From 1950 to 1968, the US's increased participation in Vietnam was largely motivated by opposing communism on ideological grounds. This led to greater presidential involvement and further entanglement in the conflict due to concerns about America's reputation being tarnished if they withdrew. The "quagmire theory" played a role in this decision-making process, as did the "commitment trap" that pushed the US towards deeper involvement in the war.
The Cold War prompted the US to oppose communism vigorously. The US became involved in Vietnam due to their opposition towards communism which went against their values of freedom, free trade, and democracy. For years, the US refused and despised communism because it was deemed a threat to enterprise, liberty, and security. The mere idea of communism spreading also irked the US even before its emergence.
Moreover, the 'red scare' led by McCarthy promulga
...ted the United States' rigidly capitalist ideology and apprehension of communism spreading, prompting a fervent campaign against it. Consequently, to assuage the danger of communism challenging US's superpower status, the presidents had to project strength. By declining to collaborate with the communists at the Geneva conference, Eisenhower demonstrated he was taking an autonomous and tough stance against communism. As a result, Vietnam was perceived as a pawn of both China and the Soviet Union, as Southeast Asia faced grave peril.
The US presidents, starting with Truman and continuing through Johnson, exhibited a heightened anti-communist sentiment as a result of the loss of China during Truman's presidency. This dedication to preventing communism from spreading in Europe led Truman to pledge support for France and any country that resisted communism in his 'Truman Doctrine' speech. Johnson compared Ho Chi Minh
to Hitler and viewed communism and fascism as equally dangerous threats. Consequently, all US presidents held an anti-communist stance which resulted in an ideological campaign against communists and refusal to negotiate with them.
During the Cold War, the United States initiated a campaign to halt communism from spreading. All presidents supported the domino theory, fearing isolation in a world dominated by communist nations that could impede trade. Truman's administration was particularly concerned about China becoming communist and validating the domino theory. Therefore, it became vital for the US to implement measures that deterred neighboring countries around China from being affected by communism.
Despite setbacks in Cuba and Laos, the US was determined to stop communism's expansion and maintain their power. They were willing to support a corrupt government in southern Vietnam to prevent the spread of communism. This demonstrates the extreme measures that the US was prepared to take in order to hinder communism, indicating that their goal was not simply engaging in an ideological conflict but actively fighting against it.
According to the revisionist perspective, the US's powerful opposition to communism during the Cold War was instigated by their economic concerns in Southeast Asia. They believed that if Vietnam fell under Soviet control, America would be at a disadvantage due to resource exploitation. Despite attempts from various presidents to resolve this conflict, their actions only exacerbated it and withdrawal became unfeasible. To add on, Truman's choice to assist France in fighting against guerrilla tactics further fueled this escalation.
Truman's decision to enter Vietnam was continued by Eisenhower through the establishment of SEATO, aimed at protecting South Vietnam. This resulted in a dependence on American aid rather than empowering
the South Vietnamese to defend themselves against the North. Kennedy further intensified involvement by increasing the number of advisors from 3,000 to 12,000, with hopes of boosting ARVN morale, but this only added to their reliance on US assistance.
The use of helicopters in the Vietnam War was ineffective, resulting in reduced activity from the ARVN. After the death of Kennedy, Johnson pledged to continue the US's involvement since he had not been elected as president. He deployed troops to safeguard the previous Southern morale-boosting efforts and to defend against advancing North Vietnamese troops, which was necessary due to his predecessor's decision. Since the attempts at negotiation and reform had failed, this was the only feasible course of action. Without the presence of superpower competition, the US would not have felt compelled to get involved and become trapped in the conflict.
Successive US presidents deepened their commitment to Vietnam out of fear of communist takeover, and were pressured to win the war following losses in Laos and Cuba during Kennedy's administration. In 1961, the US launched a secret invasion at the Bay of Pigs in an attempt to kill Castro and his communist connections with the USSR.
Kennedy experienced humiliation when his efforts failed, damaging his reputation. Additionally, he was concerned about the possibility of communist success in Laos, a region within Indochina. Despite challenges from the communist parties involved, Kennedy succeeded in creating a coalition government to "neutralise" Laos, aligning with his belief that the spread of communism must be prevented.
The loss of China tarnished Truman's reputation and similarly Kennedy faced losses, strengthening the US's commitment to avoiding the appearance of giving up. Presidential candidates during campaigns
showcased their determination to not appear weak or non-committal towards foreign policy. The Vietnam War played a significant role in the Goldwater-Johnson presidential campaign, with Goldwater being labeled as a "ruthless reactionary" and Johnson as a "peacemaker."
In summary, the stalemate concept mandated that the US combat communism and increase its engagement in Vietnam. With South Vietnam dependent on outside assistance and no possibility of withdrawal, Truman's decision to support Vietnam through France created a binding commitment that could not be easily undone without damaging the nation's credibility. Eisenhower's rejection of the Geneva Accords and establishment of MAAG and SEATO further cemented the US's involvement in Vietnam.
Despite sending in military advisers, extracting them once they reached South Vietnam proved to be challenging. Due to the lack of motivation and poor fighting skills of the ARVN, US support was necessary to defend the advisers. As Kennedy deployed Green Berets and helicopters, more Americans became involved and Johnson sent in troops to safeguard the advisers, resulting in a greater commitment from the US. Ultimately, although various measures led to US involvement and commitment in Vietnam, they still found themselves trapped in the end.
In summary, the increased American presence in Vietnam stemmed from their anti-communist stance. Despite knowing their eventual defeat, the US remained dedicated to Vietnam to avoid being perceived as defeated by their constituents. Additionally, successive presidents made decisions which reinforced their commitment due to a lack of understanding of the situation. The Cold War illustrated a fight against communism instead of one between ideologies.
- Activism essays
- Communism essays
- Conservatism essays
- Liberalism essays
- Marxism essays
- Nationalism essays
- Patriotism essays
- Policy essays
- Public Policy essays
- Social Contract essays
- Socialism essays
- Totalitarianism essays
- Abraham Lincoln essays
- Andrew Jackson essays
- Barack Obama essays
- Bill Clinton essays
- Donald Trump essays
- Franklin D. Roosevelt essays
- George W. Bush essays
- George Washington essays
- James Madison essays
- John F. Kennedy essays
- Lyndon B. Johnson essays
- Richard Nixon essays
- Theodore Roosevelt essays
- Thomas Jefferson essays
- Vice President essays
- American Civil War essays
- Atomic Bomb essays
- Attack essays
- Cold War essays
- Crimean War essays
- Diplomacy essays
- Emilio Aguinaldo essays
- Emperor essays
- Hitler essays
- Iraq War essays
- Korean War essays
- Mexican American War essays
- Nazism essays
- Nuclear Weapon essays
- Philippine Revolution essays
- Revolutionary War essays
- Rwanda essays
- The Spanish American War essays
- Trench Warfare essays
- Tribe essays
- Vietnam War essays
- War of 1812 essays
- Western Front essays