…

…

A). Is the sense of responsibility soldiers feel toward each other rational?
B). The responsibility is rational because to a soldier it is their duty through love and protection to watch out for their brother-with no time limit.

…

…

Example from real life- Captain Bonenberger feels responsible for Pulaski’s death
Famous Philosophers idea- Nietzche and his Bad conscience theory
Authors idea- moral signifigance

Example from real life-John Prior and the death of Mayek and how he built a relationship with his mother
Famous Philosophy ideas- Aristotle and how our virtue is connected with emotion and actions
Authors idea- she understands that Prior is making moral repair.

…

…

In listing all the philosophers ideas and claims, she is adding credit to the question of rational thinking in the soldiers.

…

…

A). no matter the good you do, it never balances out the bad or guilt felt
B) This supports the argument in understanding how no matter what they do or how hard they try to redeem themselves, the guilt remains.

…

…

Sherman does an excellent job of convincing the reader and providing ample proof to show moral guilt as real and rational. She listed experts from many years ago, showing this is not a new phenomenon, she cited 2 very different examples of how soldiers are dealing with the survivor guilt and she explained the impact the soldier family has an someone.