Walking on Water by Janette Turner Hospital Essay
In Janette Turner Hospital’s short narrative Walking on Water. the geographic expedition of the impact of relationships leads to the find of a person’s growing to be limited. All people have the strength to lift above hardship ; nevertheless merely some people chose to make so. Peoples who do non hold the strength to get the better of hardship may give up to the forces of life. Even though the function of hardship in one’s life is used to assist determine an person to assist them go a better individual. it can ensue in one’s interior struggle and one’s inability to get the better of fright. “Walking on Water” by Janette Turner Hospital suggests that the function of hardship in determining an individual’s individuality is affected by the individual’s relationship with others ensuing in the individual’s personal growing to be limited.
Throughout the narrative the lesson learned is that James and Gillian’s ( boy and female parent ) relationship is unstable while James is conflicted with himself. In the short narrative. James is a adolescent male child who wants to travel to California to populate with his Uncle. Aunt. and cousins. His female parent. Gillian is the adversary of the narrative and wants James to remain place with his household. Gillian does non hold the strength to get the better of her failing of allowing him travel. James’ relationship with Gillian is strained during the narrative because of their personal differences. During the class of the narrative. Gillian attempts to remind her household about all the great merriment they use to hold by traversing Lake Ontario. Gillian believed that these events and particular rites her household performed would convey them even closer.
Gillian wanted to remind James that he would lose out on household escapades if he moved to California. “Nostalgia would warm them like an old cover smelling of past felicity. ” ( Gillian ) . Gillian wanted to replace the nostalgia in James mind so he would non hold the desire to travel the California. Gillian besides wants to convert her boy that unfortunate events can go on if he were to go to California. like the plane falling out of the sky. She did non desire James to be out of her protective range which would non allow James turn as a his ain individual. James did non truly care for the statements and grounds his female parent suggested because of his ain internal struggle associated with the fright of decease. James wanted to happen a manner to acquire of Ontario as fast as he could to avoid his awful ideas of Stuart’s decease. Gillian is non allowing James make his full potency in life though.
In the terminal Gillian realizes that she is keeping James back and that is the minute of the narrative where she built to the strength to get the better of hardship. James’ relationship with Gillian is a challenge that affected his single individuality. which resulted in James’ personal growing to be limited. James’ single individuality is affected when he sees Stuart freezing to decease. Stuart’s decease was the inauspicious event and after his decease. James learns to value every minute of life. James does non hold the strength to get the better of hardship and he surrenders to the forces of life. James has conflict with his female parent and with himself through the narrative. He conflicted inside with Stuart’s decease because he feels responsible for it. He did non convert the misss in the narrative to allow Stuart endorse into the school and that’s why he had suffered hypothermia and died.
“Each forenoon when he woke he though ; this could be it. the terminal of the game. ” ( James ) . James fears decease and how it has the ability to happen at any clip. waiting to hold on him. He was unsure of when his life would stop and feared stoping up entirely every bit good. Just as how unpredictable Stuart’s decease was. James fears the same will go on to him. This besides suggests a ground to why James wants to travel to California because he did non desire to stop up entirely and would wish to cognize his relations better. merely in instance anything bad were to go on he would hold a back- up program. James besides fears populating in Ontario because of the cold conditions and how it reminds him of Stuart’s decease. Alternatively he tries to run away from his fright alternatively of confronting it.
James did non hold the strength to get the better of hardship and surrendered to force of unfortunate events conflicting him. James decides to run away from his jobs experiencing that it will do him bury about his internal struggle. Since James did non get the better of his challenge between his ain ideas. he suffered the inability to get the better of his fright of decease. James’ relationship with Stuart is a challenge that affected his ain individuality. which lead to James’ personal beliefs to be restricted.
The function of hardship in determining an individual’s personal beliefs is affected by the individual’s communicating with others. ensuing in the individual’s personal growing to be restricted. James’ relationship with Gillian was complicated because each individual wanted to be right in their determination which impacted both of them. James besides conflicted with himself about Stuart’s decease and how decease can come so easy and out of the blue in one’s life. Some people have the strength to lift above hardship but others can non. In the terminal. Gillian was able to lift above hardship to be able to allow James travel but James could non confront his struggle of his fright of decease. Janette Turner Hospital demonstrates that both the external and internal struggle creates a personal growing for the reader to recognize the struggles in the narrative and how to lift above them.