irish female experience, ultimately becoming a significant aspect of Cait's development as she navigates the mother-daughter dynamic in the novel.

In the first chapter, it is suggested that Cait's mother was only perceived as a maternal figure. Cait states, "I was everything in the world to her, everything." The concept of womanhood in Ireland was restricted to motherhood which limited women from exploring other facets of themselves due to legal and religious values. In Irish culture, Mother Church and Mother Ireland were tied to their children for them to be considered whole and prosperous. As a result, women were mainly viewed as passive objects instead of active ones. Cait relied heavily on her mother for support during her growth towards independence; hence it was crucial for her mother to create an appropriate environment. Additionally, the first chapter unveils a significant coincidence where Cait's mother passed away at the same time she received news about her scholarship at the Convent of Mercy.
Edna O'Brien employs a reliable technique that keeps young girl's journey open for self-discovery while transitioning from confined dwelling into social milieu - sharing resemblances with Bildungsroman tradition meant primarily for male bourgeois genre. However, creating an ideal form for female development poses significant challenges for writers.

However, Cait's persistent desire to depart and establish herself in the wider world remains an unwavering source of motivation for her to affirm her entitlement to be there.

According to some, women's journeys are paradoxical right from the start. The protagonist must defy

social pressure to enter the world as an agent despite being expected to remain in the familial realm. In The Country Girls, Jack Holland represents this force, as his letters prevent the protagonist from escaping the maternal influence. His letter seems to dictate what Cait "should" do with her life rather than what she "wants" to do. It upholds the traditional role of women as faithful wives and householders that must always be fulfilled.

Through the use of the female bildungsroman, the author successfully illustrates the progression of both the characters and their own development. At the end of the novel, the protagonist's integration into society showcases the manifestation of the social order's values and beliefs. The protagonist's self-reflection in their new place within society is akin to striving towards a goal and evaluating whether or not it was achieved, despite changing circumstances. The female bildungsroman effectively symbolizes and examines both personal and national development.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New