The Sex Selective Abortions In India Theology Religion

essay B
  • Words: 3149
  • Category: Theology

  • Pages: 12

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

The pattern of ending gestation based on the predicted sex of the babe is called Sex Selective abortion. Practice of sex selective abortion is really common is India, China, Pakistan and some other states as good. The most common ground for the acting this act is to hold male child alternatively of female one where their cultural norms value male kid more over female kid. This is about abortion, of class but it ‘s besides a much larger job: the worth of a adult female ‘s life. In a civilization where boies inherit belongingss and they carry on household name but girls do n’t, more of all time misss are more vulnerable to infanticide, maltreatment and disregard. ( CHLOE, 2011 ) .

This paper presents how ethical is the abortions that are sex selective and what are the stairss taken to forestall such patterns. This will besides concentrate on the beliefs of people of India.


The incidents of female foetuss ‘ abortions are recent phenomenon due to the alteration and development in the medical engineerings and diagnosing procedures. But their roots can be traced to the female infanticide. The British swayers in India noted their experiences into their journals during their travel to India. In 1835, one of the British functionaries James Thompson, while talking to the landholders of Utter Pradesh, addressed one of them to be a son-in jurisprudence of other. That remark created a sarcastic laugh among the husbandmans. When asked for their laughs, they said that he could non be son-in-law as there were no girls in small town. Thompson added that it was considered to be a most serious catastrophe to hold a female kid. And female kids were rarely allowed to populate. ( Miller, 1983 )

Most abortions are done because of unplanned gestation or holding a kid causes danger or crisis to adult female.

Curative Abortions – Curative abortions result from a medical ground where giving birth to a kid may jeopardize adult female ‘s wellness and life.

Selective Abortions – Selective abortion are those little fraction of abortion that occur in the instances where peculiar foetus is perceived as holding unwanted features. There are few grounds why the selective abortion is practiced.

The unborn kid is a miss, and parents due to cultural or other grounds, want a male child.

When the foetus is faulty.

The gestation is intended to give birth to a kid with specific familial belongingss, and foetus does n’t hold them. ( Selective abortion )

Harmonizing to the survey published in diary The Lancet, the figure of the abortions due to ground of the sex of kid has been increasing in last few old ages and the addition in Numberss are dismaying. The research workers province that there have been 4 to 5 million sex selective abortion performed during last three decennaries and the job is still declining. ( CHLOE, 2011 )

From 2001 nose count of India, it ‘s really clear that there has been an unusual high sex ratio for the immature kids that have sparked the concern about the usage of sex-selective abortions to fulfill parental penchants of boies. Harmonizing to National Family Health Survey, besides known as NFHS-2, sex ration of male to female kid is abnormally high that is 107-121 males per 100 females in 16 of India ‘s 26 provinces. There has been an extended usage of ultrasound engineering and amniocentesis during gestation, peculiarly in Gujarat, Haryana and Punjab. The survey besides showed the ‘masculine ‘ SRBs and declining or relentless female mortality disadvantage despite overall mortality diminution, the grounds behind that are female kid disregard and the broad spread usage of female infanticide in above mentioned and other topographic points in India ( Rajan, 1999 ) . In a survey conducted, the research workers stated that after eldest miss, selective abortions of misss have been increased in India. And most of the population of India lives in the provinces where selective abortions of miss kid are common. ( Prbhat Jha, 2011 )

The hereafter female parent and male parent ‘s households attend the sex-selection testing processs and many a times the abortion is done against the will of the female parent. The authorities has shown ruddy eyes to those households supercharging the anticipating female parent to undergo abortion. ( Quinn, 2012 )


( Natrajan, 1972 )

Ethical positions on Abortions and Sex-selective abortions

As Rosalind Hursthouse provinces, any action is considered right given certain fortunes, from a practical ethical position if and merely if it is what the moral agent would make in same sort of fortunes. Here we will see the instance of gestation, when sing that when the 1 ‘s determination to abort of non is called a ‘right action ‘ when compared to its options actions? ( Caouette, 2012 )

A hard instance for the guardians emerges when there is a instance of abortion for the remotion of unwanted foetus because the foetus is of unwanted gender: Sexual activity selective abortion. Sex selective abortion has ever meant to be the riddance of female foetuss. In some states it is non limited to foetuss, it besides extends to infanticide. Abortion means killing a individual, Warren states for case, is no more serious than killing a guppy so abortion of human because of sex differences would be allowable. Many guardians would experience uncomfortable by such a decision. Many minds hold that abortion in general is morally debatable. However some statements against sex-selective abortions can be understood based on the lone premise that human foetus is non a individual with rights, but this premise is related to abortion in the general merely non to sex-selective abortion. ( Kaczor, 2011 )

As here we are speaking about India, we would concentrate more on the issues in context to India. Even though India has been idolizing Goddesss since long, some of the anticipant female parents from India have been pressured by household and civilization that privilege males into aborting their female foetuss. The authorities is going really rigorous now ; new jurisprudence makes the full household to hold a gaol for at least 7 old ages, if the ground is found to be the female gender of foetus for the abortion. ( Quinn, 2012 )

There has been ever a function of the clinician to acquire these all deed done. So authorities has besides decided to ticket the clinicians involved in the instances of abortion due to gender favoritism. In some less-developed portion of India, a girl is seen as a fiscal load to the household members in future. The ground behind this is considered to be the civilization of giving doweries at the clip of matrimony of the girls. The writer adds that, there are ethical inquiries sing the abortions of female foetuss. The figure of work forces in India outnumbers the figure of adult females by 40 million. Indian authorities wants the adult females population to turn but on the other manus it is curtailing the adult female ‘s generative rights of leting her what she wants to make with her organic structure. ( Quinn, 2012 )

Moral and Ethical rules

Harmonizing to Mettanando Bhikkhu professor at Oxford and Harvard university, there are five cardinal inquiries that divide the thought, moral rules and moralss to persons. They are:

Who am I?

What is this universe?

Is there any hereafter?

What is the significance of my life?

Why this has to go on to me?

Harmonizing to the replies one give O above mentioned cardinal inquiries, the people can be characterized as either from a modern society or from a traditional society. The modern society believes scientifically and the traditional 1 has the spiritual positions.

Abortion is considered as a ageless contention. There have been two different positions from the moral rules of the different groups.

Pro-life: The human life is really sacred. Abortion is considered morally incorrect and should be criminalized as it is equal to slaying.

Pro-choice: this group thinks that adult female has right to end the gestation regardless of the ground for that. ( Bhikkhu )

Whatever the specific ground for the abortion, most women’s rightists believe that the adult females concerned are in the best place to judge whether the abortion is an appropriate response to the gestation or non. By and large the adult female ne’er wants abortion that is influenced by the sex of foetus. The adult females should acquire full control on their generative lives and be free from male laterality or household laterality. ( Dickens, 2002 ) .

Religious positions:


If we talk about life harmonizing to Hindu Bibles, it is fundamentally a Manichaean theoretical account dwelling of atam ( spirit ) and prakriti ( affair ) . Harmonizing to carak Samhita, a Hindu medical text, at the clip of construct merely the psyche is already joined. Though there are different sentiments sing ensoulments in Hindu Bible. Harmonizing to the Garbh Samhita, the encoulments take topographic point in the 7th month of gestation. Though there are some different sentiments sing the consciousness in to the uterus. Vishnu puran, a celebrated Hindu Bible, describes the consciousness in the uterus. ( Moad, 2004 )

The pattern of abortion is negatively described in ancient Hindu Bibles, The Vedas. In the text Rg Samhit, perchance arising before 1200BC, ‘Lord Vishnu is the defender of the child re-birth ‘ , connoting that foetus really deserved even godly fear. While Atharva Veda expresses following supplication in respect to those who perform abortion:

“ With what bonds the overslaughed one is bound apart, applied and tied up on each limb – allow them be released, for they are releasers ; pass over off troubles, O Pushan, on the embryo killer. ” VI-112.3

“ Enter 1000 after the beams, the fumes, O immorality ; travel unto the mists or besides the fogs ; vanish along those froths of the rivers: pass over off troubles, O Pushan, on the embryo killer. “ VI-113.2 ( Moad, 2004 )

Female is seen as Goddess in Hinduism and aborting foetus because of the gender is considered a biggest wickedness. Obviously, embryo killer is seen as a slayer and a suited campaigner to bear agonies and wickednesss of the remainder of Vedic community. In another Hindu Bible Visnudharmasutra, one who performs abortion is similar to trying the worst wickedness in Hindu society, killing a Brahmin. ( Moad, 2004 )


Christian and Judaic groups oppose sex-selection abortion really strongly. While the prolife-movements is forcing excessively difficult these yearss taking to vote on the measure to censor the sex-selection abortions, some Christian churches remained soundless on the step and took places opposite to it. The church belonged groups Methodist Federation for societal Action, justness and witness Ministries of the United Church of Christ and Presbyterian Voices for Justice voiced their resistance to the sex-selection abortion prohibition. They are besides supported by a figure of groups including: Judaic Reconstructionist Federation, National Council of Jewish Women, and Union for Reform Judaism, Hadassah, Women of Reform Judaism, .and the Women ‘s League for Conservative Judaism. ( Ertelt, 2012 )

The Institute on Religion and Democracy asks why so many churches are non taking any base to oppose the act of sex-selective abortions. The Institute on Religion and Democracy voted and strongly condemned sex-selective abortion as “ as a peculiarly deplorable and violent look of sexism. ” “ Churches should be among first to stand and oppose the act of sex-selective abortions ” said IRD President Mark Tolley. Most of the church groups are concerned about issues like societal justness and planetary jobs that range from deficiency of entree to imbibing H2O to predicament of those individuals victimized by sex trafficking, Yet the gender-selective abortion should be considered as planetary job merely, Mark added. ( Ertelt, 2012 ) .


It is really clear from the beginnings that sex-selective abortions have been disapproved by Buddhism every bit good. Superficially, state of affairs seems non unlike the Roman Catholism, where the abortion though disapproved in the strongest footings by the churches pulling a canonical tradition. The most cardinal is consciousness ( ) , the fifth. More of all time to stipulate the consciousness the standards of moral position is about impossible to insulate ( Barnhart, 1997 ) .

Sex-selective abortion pattern in India

As there has been ever a societal and Indian cultural demand to hold male kid, there was high wonder among the anticipating parents to cognize the gender of foetus. So, sex finding itself became a concern for the clinicians. Sex finding became large concern in India after it was introduced into 1970s. The hoardings were saying that, “ Invest Rs.500 now and salvage Rs.50000 subsequently ” . These sorts of advertizements were promoting the anticipating parents and salvage future dowery ( Kusum, 1993 ) . Posters in the train station promoted the sex-determination together with an abortion for merely Rs.70. Certain clinicians used to administer the circulars publicizing their services. ( Jeffery, 1984 )

However non all the clinicians are personally happy by making these, sex findings and abortions. ( Professional duties vs Personal moralss )


Courtesy: ( Professional duties vs Personal moralss )

Social Context:

To understand the pattern of sex-selective abortion in India, one has to thoroughly understand the roots of cultural norms and footing of boy penchant in India. The construct of ‘Son Mania ‘ in India is multi-faceted and profoundly embedded in Indian civilization ( Ramanamma, 1980 ) . In the ancient India text Athrva Veda, there are mantras written to alter the sex of foetus from female to girl. A boy ‘s birth considered to be ‘a dawn in the residence of God ‘ and ‘to have a boy was every bit indispensable as to hold nutrient one time a twenty-four hours ‘ , where as girl ‘s birth was considered a cause for greatest unhappiness and letdown ( Ramanamma, 1980 ) .

Indian society is patrilocal, patriarchal, and patrilineal. The boies are supposed to transport household name. Sons are besides charged with the responsibility and undertaking to back up their parents in old-age. Whereas on other manus girls get married and become portion of hubbies ‘ household, they do n’t do any farther part to birth parents. There is a stating in India that, “ conveying up a girl is like irrigating to neighbour ‘s works. ” ( Jeffery, 1984 ) .

Since most grounds for the penchant for boies are economically based, it is truly really dry to happen that the utmost degree of sex-ratio that is more male childs to misss are found into the higher dramatis personaes who tend to hold wealth ( Miller, 1981 ) .

Since come into the pattern, the doctors ever have been a strong support to those parents who want the sex-selective abortion done. This statement besides involves the right to allow the households make their personal determination. If we think a instance of a adult female holding two or three girls and still she present a miss kid so her life will go hard and she will hold excessively many girls. One of the celebrated Bombay gynaecologists province that, “ How can you deny the female parent to hold a boy alternatively of girl? Who are we to take away her right to make up one’s mind that she should hold a girl or boy? It is better to acquire rid of the unwanted kid than to endure the whole life ” ( Kusum, 1993 ) . Although practicians might hold involvements in this because of fiscal involvement, its considerable that their positions will be their involvement oriented instead than in the involvement of overall ethical state of affairs.

Government ‘s Response

Since the job of male to female ratio is declining, India has shown the history of activism and policy attending to Female -selective abortions. It started all the manner in 1988 from the province of Maharashtra. Maharashtra banned the usage of amniocentesis for the intent of sex-determination. Fines and prison were made mandatary for those who administer the trial every bit good as adult female and her household undergoing the trial. Within the same twelvemonth, there were uncertainties raised sing effectivity of the prohibition on the sex-determination, because the private sector remained unregulated. The deficiency of authorities action was cited by a group of militant in Mumbai, which advertised the sex-determination and sex preselection. ( Miller, Female-Selective Abortion in Asia: Forms, Policies, and Debates, 2001 )

The Indian authorities has opposed the pattern of female infanticide and the patterns of sex-selective abortions, but has been really slow and ineffective in using the jurisprudence purely around the state. The dowery prohibition act was passed by Indian authorities in 1961 itself about a decennary ago the sex-determination techniques were introduced in India. Despite its alteration in 1983 and 1985, this jurisprudence has been hapless in execution ( Bumiller, 1990 ) .

Maharashtra province provided the first policy theoretical account to take serious stairss against these sort of patterns. ( Miller, Female-Selective Abortion in Asia: Forms, Policies, and Debates, 2001 )

The salient characteristics of Maharashtra Regulation of Prenatal Diagnostic Techniques Act are as follows ( Kusum, 1993 ) :

Pre-natal diagnosing is permitted merely to observe any sort of foetus abnormalcies that includes sex-linked familial diseases.

The trial can merely be undertaken by a high hazard pregnant adult female who should run into one or more of the undermentioned standards:

Age over 35 old ages

History of 2 or more abortions or abortion

History to the exposure to any risky substances

Hereditary familial upset

The utilizations of all sort of antenatal diagnosing techniques are banned for the intent of finding of sex of foetus.

Three governments were made to run all these policies, State Appropriate Authority, State Vigilance Committee, and Local Vigilance Committees.

The adult female who experienced two or more curative abortions in past technically becomes eligible under this act. Second, while finding the ex-linked familial upset the can theoretically uncover the sex of foetus to the doctor. So gratuitous to state, corruptness, increased in illegal patterns made the pattern of sex-determination unabated. ( Kusum, 1993 )


Sex-selective abortion should be best called Female-selective abortions. India is a really big democracy. The Torahs in state are really hard to use exhaustively because of the corruptness and such other issues in Indian authorities. The clinicians, most of them ne’er use their ain ethical and moral rules to such instances, everyone is busy roll uping wealth. Morally my ain beliefs, my religion in my faith, my state ne’er let me to try such wickedness. A boy and a girl should be considered equal. We are populating in twenty-first century, where there is nil that a adult female can non make and a adult male can make.

Personally I believe that the sex-determination should non be banned but there should be consciousness among the anticipating parents about the importance of life. The adult female should be made think that what if her female parent had aborted her?

Everyone has got right to populate, to take lives, is non in our custodies. There is no state in the universe that has placed sex-selective abortion high on its policy docket, though the United Nations included pre natal sex choice in its Program of Action in Cairo Conference on Population and development in 1994 ( Miller, Female-Selective Abortion in Asia: Forms, Policies, and Debates, 2001 )

We should esteem human rights every bit good. India is a developing state and it should be thought that adult females are an integral portion of Indian work force.

To reason with, I strongly take my place against the usage of sex-determination and the pattern of sex-selective abortion around the Earth, we all will hold to re-think and develop a interior sense of equality and freedom.

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member