Synopsis, Analysis, Commentary and Philosophical Implications the Dead Essay Example
James Joyce's "The Dead" from his book "Dubliners" depicts a character reflecting on the image of his partner's lover's eyes, who expressed a desire not to live. Born in Dublin in February 1882 and passing away in Zurich in January 1941, Joyce is an acclaimed Irish writer known for his portrayal of Dublin in "Dubliners" (London, 1914) and his innovative narrative style and techniques showcased in his later work "Ulysses" (Paris, 1922).
Despite spending a majority of his life outside of Dublin after leaving in his early twenties, Joyce maintains a strong connection to his city. He specifically sets his stories within the streets and alleyways of Dublin, explaining that by understanding the heart of Dublin, one can understand the essence of any city in the world. This sentiment is captured in his collection of short stories called "Dubliners," which aims to portray the
...Irish society of the early 20th century in a naturalistic manner.
The lower and middle classes in Ireland are portrayed as experiencing poverty, unemployment, alcoholism, ignorance, and superstition. This portrayal reflects a prevailing sense of hopelessness and acceptance of their fate that is shared throughout Irish society. The source of this paralysis can be traced back to the years of British subjugation and the strict moral code enforced by the Catholic Church. It was during this time that Ireland was engaged in its fight for independence, fueling a strong sense of nationalism which Joyce's work contributed to by helping establish a national identity.
The collection begins with stories told by child protagonists and then shifts its focus to the lives of older individuals. This mirrors Joyce's three-part division of childhood, adolescence, and adulthood
throughout the collection. Each story showcases a main character who experiences an epiphany, a moment of self-realization or enlightenment that brings new significance to their existence. The book culminates with "The Dead," the lengthiest story in the collection, which follows a circular format. It commences with a funeral in the first story and concludes with reflection on death in the final tale.
The central plot focuses on Gabriel, the protagonist, and his journey of self-discovery. This occurs when he has a troubling realization about his marriage to Gretta and their connection with Death. Gabriel and Gretta attend the Morkan sisters' annual Christmas gathering, where Gabriel's social anxieties and unease become evident as he navigates through the event.
As Gabriel gets ready to depart from the party, he notices a woman deep in contemplation. The woman is standing at the staircase, absorbed in an old song that is currently playing. Gabriel gazes at her briefly before realizing that she is his wife. Her absent-minded and sentimental state stirs up sexual attraction within him. After the party, in the hotel room he has booked for both of them, Gabriel attempts to indirectly address this with her, but she remains unresponsive.
Trying to make ironic comments, Gabriel discovers that Gretta was experiencing nostalgia. When questioned further, Gretta reveals that the song reminded her of her first love, a boy named Michael Furey. Despite his severe illness, Michael braved the rain to visit Gretta one last time before she departed for Dublin. Tragically, he passed away mere weeks later, and Gretta believes herself to be the catalyst of his demise. She experiences a combination of guilt and pride for the love they
shared, shedding tears before finally succumbing to sleep.
Gabriel realizes that he never truly knew the woman he spent his life with. He discovers a hidden aspect of her life. He believes her memory of her first love will remain young in her mind, unlike his love which has aged along with his face. As he looks at Gretta's aged face, he wonders if it is better to die young and be remembered positively like Furey, rather than experience the hardships of aging and disillusionment. However, he questions why this matter concerns him.
Death is inevitable for everyone, even those who are currently happy and those who would remember us after we're gone. Gabriel looks at the falling snow outside the window, as it covers everything in oblivion. He believes death possesses a cold justice like how snow erases all remembrance.
COMMENTARY
Despite spending a lifetime together and building a family, Gabriel and Gretta still have unknown aspects of their lives, making them strangers in some regards.
Gabriel attempts to conceal his vulnerabilities from others, including his wife, who is oblivious to her husband's emotions. They spend an evening together without understanding or supporting each other, concealing their true selves. The fact that Gretta has never discussed her past love with Gabriel shows her affectionate regard for his memory, which weighs heavily on her conscience. They lead separate lives, showing little concern for each other except when they are required to play a role in their private desires and narratives.
This reflects the human attitude of recreating reality through fear and desire, rather than interpreting it with intelligence and rationality. The epiphany occurs when, at a certain point, it becomes
impossible to merge reality with our own personal fiction and Truth painfully strikes, shedding light on everything that was manipulated and concealed.
MORE ABOUT JOYCE'S MATURE WORK
Later in his life, Joyce embraced Modernist ideas in literature and sought to break away from traditional storytelling and depiction, which mirrored a society that no longer existed due to the devastating impact of the First World War.
Modernists were influenced by Freud's psychoanalytic theories and utilized interior monologue, which is the written expression of the stream of consciousness, to depict characters' inner worlds. The perception of time in narratives changed as well, influenced by Bergson's theories on time. Instead of being divided into discrete units, time's flow is now determined by personal feelings. The language used in these novels combines sophisticated discourse and specialized terminology with everyday vernacular. The intentional complexity of these novels opposes the rising mass culture, representing an intellectual avant-garde. "Ulysses" encompasses all these elements, as it primarily consists of interior monologues from various characters in early 20th century Dublin. Although there are many characters, some only make brief appearances, while the main protagonists are Leopold and Molly Bloom, an average man and his unfaithful wife, and Stephen Dedalus, a young poet who, like everyone else, is struggling with his life.
The book is constructed following the mythical method, which involves drawing parallels in structure and subjects between the Homeric epic and contemporary narrative. This approach organizes the chaos of that period while also comparing the heroism of one era to the ordinary suffering of another.
- Book Summary essays
- Metaphor essays
- Reader essays
- Rhyme essays
- Literary devices essays
- Villain essays
- Books essays
- Genre essays
- Literary Criticism essays
- Writer essays
- Protagonist essays
- Simile essays
- Poem essays
- Book Report essays
- Book Review essays
- Greek Mythology essays
- Plot essays
- Tragic Hero essays
- Coming of Age essays
- Play essays
- Rhetoric essays
- Rhetorical Question essays
- Translation essays
- Understanding essays
- Reason essays
- Character essays
- Letter essays
- American Literature essays
- Literature Review essays
- Utopia essays
- Poetry Analysis essays
- Dante's Inferno essays
- Between The World and Me essays
- Incidents in The Life of a Slave Girl essays
- Flowers for Algernon essays
- Myth essays
- Everyday Use essays
- Boo Radley essays
- Genesis essays
- Richard iii essays
- Alice in Wonderland essays
- On the road essays
- Ozymandias essays
- The Nightingale essays
- Holden Caulfield essays
- Animal Farm essays
- 1984 essays
- A Hanging essays
- Shooting An Elephant essays
- A Tale Of Two Cities essays