The Tragedy of Forced Equality in Harrison Bergeron Essay Example
In Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron, a dystopian society is depicted where the pursuit of social equality results in enforced ignorance and limited abilities. In the United States, equality means uniformity across all aspects of our culture - regardless of one's religion, race, or societal background, everyone should receive equal treatment. However, I contend that complete equality is not an inherent right. Presently in our culture, there is often a tendency to associate equal treatment with respectful treatment.
Americans support equal rights for various groups, such as the LGBTQ+ community, women, and workers. However, it is important to recognize that complete assimilation is not always desired. For example, a woman may want fair treatment and equal pay like her male colleagues but still prefer separate restrooms. In Vonnegut's story, the idea emerges that achieving equality may
...be both impossible and undesirable. As Vonnegut expresses it, "Everybody was finally equal."
They were equal not only before God and the law, but in every aspect. Equality is highly valued in this future America, where citizens willingly wear their impairment devices. These devices prevent them from questioning their desire for equality. George, who would be strong and wise if not for his handicaps, chooses to bear the burden of his impairments. He even refuses to remove them in his own home, fearing a regression to a time of darkness.
George reflects on the societal implications of individuals defying laws, but his contemplation is abruptly disrupted by the mental handicap radio in his ear. This serves to emphasize that society has surrendered its humanity. In a disturbing series of events, Diana Moon Glampers, the Handicapper General, fatally shoots Harrison after he removes hi
handicap devices. This illustrates that not only is it irrational to limit the capabilities of those who may be more advanced than others, but it is also excessive to penalize those who reject societal conventions. Taking equality too literally can actually jeopardize humanity rather than improve it.
Instead of striving for complete equality, our focus should be on fostering equal respect.
- John Locke essays
- 9/11 essays
- A Good Teacher essays
- A Healthy Diet essays
- A Modest Proposal essays
- A&P essays
- Academic Achievement essays
- Achievement essays
- Achieving goals essays
- Admission essays
- Advantages And Disadvantages Of Internet essays
- Alcoholic drinks essays
- Ammonia essays
- Analytical essays
- Ancient Olympic Games essays
- APA essays
- Arabian Peninsula essays
- Argument essays
- Argumentative essays
- Art essays
- Atlantic Ocean essays
- Auto-ethnography essays
- Autobiography essays
- Ballad essays
- Batman essays
- Binge Eating essays
- Black Power Movement essays
- Blogger essays
- Body Mass Index essays
- Book I Want a Wife essays
- Boycott essays
- Breastfeeding essays
- Bulimia Nervosa essays
- Business essays
- Business Process essays
- Canterbury essays
- Carbonate essays
- Catalina de Erauso essays
- Cause and Effect essays
- Cesar Chavez essays
- Character Analysis essays
- Chemical Compound essays
- Chemical Element essays
- Chemical Substance essays
- Cherokee essays
- Cherry essays
- Childhood Obesity essays
- Chlorine essays
- Classification essays
- Cognitive Science essays