The bureaucratic centralization theory of max weber

essay B

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

Max Weber, known as the male parent of organisation theory, founded the bureaucratic centralisation theory. Despite of the survey on this issue made by others prior to him, the theory did non articulate its being as a systematic one until Web. This theory advocated bureaucratic organisation and many people considered it is a most ideal construction with industrialisation. As a traditionally organisational manner suited for industrialising society, bureaucratism could be moderately. But along with the development of modern society, its drawback has been exposed twenty-four hours by twenty-four hours. Research ( Turner & A ; Factor, 2009 ) showed that the rational functionary system could non hold an active response to the post-industrial society because of its maltreatments since 1970s ‘ . Consequently, most western advanced states started the disposal reform against the officialism. It is clip to reform bureaucratic system and modern people nowadays pay more and more attending to research and work out these major issues and choose the kernel of new direction to develop our disposal.

Bureaucratic direction ideas

Max Weber is a celebrated sociologist, political economic expert and the laminitis of the bureaucratic centralisation theory. Weber ‘s bureaucratic organisation theory has profound influence on the full western society and even the universe since it birth ( Turner, 1993 ) . Weber ‘s bureaucratic centralisation theory is one of the biggest impact theories throughout the twentieth century. It can be state that web ‘s bureaucratic centralisation theory is a milepost in the history of organisational theory that it marked the classical theory become mature and perfect. However, in the period of Weber ‘s, there are evident split between Germany ‘s economic construction and the political and societal value system that the economic construction could be easy controlled by industrial system and bureaucratic regulation. In the interim, civilization value system and political construction is still influenced by traditional semi-feudal society values and bureaucratic conservativism. Web deeply realize that the characteristic and defects of this system and analyzed exhaustively about the ground of characteristics and defects, therefore he put frontward the bureaucratic centralisation theory ( Kasler, 1989 ) .

Weber gave an highly high congratulationss to modern bureaucratism, he thought the outgrowth of modern capitalist economy is inseparable with the bureaucratism although entrepreneurs possess agencies of production. Market freedom, rational proficient, predictable legal, free labour and commercial of capitalist is besides the necessary status of being and development of capitalist. If people want to optimum usage of the industrial organisation of capitalist economy signifiers they must trust on the predictable judgement and direction ( Weber, 1978 ) .

From 1960 ‘s, along with the rapid development of bureaucratic organisation, bookmans of western direction, societal field and even political field make a great unfavorable judgment and rethinking of these bureaucratic organisation. Since 1980 ‘s, in the most typical bureaucratism of public direction field, from Britain to the United States, from Australia to New Zealand, it launched a planetary reform motion called the new public manage motion. In the concern universe, there is a powerful sound that authorities or endeavors must abandon bureaucratism since the outgrowth of a new direction manner, for illustration, humanized direction, web organisation, practical organisation and larning organisation.

Bureaucratic in modern direction

Since the eighteenth century, bureaucratic has achieved great success in western society that the formal reason and proficient design are fit for their society. However, in modern-day developed states they all entered the post-industrial society and the bureaucratism emergence several different grades of ailments on in or outside adapt. Because of its ain defects and the development of the alteration modern societal environment, the organisation manner of the bureaucratism is besides confronting a crisis and the bureaucratic organisation besides exist some disadvantages.

First, bureaucratic organisation ‘s stiff and closed. Bureaucracy organisation usage hierarchy moderation type of organisation signifier to keep the authorization of organisation, use the graduated table and degree of organisation to reflect the high quality of bureaucratic organisation, hence, it leads unrestricted enlargement of the organisation ‘s size ( Andreski, 2010 ) . As Weber said people will keep their place and utilize their deliberate to mount the extremum of bureaucratism hierarchy. But at the extremum it necessarily at least has a sort of non purely factors of bureaucratic system. Meanwhile, the proficient and mysteriousness of bureaucratic organisation make it go a closed system that separated from the societal environment ( Downs, 1967 ) . So bureaucratic organisation became deficiency of flexibleness, more and more inflexible and can non accommodate to the rapid development of the information society alterations therefore it showed overall non efficiency.

Second, bureaucratism advocated impersonal, rationalized and institutionalised spirit that hampered personal growing and personal mature, in a certain extent it influence the efficiency of the integrity and organisational members ( Levin & A ; Sanger, 1994 ) . The worker of bureaucratism merely do things routine nature, they will lose their fondness and eventually go a individual that has no religious experts and no emotion enjoyment. Individual ‘s freedom is encroached by technological progresss and organisational ends, people ‘s personality and passion will be depressive, the adult male ‘s work has become progressively nonmeaningful and no humanized.

Third, the inverted of intent and agencies make former reason enter the erroneous zone. Organization regulation and plan is average to accomplish organisation ‘s efficiency and agencies. But because the ego rising prices of bureaucratism organisation and the chase of their ain involvements make the intent and agencies of bureaucratism organisation inverted. Bureaucracy invariably improves its method for accomplishing its aims and means progressively become the intents of direction.

Forth, from the practical position analysis, bureaucratism led to widespread bureaucratize and corruptness job. Personal go a portion of machine and any flexible behaviour is non allowed in the hierarchy rule of machine built by organisation division and distinction. This will necessarily take to the bureaucratic disease such as narcissistic socialist and red-tape, bureaucratism will be to the full development but the job of bureaucratism will be more and more serious. Particularly when people analysis the theory of Max Weber and bureaucratic centralisation theory people will happen some jobs that many administrative officials abuse public power and maltreatment power for their ain involvements even though these theory reflect rigorous reason and scientific discipline engineering centre of socialism, so that in the universe most states suffered bureaucratize and corruptness job when they pattern bureaucratism ( Morgan, 2010 ) . As that point, people can state that bureaucratic organisation is the engendering the hotbed of bureaucratism and corruptness.

The more influential theory the more inquiry will come from all parties. A widely distributed theory must undergo perennial unfavorable judgment and pique. Weber ‘s bureaucratism born with the noise of great industrial machine and it made a superb influence on industrial age. Bureaucratic organisation appeared assorted jobs in existent operation public presentation and most people put fault oculus to Weber ‘s theory. Meanwhile many people thought bureaucratic organisation will be ended at 1950 ‘s or 1960 ‘s ( Bennis, 2009 ) , but the life of bureaucratic organisation still non over.

If people can detect and analyze carefully, they will happen an interesting fact that those alleged alternate bureaucratism things, whether new theory or practical manner, non merely abandon away bureaucratism but besides perfect repair the bureaucratism. But there are some academic theories that do non direct struggle with bureaucratism corroded softly with foundation of bureaucratism ( Andreski, 2008 ) . In a pattern direction, the new public direction reform of authorities field and the direction revolution of endeavor direction have no basically impact on bureaucratism. On the contrary, these reforms fundamentally focus on improve public presentation, cut down cost and utilize rational method and without a reform is focus on negative the degree of division, cut down rational factors and against professional accomplishments. However, since 1960 ‘s, the new reform of bureaucratism as it is for swab machine soil, take the machine sundry, smoothing, tighten parts and add some oil that make machine appear reflecting. So human existences can state because the Weber ‘s bureaucratism, people established a research organisation and unprecedented paradigm of direction. Future direction after Weber ‘s is really perfect, enrich and development this bureaucratism paradigm. So far, the new organisation theory although had some breakthrough bureaucratism paradigm, but is still can non go a new paradigm to alternative Weber ‘s. Furthermore, those reform patterns who try to abandon the bureaucratism have become new subdivisions of this paradigm and those critical theories of bureaucratism are added Weber ‘s theory on advocate reason ( Wood & A ; Watermn, 1994 ) . So bureaucracy paradigm of Weber ‘s is still dominated the whole universe.


Weber introduced bureaucratism to stress regulation, ability and cognition, which in fact offered an efficient and rational administrative system to society. An ideal administrative organisation should be based on rationality-legal rights. The more it reduced the personal, irrational and unpredictable factors, the more it developed in Weber ‘s position. Although the civil order, economic system and civilization of modern society has changed a batch compared the Weber ‘s age, but the basic thought of his age still applies to today ‘s organisation. Surely, bureaucratic organisation is still can non easy replace of organisation in the direction of authorities ‘ section, big societal group and endeavor ( Rosenbloom, 1995 ) . However, people must be to the full cognizant that the bureaucratism that developed on the industrial age already exist many jobs and it becomes overstaffed, terrible waste and low efficiency. Therefore, people must reform portion of bureaucratic system, such as to the full exert authorities functionaries ‘ subjective and adaptability, decentralised authorities ‘s power, pay a more attending to reason, train rational spirit, play the advantage of bureaucratism engineering, organize a organisation construct that regard cognition and endowment, set up a inexpensive and efficient authorities organisation.

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member