Pennsylvania during Colonial America Essay Example
Pennsylvania during Colonial America Essay Example

Pennsylvania during Colonial America Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
Topics:
  • Pages: 3 (605 words)
  • Published: December 5, 2016
  • Type: Essay
View Entire Sample
Text preview

It has been argued by many that Pennsylvania was the place to be for a poor man in colonial America. Whether this is factual or not is something historians have had much debate over. There are several different reasons why conclusions over the issue are questionable. In Hollitz chapter 3, the text states that one reason for such controversy is because “historians traditionally have relied on “literary” sources – yet such evidence usually reflects only one person’s views.

Another issue with some claims is that there were so many settlers during this period, whose day to day lives “varied greatly,” that having a truly representative sample that is unbiased is very difficult and close to impossible. Legal documents such as wills and tax rolls give us slight insight on the state of living during this ti

...

me, however, there is more unreliable information coming from the opinions of individuals than there is factual, accountable evidence.

In order to determine whether or not Pennsylvania was indeed the poor man’s paradise during the time of Colonial America you have to look at the evidence in the text from different perspectives. For instance, according to source 3, Mittleberger’s passage, life in Pennsylvania was no guarantee. If you were lucky enough to, at best, be purchased, you still had a minimum four year term to serve. If anyone from your family were to have accompanied you on the journey to Pennsylvania, it was very unlikely that you would be anywhere close to each other once the destination was reached.

Also, if a parent or child did not survive the journey for whatever reason, that individual’

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

family would make up for their loss either by serving more time as an indentured servant, or some other way. Mittleberger recommends at the end of his passage that “every one stay in his own country and support himself and his family honestly. ” Reading this particular passage makes it very easy for the reader to paint a negative picture of Pennsylvania State in the time of Colonial America, but it is imperative that while reading Mittleberger’s passage the reader remains critical.

It’s also important to keep those in mind who had nothing to live for, or not much to live for during this time. Contrary to Gotlieb Mittleberger’s passage, you have those who not only appreciated life in Pennsylvania, but valued it more so than the life they left behind, such as Gabriel Thomas. Thomas calls the benefits of Pennsylvania “inviting” for poor men and women everywhere. He states that it is easy to make “three times the wages for their labor than in England. Thomas explains that the land is more flourishing than that in England which is why farmers can afford to give workers better wages. Not only does he speak of the great money to be made in Pennsylvania, but he talks about the price of food and nourishment in comparison to England, saying that it is much cheaper to support oneself. Therefore, in order to make an accurate assumption as to whether or not life was good in Pennsylvania, you must first think about whom you’re talking about.

For instance, women were unable to own property or do anything for themselves for that matter. As well as African

Americans were never freed and were sentenced to slavery for life in most places in America during this time period. The question can be answered in many different ways depending on which perspective you are basing your opinion on. In the eyes of many, people were leaving behind a wretched life and heading towards a door of opportunity.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New