Theology Essay: British Parish Life
Theology Essay: British Parish Life

Theology Essay: British Parish Life

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 10 (2572 words)
  • Published: October 7, 2017
  • Type: Essay
View Entire Sample
Text preview

Models of British parish life: A systematic and critical analysis of theoretical accounts and their impact on pastoral reclamation

According to Cardinal Murphy-O'Connor (2005), the rejuvenation of our Church relies on revitalizing our parishes. The revival, whether religious, liturgical, or pastoral, will mainly come from the communities within our parishes. Therefore, parishes should see themselves as central to this reclamation effort.

In recent times, British parishes have faced significant crises. Applications for priesthood have decreased, memberships have halved in certain areas, churches have closed and been sold off, and some have had to merge with neighboring parishes. Critics argue that this decline is irreversible. However, Cardinal O'Connor's statement suggests otherwise. He proposes that a fundamental revitalization and restructuring of British parishes can revive both the pastoral and religious aspects of the Church.

This essay examines var

...

ious potential future theoretical models of British parish life and evaluates their suitability in achieving this parish reclamation goal.The essay examines two examples where theoretical models have been implemented in British parish life after assessing each model. To understand the need for these theoretical accounts of reclamation, let's first explore what needs to be renewed. The parish has traditionally been the central focus of Church life in Britain, with abundant congregations and aspiring priests. These parishes thrived in terms of pastoral success, religious fervor, and financial stability. Typically, a pastor was supported by fellow clergy, a secretary, and a bookkeeper. Laypeople played an important but limited role in the leadership and organization of the parish (Hornsby-Smith, 1999). However, over the past three decades, Europe and specifically Britain's parishes have experienced a significant decline in their fortunes due to secularization and growing doubt

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

about the Church's ability to fulfill its religious and pastoral responsibilities. This crisis has necessitated dioceses and parishes throughout the United Kingdom considering radical restructuring and reorganization of long-standing traditions. Theologians and parishioners have proposed various "models of parish life" as potential ways to rejuvenate these parishes' pastoral lives (Sweeter, 1993).The text discusses the merging of multiple parishes into a larger single parish, known as the 'Cluster' parish model. This model is becoming the dominant alternative to the traditional parish model and involves fusing together multiple parishes under the supervision of a single priest or pastoral team. Each individual parish maintains its uniqueness and independence according to church and state laws but typically adopts a centralized administration and ministry approach in practice.

According to diocesan instructions, clustered parishes can hold joint worship assemblies where members from each individual parish participate. While each parish must maintain its own financial assembly, representatives from different parishes may convene together to discuss collective policies or proposals. Clustered parishes are described as 'yoked', meaning separate entities joined by a common purpose and direction, with their main objective being promoting community activity.

The advantage of these theoretical accounts is that they allow for the sharing of pooled resources such as fiscal, staffing, and congregational aspects.These activities aim to create cluster programs where multiple parishes collaborate on short-term and long-term plans. In the case of Bedfordshire, the parishes of Shillington, Barton, and Shefford joined forces to hire a lay minister, an educational consultant for nine local schools, and a lay training manager. This clustering activity demonstrates the potential improvements in finance, staff, and organizational deficits if other parishes were to adopt similar strategies.

British parishes

can take inspiration from the successful example of cluster parishes in the United States. Bishop Clark's "Pastoral Planning in the New Millennium" strategy has been effectively implemented in multiple parishes in the bishopric of Rochester. Clusters are also seen as a critical way of revitalizing and reevaluating parish leadership.

The "Notre Dame Study of Parish Life" underscores the importance of lay staff within parish structures. The combination of various professional experiences brought together by groups allows for a wider preparation and expertise in curating ballads. This includes the training of temporary individuals to curate Sunday Communion Services when a priest is absent.

Parishes can also employ lay staff, including women, to work as "pastoral helpers" in parish ministries (Hoge, 1998). Moreover, single parishes are considered the traditional and ideal form of the British parish.Despite the challenges faced by British parishes and the increasing trend of consolidating parishes by bishoprics, individual parishes are still being established in the United Kingdom. These single parishes are created to meet the demands of a growing Catholic or Anglican population in specific areas. Recent demographic shifts have caused significant changes in population distribution, with previously sparsely populated areas experiencing a large influx of people while heavily populated areas have seen groups leaving, resulting in them becoming sparsely populated (Harrington, 1997). As a result, many parishes have had to adjust their boundaries to accommodate these mass movements of parishioners. Some individual parishes have closed down, while others have been reconstituted or newly formed to address the changing demographics of their congregations. In some cases, these individual parishes have taken over the territories of closed parishes. There is also an increasing trend of multiple

adjacent parishes. Many closing parishes were originally established to serve different nationalities in heavily populated urban areas. The purpose of a parish is to strengthen the faith community, raise funds for building projects and development programs, and provide pastoral care for its members. A new model called "The Single Parish With Multiple Worship and Ministry Sites" involves merging two or more separate parishes into one.Each parish's facilities are still used by its members, but they now belong to a single parish. The newly created parish has a new name, a new priest and leadership for pastoral care and ministry. Sometimes, one church from these merged parishes will be used for ministry training or sold to another community organization.

In the Single Parish with Multiple Faith Communities model, a single parish takes responsibility for several faith communities such as hospitals, schools, prisons, etc. If a school is located in a particular parish, the vicar or chaplain for that school will be part of the pastoral leadership panel for that parish. In this scenario, the parish takes on direct pastoral responsibility for the school. This collaboration between different faith communities aims to rejuvenate pastoral work and strengthen religious enthusiasm within the parish while promoting greater coordination among various faith communities.

The leadership of the parish becomes more multicultural and can draw on a more diverse group of experts to oversee its pastoral care.

A similar model is seen in Multiple Parishes with Multiple Faith Communities. In this model, independent parishes form a partnership to provide pastoral support to various faith communities within their respective parishes. In addition to faith communities such as hospitals and schools, these strategies offer pastoral care

to specific groups like the physically or mentally handicapped immigrants and victims of domestic violence.The joint parish partnership shares the financial cost with the faith community it assists in these cases. The ministry of the parish can be based in a single parish or represent a collective effort from each participating parish. For instance, multiple parishes collaborate in Luton to provide assistance for the local Pakistani and Indian immigrant communities. Alternative models of leadership and ministry are also being considered, along with new theoretical models of parish life. This essay will explore three such models briefly.

Firstly, there are Joint Plans which are implemented as collaborative efforts between multiple parishes, rather than separate plans as traditionally done. These plans tend to be concentrated in one location to improve efficiency. An example of this model is the partnership board of Monroe Country Parishes (Monroe) in America's Catholic Schools, which has been piloted and may prove successful in Britain as well.

Secondly, Joint Staff plans allow several parishes to hire one staff member who oversees ministerial programs across these parishes. This innovative approach utilizes the increasing number of individuals becoming involved in parish life.

Lastly, Independent Single Parish Programs follow the traditional model of parish ministry.The number of independent ministry programs in individual parishes is decreasing, favoring two other models. All these models require a significant restructuring of the traditional staffing model within a parish. In the past, a typical parish in Great Britain would have had a priest with assistant priests, a parish secretary, and an accountant. However, there is now more diversity in the composition of parish staff. This includes permanent deacons, priest curates, and laypersons. This diversity

allows parishes to select staff based on their specific needs and chosen model. For example, some parishes may employ retired priests or women for marriage or baptism ceremonies. "Priest administrators" appointed by bishops act as efficient replacements for costly parish bookkeepers. Permanent deacons have been employed since 1982 and serve various functions such as assisting with baptisms and funerals. They can witness marriages, participate in Mass, lead prayers, and also have pastoral duties including charity work and involvement in the justice system.

Note: The original text did not contain any or contents to keep while it.With the decrease in priest numbers, parishes are increasingly relying on permanent deacons for pastoral work and to assist exhausted curates. Permanent deacons now often serve as curates alongside Pastoral Administrators who are appointed to carry out pastoral work in a parish without being priests. Despite not being able to preside over sacraments reserved for ordained priests, women and laypeople can also be appointed as Pastoral Administrators. When a parish has a Pastoral Administrator, a sacramental curate will be assigned to administer sacraments like the Eucharist. Catechetical Leaders provide spiritual education programs for all members of the parish, including instruction for school children, preparation for sacraments, and education for parents and those seeking Confirmation. Business Directors are becoming increasingly important in modern parishes to handle finances, building projects, staff expenses, legal matters, and other administrative tasks. Cardinal Murphy O'Connor, Archbishop of Westminster, believes that adopting a "cluster" model of parishes is the future for his diocese's parishes. The Cardinal recently presented a highly anticipated green paper titled 'Response and Analysis'. In his address at Westminster Cathedral, he emphasized the

need for significant restructuring of Westminster parishes to ensure their revitalization.According to an article in The Times, the plans of Westminster diocese, known as the 'mother' diocese in England and Wales, to make significant changes due to declining numbers are being closely watched by church authorities across the West. The importance of the Cardinal's speech was widely recognized throughout Europe as a call for parish reform. He informed his parishioners that many parishes would either close or merge and that they should no longer expect a permanent priest in their parish. The Cardinal also encouraged laypersons to take on more responsibility in administration, pastoral work, and prayers of the parishes. He suggested reducing Mass frequency and stressed the need for coordination among staff, ministries, prayers, and potentially Holy Eucharists within parishes. These measures were described as responses to the substantial decrease in priests and congregations over recent years. In 1990, there were 843 priests in Westminster's parishes. By 2005, this number had decreased to 623 and is projected to further decline to 471 by 2015 - representing a 50% decrease within ten years. In response to these alarming figures, Westminster is implementing the cluster model to address this issue. Cardinal Murphy-O'Connor expressed confidence in the success of these new measures while assuring that there is no reason for losing faith in God's plan for His Church.
In the text, the Cardinal highlights the increasing number of Roman Catholics joining Westminster parishes and the record number of individuals applying for adult baptism. Therefore, he argues that it is necessary to reorganize parishes in order to adapt to changes in Church structure and demographics. The Cardinal's green paper

emphasizes that there will be a significant transformation in both the image and structure of the Church over the next 15 years. Furthermore, parishes need to adopt a new mindset to maximize lay leadership potential. It is no longer sufficient for a parish's viability to rely solely on its resident priest. The Cardinal's message has spread throughout United Kingdom parishes, urging each one to seriously consider whether they should close, merge, be absorbed by larger parishes, or grouped together with others. He warns about the consequences of ignoring these changes during a time when European churches, particularly those in Great Britain, are experiencing both decline and growth - a crisis characterized by decision-making and unpredictability but also presenting opportunities. When discussing the need for reform, he acknowledges that challenges, anxieties, and fears faced within our own country should not catch us off guard.The introduction of "cluster" models in Westminster has generated cautious optimism among parishes. However, the Diocese of Salford, which covers Lancashire and includes the parishes of Manchester, Bolton, Rochdale, Blackburn, Oldham, and Bury, has shown less enthusiasm for proposals for new models of parish life. Bishop Terence Brain implemented cluster models in an attempt to address the declining number of priesthood applicants and church attendance. It is predicted that the number of priests in Salford will decrease from 216 today to 113 in 2018. Bishop Brain warned his parishioners that redundant buildings will be demolished and sold. Fifteen churches are proposed to be shut down while 17 have already been closed since the 1960's. Some parishioners criticize the Bishop's proposals as resembling a downsizing program rather than addressing the religious aspects of the

Church. The outrage continued when parish churches were demolished while a planned office building was constructed in Manchester at a cost of 1 million pounds. Parishioners argue that instead of restructuring based on theoretical accounts of parish life, what is needed is a revitalization of the religious side of the Church."One passionate parishioner quoted Harrington (1997) stating that a Church in love with the Eucharist alone generates holy and legion priestly holidays. The evident commercialization of the Church under these theoretical accounts is causing deep concern among Salford's parishioners. They argue that parishes should stop constructing buildings, especially for diocesan offices, and instead focus on recruiting new priests from Brazil, the Philippines, and Eastern Europe where their numbers are increasing. Parishes should only have to close or merge if their corresponding bishoprics are also closed or merged. Most Church and parish leaders agree that there is a pastoral crisis facing parishes. To address this issue, there is a widespread call for using new theoretical models of parish life, particularly the 'cluster' model which is gaining popularity in Britain and the United States. This model offers practical benefits such as reducing parish costs and bringing together various faith communities that were previously disconnected. However, critics argue that such models commercialize parish life and advocate for a return to the simplicity and effectiveness of the traditional individual parish model that has been successful for centuries."A possible compromise is to view the 'cluster' model as a temporary solution, with the intention of reverting to the traditional model once Christianity regains authority in the United Kingdom. The text cites various publications on parish leadership, including "Forms of Parish Leadership:

Cost and Effectiveness" by Sheed & Ward, "The Changing Parish: a Study of Parishes, Priests and Parishioners after Vatican II" by Hornsby-Smith, "The Church for an Open Future: Biblical Roots and Parish Renewal" by Lundin, "Creative Ideas: For Small Groups in the Christian Community" by Mallison, and Murphy-O'Connor's response and analysis to the "Green Paper". The term "Alternative Staffing of Parishes" was first used in a 1987 publication by the National Pastoral Life Centre.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New