Egg donation ivf for postmenopausal women
Egg donation ivf for postmenopausal women

Egg donation ivf for postmenopausal women

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 6 (2977 words)
  • Published: August 4, 2017
Text preview

This subject has come under much examination in the past decennary. In this paper I discuss the different statements put frontward by the critics, which include, increased complications to the female parent and kid, the ‘right non to be orphaned ‘ , scarceness of resources and who should hold precedence, every bit good as the societal concern such as postmenopausal female parents being unnatural and being thought of as ‘inappropriate female parents ‘ . Reviewing and analyzing these statements I feel that the is no ground to deny entree to postmenopausal female parents, every bit long as they have been screened and have been found to be healthy, they are funding the intervention themselves and they have thourally weighed up both the hazards and the benefits of the intervention. Sing the societal facets of the statement, I feel that they are strictly baseless and that societies attitudes to this subject should germinate merely as the engineering and scientific discipline has done.

The mean age of a adult female traveling through the climacteric in the UK is 52 old ages ( NHS, 2009 ) . However the NHS merely financess adult females up to 39 to hold IVF intervention ( HFEA, 2009 ) , private clinics have no age limitations but typically merely dainty adult females up to 50 ( Bown- Simpkins, 2009 ) . Modern biotechnology such as egg contribution can let adult females over 50 who have gone through the climacteric to go pregnant and give birth to healthy babes. In this essay I will discourse the concerns of the critics of this process and set frontward my pos

...

ition on why postmenopausal adult females should be allowed entree to IVF.

Increased complications

One of the major statements put frontward against IVF intervention in postmenopausal adult females Centres on the belief that it is unethical to supply intervention to these adult females, due to increased hazard of complications to both female parent and the babe. Doctors cardinal dogma is ‘first of all do no injury ‘ , hence if utilizing IVF in postmenopausal female parents leads to morbidity or put on the line the life of the female parent or the kid so it is unethical to let them to hold this intervention. However, if this is the exclusive ground for declining IVF to this sector of adult females so physicians should besides decline birthrate intervention to adult females who have medical upsets such as cardiac disease or malignant neoplastic disease who are besides at increased hazard of complications ( Bewley, 1995 ) .

Retrospective surveies that have suggested important additions in the hazard of complications in adult females over a certain age, when compared to their younger opposite numbers ( Lehmann & A ; Chism, 1987 ) are non changeless at looking at pre- bing medical conditions, antenatal showing and the wellness attention they received throughout their gestations ( Paulson, et Al. 2002 ) . Thus their dependability can be called into inquiry.

Paulson et Al. ( 2002 ) found that healthy adult females in their 50 ‘s can anticipate a successful gestation and bringing providing they have modern obstetric observation and monitoring an

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay
View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

are carefully screened. He did note, nevertheless, an addition of pregnancy-associated high blood pressure and gestational diabetes in postmenopausal adult females, and an addition in c-section bringings. This alone is non a sufficient medical ground to exclude all adult females aged 50-60 old ages from entree to IVF. These hazards of complication are highly low when compared to the strength of the desire these adult females have to be female parents ( Lockwood, 2009 ) .

IVF like other medical interventions in which older members of society have limited entree to, due to ageist favoritism. The concluding determination should be down to the person, every bit long as they have evaluated both the hazards and the possible benefits, so a physician should non be restricted from offering the intervention ( Paulson & A ; Sauer, 1994 B ) .

Whilst there is a hazard of increased complication to postmenopausal adult females, this is minimum if the adult female screened and found to be in good wellness. There is no sound medical ground why these adult females should be denied entree to IVF. It is an abuse to the adult females who want this process to presume that they have n’t weighed up the hazards and benefits for themselves. Therefore every bit long as a adult female in her 50 ‘s is healthy and has weighed up the hazards against the benefits I can see no ground why postmenopausal adult females can be denied entree to IVF on these evidences.

Right non to be orphaned

The 2nd major statement voiced by critics is that station menopausal adult females will stop up dyeing at an earlier age in their child life, than those with younger parents ( Park, 1999 ) . The mean life anticipation has increased radically. A century ago, when the mean life anticipation was 40 to 50 old ages, ( Antinori et al. 1993 ) cipher objected to adult females holding kids in their late 20 ‘s. Given that mean life anticipation has increased to 70 to 80 old ages, a healthy adult female in her 50 ‘s allows plentifulness of clip to rise up a kid to maturity ( Paulson & A ; Sauer, 1994a )

The right non to be orphaned is non an statement that is used against the generative rights of younger adult females who have reduced length of service because of medical conditions such as malignant neoplastic disease or chronic nephritic failure, which may merely go forth them 5 – 10 old ages to populate, they are non prohibited from holding kids and are allowed to gestate without disapproval ( Edwards, 1993 ) ( Paulson & A ; Sauer, 1994a ) . Besides adult females with familial upsets which compromise quality of life and or life anticipation may choose for oocyte contribution to seek to forestall the upset being passed to their progeny. Clinics feel that such single are suited campaigners for this type of IVF intervention ( Paulson & A ; Sauer, 1994a ) .

I can non challenge that station menopausal female parents are more likely to decease sooner than their younger opposite numbers, but is it non

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay