Iraqi prisoners held at the Abu Ghraib prison Essay Example
Iraqi prisoners held at the Abu Ghraib prison Essay Example

Iraqi prisoners held at the Abu Ghraib prison Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
Topics:
  • Pages: 4 (1099 words)
  • Published: December 11, 2017
  • Type: Essay
View Entire Sample
Text preview

The Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse story is a topic that various individuals and groups in the United States must consider whether it will have an advantageous or disadvantageous effect on the country's mood and security. Before deciding to report or publish such a story, journalists, newspapers, magazines, web sites, and radio stations are responsible for evaluating its potential benefit or harm to the nation, as well as their willingness to take risks for global betterment. However, in early 2004, the news media and journalists in the United States ultimately made a favorable decision by resolving the debate over whether coverage of this story should have taken place. This was due to multiple images that emerged showing torture and mistreatment of Iraqi prisoners who were held at Abu Ghraib prison while under U.S. control.Multiple unsettling photographs were r

...

eleased as a result of American soldiers' custody of Iraqi detainees. These images depicted male and female soldiers laughing and making thumbs-up gestures while taking pictures with naked prisoners who were either stacked in a pyramid formation, posing for sex acts, or deceased. One particularly disturbing picture showed an Iraqi man standing on a box with wires attached to his hooded head and hands. Two Muslim captives at Abu Ghraib reported being subjected to torture that included consuming alcohol and pork - both forbidden under Islamic law - as well as being coerced into public masturbation. They were also added to an undressed men pyramid.

The detainees stated that they were being tortured in a manner that seemed like entertainment for the soldiers. This caused a shift in their perception of all Americans. They claimed that even Saddam Hussein did

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

not subject them to this kind of treatment. The soldiers were shown to have beaten the prisoners, made them undress, masturbate, intimidated them with dogs, and covered them in excrement while placing them in embarrassing and stressful positions. Sergeant Joseph Darby, a military police officer who felt that the actions shown in the images were ethically unacceptable, presented them to Army investigators.

According to Darby, the prison had a history of abuse that preceded his unit's arrival. During a compound tour in October 2003, his unit witnessed 15 inmates wearing women's underwear in their cells. Additionally, there were instances where government agencies took detainees from the prison, leaving uncertainty as to when or if they would return. Darby even remembers a Black Hawk helicopter landing at 4 a.m. during one such instance.

Several men took a prisoner and put up sheets to block the view of their actions. They remained behind the sheets all night and later revealed that the prisoner had died. They requested ice to preserve the body and informed U.S. authorities.

The argument was made that soldiers ought to accept accountability for the chaos and consider their absence during the occurrences at Abu Ghraib. The behaviors were ethically wrong, brutal, inappropriate, and stayed hidden. Six Americans became involved eventually.

Members of the 800th Military Police Brigade, who were responsible for guarding Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, faced charges related to mistreating Iraqi prisoners. The charges included assault, dereliction of duty, cruelty, maltreatment, conspiracy and engaging in indecent acts with others. Seventeen soldiers were suspended from their duties for violating the Uniform Code Military Justice, exceeding those charged. While some people believe that releasing pictures depicting the

abuse at Abu Ghraib was helpful, others think it damaged both America’s reputation and efforts.

General Mark Kimmitt warns that soldiers in Iraq are in danger because of reports of abuse towards Iraqis. Military expert Colonel Bob Stewart shares these concerns, stating that the photos could worsen an already unstable situation in the Arab world. Many expect setbacks for the U.S. due to this information being released.

The efforts of the United States to win the support of the Iraqi people have had negative consequences on the morale of U.S. troops in Iraq, as well as fueling anti-U.S. sentiments.

Despite potential repercussions on national mood and security, S. was angered by reports of abuse, acknowledging the gravity of the U.S. soldiers' actions at Abu Ghraib. The release of this information was crucial for ensuring global justice.

Martin Luther King Jr. stressed that injustice anywhere poses a threat to justice everywhere and prioritized human rights and impartiality above the state of the United States. The atrocities committed at Abu Ghraib warranted action, but if not for organizations like the American Civil Liberties Union utilizing a Freedom of Information Act case to sue the Defense Department, much of the reprehensible conduct would have remained concealed. Despite dissenting opinions arguing that exposing this information was detrimental to the nation.

It was a triumph for the general population as they have the right to be informed about the actions of the United States military in the Middle East and to receive complete honesty. Overlooking incidents like those that took place at Abu Ghraib would result in individuals' inherent entitlement to physical wellbeing and respect becoming increasingly at risk.

The incident that occurred at Abu

Ghraib was extremely disturbing and constituted a severe violation of the dignity and humane treatment of Iraqis. If reports on such incidents are not spread through various media channels, it will impede the advancement of progress and justice. Furthermore, if a nation as dominant as the United States ignores regulations, it sets an example for others to follow suit.

Negative responses to the incident hold significant importance for moral and security concerns in the United States. They play a crucial role in maintaining the reputation of the country among other nations. Without public disapproval of such actions, this reputation would suffer.

S. even more crucial is our response to incidents like the Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse scandal. Although media coverage did not depict US soldiers in a favorable manner, the nation's reaction and ensuing measures indicate a zero-tolerance policy towards such cruelty.

Although a few American soldiers engaged in torture of Iraqi detainees, this behavior did not reflect the entire nation. Initially, there were negative effects on national mood and security; however, the widespread coverage of the Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse story exposed inappropriate actions by some U.S. and other soldiers. Ultimately, this informed and educated numerous individuals worldwide.

The exposure of these heinous acts has prompted individuals to scrutinize the intentions of the United States and react accordingly, which is imperative. Failure to publicize this matter may result in ongoing misconduct, allowing government and military officials to avoid responsibility. Ultimately, neglecting to address this issue could compromise national spirit, safety, civil liberties, and human rights.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New