Tylenol Case And Ethical Issues Essay

essay B
  • Words: 4544
  • Category: Database

  • Pages: 17

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

It is the responsibility of the concern fraternity to pattern and advance ethical concern patterns to avoid misdemeanor of human rights. This will be demonstrated in the moral behaviour of the direction while transporting out their duties in their several establishments. Ethical consciousness is cardinal and hence should be given precedence. as it is a societal duty in the universe of concern. Corporate administration has besides been on focal point because of increased instances of deceitful activities every bit good as breach of contracts on the portion of concern spouses and other investors.

Good administration and apprehension of concern moralss promotes trust in the senior executives and lead to growing of concern. These are lending factors to strategic planning and better on accomplishments to pull and retain good concern dealingss. Ethical concern patterns serve to pull possible clients and prevent losingss that may come as a consequence of legal colony in a tribunal of jurisprudence. It besides protects a concern from incurring losingss and other disbursals in compensations and other liability issues. ( Clarence and Ronald 1998 ) .

There are of import elements that support concern and this is in footings of qualified forces and ethical leading being practiced at the topographic point of work. This is coupled by ethical decision-making accomplishments that link the concern universe to the society that is being served. Employees are an establishments greatest plus and their concerns and demands should be looked into. Employers and employees should hence understand the demand for their committedness and set all attempts that helps carry through their personal and concern ends and those of the society at big.

The parties should uphold high criterion patterns that comply with the Torahs and ordinances that are set on each concern set-up. A professional codification of moralss is laid down and acts as a guideline to proper behavior. subject and the duties that go with the profession. The behavior of concern operators and the stakeholders is within a certain bound. In this they can put to death their responsibilities without doing any breaks to the workers and the community as a whole.

Assorted operations in a company may take to enforcement of jurisprudence and sometimes may hold condemnable punishments on those that break the jurisprudence. There are federal and province Torahs that have major concerns on safety. condemnable misdemeanor and the position of a company’s concern as a public company. It is of ethical concern that companies should supply a contributing environment for workers every bit good as safety steps put in topographic point.

Good concern patterns is a consequence of combined attempts of professional values and moralss that help to judge and work out issues in an ethical mode with an involvement of the society at bosom and in regard to the profession. The success of a concern does depend on the purposes and aims of the enterpriser but farther more. it is of great importance that the patterns involved are justifiable on an ethical land. ( Clarence and Ronald 1998 ) .

A merchandise for illustration. captures great concern particularly due to the procedures involved every bit good as the concluding merchandise that reaches the market. In production. moralss is an single duty of those that prepare procedure and bring forth the merchandises. The stuffs used. their acquisition and usage in the industry count a batch. The stuffs should be truly sought and acquired through proper minutess. Their quality should be defined and their content should be known. All this is in an attempt to bring forth the really best of the merchandise that reaches the consumer in the market.

It is of import to advert that the criterions of quality are necessary in footings of safety and truth of content and other specification. Quality control is an of import component in bring forthing high criterion of quality. design and industry of the merchandise. . The ethical issues that encompass a merchandise demand to be considered with a batch of acuteness since liability suits or prison footings may originate due to losingss or hurts incurred on the consumers.

This may do a major crisis that a company’s repute and public image may be badly affected. It is hence the responsibility of every individual concerned to transport out their responsibilities and duty that ensures choice criterion merchandises. Any defects should be checked through carry oning topographic point cheques from the production units and this prevents instances of harm. spilling and taint that may do injury to the consumers.

Quality confidence demands careful attending so that safety steps. stuff and quality specifications are realized in the production procedure. It is the moral duty of a company to forestall hurt by supplying merchandises that are non faulty. Merchandises can be rated harmonizing to the quality. content. bundle. value and the ethical patterns involved in production. A merchandise. which is good designed. has good characteristics and good value for the monetary value attracts many clients to purchase and utilize the merchandise. This leads to client satisfaction and finally. client trueness. Such a merchandise is bound to make good every bit long as quality. value and ethical concerns are maintained and much better if the merchandise is improved from clip to clip. ( Jacques. 2002 )

Ethical motives in merchandises and production procedures examine the rules that are used to ensue to the concluding merchandise that goes into the market. It besides looks into analysing and work outing ethical jobs that may come about in a concern environment. Issues about content. usage and inside informations on side effects are given attending. This has been as a consequence of the increased consciousness and demand for ethical merchandises and procedures which has led to increased force per unit areas on industries to bring forth quality and acceptable merchandises.

As a consequence. merchandise codifications of moralss have been given more accent. It is now the societal duty of a company and its employees to take part to the full in bring forthing the best merchandise which poses small of no danger to the clients. If there are any warnings on ingestion of such a merchandise. ample inside informations should be given as side effects. contraindications or any other possible effects associated.

There are merchandises that may do injury and are unsafe when consumed. Tobacco and intoxicant may be habit-forming and be a unsafe merchandise that can take to diseases such as malignant neoplastic disease. ulcers. respiratory upsets and many more. This finally deteriorates the wellness status of the person and risks the normal operation of organic structure systems.

On the other manus production of arms such as bombs. guns and other missiles are besides seen to be unsafe to the life and the environment. Any sort of arm that risks life and being has raised ethical concerns. It is said that adult male is bring forthing substances that are bound to do injury to himself every bit good as to his environment. Environmental concerns are besides addressed in production. There include instances of pollution through C emanations. noise and waste disposal. These are possible menaces to the environmental vegetations and zoologies.

With increased technological promotion came major ethical jobs as is seen in genetically modified nutrients. GMOs have non been embraced good in a huge bulk of spiritual groups and some states. They have protested against the incorporation of human and other carnal cistrons into programs as being unethical and unacceptable to them. It has since been seen as a misdemeanor and maltreatment of natural being of most workss through such scientific finds.

Mobile phones have besides been used to function about every other intent of communicating and have interfered with human interaction and dealingss. The usage of nomadic phones has been relied on and the bond that exists between individuals has been compromised. This has besides been seen in the usage of computing machines and other communicating channels that have reduced intimacy and face to face dealingss of people. Use of research lab animate beings to prove for drug efficaciousness and disposal has been criticized due to the animate being rights misdemeanor and perturbation. Furthermore. usage of mark groups as sample checks for experiments such as drug opposition. disease symptoms. responses and direction is unethical. Ethical rules demand that no injury. hurting or hurt should be subjected to such guiltless animate beings that worlds have used as experimental objects.

When a merchandise has been found to hold any abnormalities and doing injury there may be merchandise liability claims by the complainant. This may be due to negligence that causes defect in design. fabrication and deficiency of inside informations that warn against usage of the merchandise. When a job is anticipated during the procedure of production. it is necessary to rectify the merchandise before it reaches the consumer.

Under rigorous liability. the liability is held on the maker and the consumer recovers through compensation due to any hurt occasioned to him or her. There are factors that are use to warrant one to claiming carelessness. It is cardinal that one is able to proof that a responsibility of attention was owed to him or her. or a breach of that responsibility has occurred and as a consequence hurt has been occasioned on him or her. ( Clarence and Ronald 1998 )

Making a determination on the footing of moralss is nevertheless a critical issue because of the complexness of the issues that presents themselves at the workplace and in the market. This is to intend that it is non ever easy to work out and do determination on issues that need ethical consideration. At some point. scruples may non be a guiding factor to determination doing since thorough. critical and originative analysis of the state of affairs is the finding factor. ( Abraham. 2004 )

This was illustrated in the Johnson & A ; Johnson Tylenol instance in which ethical logical thinking can be examined and analyzed. In this instance. there was cyanide poisoning in excess strength Tylenol capsules that resulted in the decease of three people in Chicago. When the governments were alerted they were able to take action. During this clip the figure rose to seven and this was a cause of dismay to the being and celebrity of the trade name which was a taking hurting stand-in. ( Howard & A ; Smith 2004 )

There were issues that the executives were non informed about since it was non clear if the nitrile was put during the fabrication procedure or subsequently. There was no dependable beginning to happen out if the deceases were the first to be reported and whether they were limited to the Chicago country. The U. S Food and Drug Administration warned against ingestion of the drug while the authorities gave no specific action. In this instance. they thought that local deceases were reported and possibly non more than seven would decease. They considered a impermanent halt in gross revenues which would forestall farther injury.

The executives of the Johnson & A ; Johnson estimated a recall loss of up to $ 100 million. which was non covered by insurance. The callback would besides intend that Tylenol would ne’er recover its public assurance every bit good as its 37 per centum market portion. The intelligence that were heard in the media houses besides would take to a bead in the company’s stock every bit good as rivals being timeserving in the Tylenol’s loss. The fact that the company was non willing to expose the consumers to farther hazard ; Johnson & A ; Johnson had to do a determination and ordered a callback of all Tylenol bottles. ( Howard & A ; Smith 2004 ) ( Clarence and Ronald 1998 ) .

During this first crisis. the company offered to interchange tablets at no excess cost to all its clients. The trade name value deteriorated but the speedy action every bit good as sincere attempts of giving consumer safety by remembering 31 million bottles was a good gesture The company did non trust on the guesss and rumours traveling unit of ammunition and for this ground they opted to do a determination that was worthwhile. Through this the company enjoyed protection from public warfare and it enjoyed good repute through the ethical determination arrived at.

. Ethical issues present themselves otherwise and hence necessitate a consistent attack of bing state of affairs and the options available should be directed towards the good of the consumers and the society. Tylenol went back to its normal place after six months.

The challenge was far from over and the company subsequently faced a major challenge due to deceases which resulted to an overdose of the drug and its side effects. Bad promotion and immense losingss were incurred following all the legal colonies that came due to legal suits. This made the company to do alterations in Tylenols label so that they would include all the side effects in it.

In the 2nd crisis. deceases were reported and terrible liver amendss were linked to over dose of Tylenol. The content was to be highlighted in the J & A ; J’s label and explicitly warning consumers of its side effects. The status was made harsh by the Datril poisoning which found the company with more than 100 suits in a period of 7 old ages. In an attempt to cut down the harm the populace was made aware of the hazard involved every bit good as prescription inside informations for different age groups. Information about side effects on kids would be included in the labels. which besides warned against overdose of the drug. ( Grace. 2003 ) ( Howard & A ; Smith 2004 )

It is hence apparent that in managerial pattern. ethical facets. corporate and single determination devising accomplishments are needed in state of affairss that arise in the workplace.

The Tylenol related statistics have been so annihilating losingss as it still tries to work out the tribunal suits against them but a media wall that does non uncover its immense losingss concealed them. The silence about the inauspicious side effects by the company has led to increased sale of risky drugs and more deadly drugs. It is the societal duty of the company to give every item about all the possible side effects and giving inside informations about their ingestion.

The consumer should be protected because such laxness has been clear grounds that the success of the industry may non be associated to a life salvaging oriented company but one. which performs corrupt concern trades. Sketching the lethal hazard is a right of the consumer so that they are guided. warned or instructed on how to utilize the merchandise. Such information should hence be revealed to possible consumers on a regular basis. ( Jacques. 2002 )

Ethical issues should besides function beyond single involvement of proprietors. stakeholders. employers and clients. Stakeholders are said to hold even rights of administration but others have democratic associations that allow for engagement of the employees and other stakeholders in the company’s operations.

It is nevertheless of import to recognize that ethical issues may differ for companies that operate in different states. If a company exists in two states for illustration. there can be differences in the Torahs of its place state and that in which it is runing. Some Torahs are non enforceable in some states while others may demo laxness in implementing the jurisprudence. . However. a challenge exists since a company could be in a state with less rigorous Torahs or one. which does non prohibit some patterns. Ethical concerns are hence found to be irrelevant in such instances because the company is runing in a foreign land. They should stay to the jurisprudence and esteem the regulation of that state since they are foreign investors and need to follow with the jurisprudence.

For illustration. United States jurisprudence does non let companies to pay payoffs but in other universes. graft is customary. When an investor moves to another state they are bound by the jurisprudence of that state as no changes can be made to accommodate their demand to ethical practicableness. Such contradictions are hard ethical issues to analyse. as is the instance of kid labour which has attracted the attending of great bookmans.

It is nevertheless noted that in really hapless states and those developing states they strain to do a life and kids are subjected to such labour for deficiency of resources. Working hours and environmental protection Torahs are ethical issues that can non be standard in all states. For illustration. there are working states that opt to work for twenty four hours so as to maximise of net incomes. In the same manner industries have to carryout production all twelvemonth round despite the fact that pollution is taking topographic point. Decision doing on concern and its operations requires skilled appraisal and computations that are accomplishable.

Different companies have internal policies that govern the ethical behavior of employees. The statement can be general. wide or may hold specifications on behavioural demands. These are characteristic of a company and supply a guideline on work outing common ethical jobs and heightening consciousness and application of the ethical policies.

Cooperate administration is a guideline that shows the committedness to supervise policy issues and be involved in decision-making. This will later heighten long-run value of the stockholders and the society. Environmental concerns are of ethical consideration since pollution of H2O. air and noise pollution are non acceptable in the environment. Waste disposal is besides a large challenge.

The ethical issue at manus is at some point hard to analyse because the concern directors and CEO’s may non pass their clip worrying about environmental pollution since it’s beyond their control. It becomes more hard because there is no accurate step of what extent is pollution particularly with C emanations and other gases. Waste merchandises have to be disposed but the mere ground that they can non be put into a shop. makes it ethically impractible to avoid dumping them in the environment.

Issues on a merchandise that is needed in the market may raise ethical concerns. One of these would be production of contraceptive method drugs. Harmonizing to some beliefs and traditions. it is against the codification of moralss to bring forth and utilize of preventives. On the manus the demands of the consumers of the drug count it as a benefit to them as compared to unplanned construct for those who do non utilize the drug. ( Jacques. 2002 )

Content of a merchandise may besides convey a point of concern. This is particularly due to the different ethical backgrounds of different traditions in a state and spiritual position. Tea and other stimulations contain caffeine. which many spiritual groups detest. A merchandise like sausages may be controversial on spiritual backgrounds and may really necessitate consistent ethical determination devising before get downing on its production.

Puting up a concern for such a venture needs a critical analysis of the mark groups every bit good as the spiritual background of the people. Other additives that are put in merchandises need to be carefully analyzed and their side effects known. Merchandises such as tegument oils need dermatological proving so that they do non do unsought effects such as bleaching. tegument toning. Markss or more adversely do skin malignant neoplastic disease. ( Ronald. 2004 )

Merchandise moralss besides require that certain districts are observed while selling or utilizing a merchandise. Smoke or ingestion of intoxicant near a spiritual edifice should be discouraged. At the same clip merchandises such as beers should non be sold to immature individuals or those who are anticipant. Warnings which include wellness hazards associated with its ingestion should be clearly indicated. A merchandise that causes injury to the consumers should be withdrawn from the market instantly. The company should seek to counterbalance those affected and seek to reconstruct on their public image one time once more. ( Grace. 2003 ) . ( Clarence and Ronald 1998 )

Companies need to hold their employees go toing seminars. which teach on concern behavior. company policies and other surveies that help them understand on legal demands. It is hence a responsibility of the employer to guarantee continued preparation and development of their employees. Unethical behavior of employees may originate from those who do non back up the corporate policies but instead claim that they require their ain judgement to cover with the issue. ( Jacques. 2002 )

In production. packaging concerns are given precedence heat immune packaging and tamping bar immune devices due to bing fiddling panics. It is besides critical to guard against cabbaging. fiddling during the existent industry. taint. forging utilizing engineering and usage of alone labels. Current issues such as advertisement have raised some ethical concerns. This is because of the extent of advertizement. show and practical exposure on some merchandises particularly on a telecasting screen.

It has been excessively expressed and causes ingestion or purchase of points. which are non needed by kids. This has mostly contributed to the ruin of social moralss and behavior due to luxuriant advertizements. They have possible impacts on kids who watch these advertizements. One of the major challenges is to face the ethical issue as it presents itself. make up one’s minding on the right thing to make and the uncertainness of the action taken.

Bing ethical while carry oning concerns every bit good as smartly being involved in concern net incomes are non target ends in concern apparatuss. Other concern ends and schemes should be adopted so that maximal net incomes can be made.

Product direction can be viewed in footings of monetary value. topographic point. type of merchandise and publicities. A merchandise needs to make a bulk in the market by offering good monetary values. quality. size. colour. form every bit good as transporting out publicity activities to countries where the merchandise has non penetrated. ( Abraham. 2004 )

Packaging should be appropriate and beautifully done harmonizing to the type of merchandise. Due to environmental moralss. the stuff used for packaging should be reclaimable or should be environmentally healthy. Proper instructions about the disposal of the bundle stuff should be good indicated. Proper packaging prevents escape. breakage and protects from any signifier of taint.

Human rights. scientific research and moralss need to be understood in a mode that distinguishes the misdemeanor or promotion and hence demands to be approached good while doing determinations. ( Ronald. 2004 )

Though major accent is placed on moral. societal justness issues and at times democracy. the ethical rules require good determination doing accomplishments that still promote and protect other rights and policies set. Those merchandises that are used or consumed by human existences and animate being require to be decently manufactured with maximal quality and content.

Incase of any side effects the consumers should be made cognizant every bit good as any contraindications included. The curative drug index should be used to look into the lower limit and maximal drug dose so that they can come up with a proper measure that is effectual. Chemical fabrication besides calls for safety of workers and more significantly protection equipments available to them. ( Graema and Newman 2005 )

In Bhopal catastrophe in India. 3000 people perished with 15000 claims of dead individuals in the first month. A pesticide works had released 40 tones of MIC ( methyl isocyanides ) gas killing about 3. 800 people and is seen as universes worst catastrophe in the industries

Other effects are still felt and this includes malignant neoplastic disease. sightlessness and other troubles and related wellness jobs. The works was in dumbly populated countries and after the calamity the demand had fallen. losingss had been incurred and affected its workers. The company had ignored different danger marks with their dismaies non in working order for four old ages. The company nevertheless responded good and helped those who were affected by directing medical experts to salvage the victims. ( Grace. 2003 )

The company followed the legal proceedings to settle suits against them.

There were alterations in the corporate individuality and there was a amalgamation of brotherhood carbide and Dow chemical company. Their major concern was to hold a clean up exercising for all the waste taint in the company environs. It was ethical to hold concerns on the victims. the environment and besides attend instance hearings as agreed.

Ethical concerns on abbestos were besides looked in to due to malignant neoplastic disease caused on lungs. kidney and voice box. Different states banned its supply in to their states and this included Canada. France. and the UK controlled managing due to the nexus of exposure and attendant decease. Those that understand the danger of such a merchandise should be acute to maintain their distance. protect themselves and their kids so that they are safe.

Since bar is better than remedy. persons working in such companies need to take attention of the kids and colleague’s who are exposed to the dangers. Ethical planning and considerations should be made to do certain that such accidents do non take topographic point in the hereafter. Adequate safeguard. safety equipment and flight paths should be provided so that incase of such a catastrophe. those who run can salvage their lives.

If a policy is set. so a company may hold concern for victims. merchandise damages and other alterations and purposes at supplying merchandises without farther defect.


The ethical issues environing Tylenol instance is seen by the extended losingss incurred in remembering the merchandise and besides compensation and legal proceeding. The of import factor here is the consumer who should hold quality merchandises at all times.

It is an single and corporate attempt to keep the ethical criterions in merchandises and services. The ethnics’ officer and the direction should adhere to quality and other specifications.

In pattern. good on the job conditions. employment footings. safety equipment and societal demands of the employees need to be provided. It is besides necessary to guarantee good and friendly supervising. This can be demonstrated through quality leading manners to all employees.

Business moralss and administration are cardinal facets that control the concern patterns. They need to be enforced and adopted so that quality of merchandises ensures client satisfaction.

It is of import to analyse the bing state of affairs and exert decision-making options to outdo suit the consumers. society or the other parties involved.

Expert judgement may besides be needed and in such a instance an moralss officer may be used. Customer trueness is built on the assurance of the merchandise. the quality produced and the proper content used to do the concluding merchandise. ( Abraham. 2004 )

The direction and its employees can pattern corporate administration through their single committedness to safeguarding the company’s image and corporate behaviour. ( Ronald. 2004 )

Proper guidelines on doing a determination should be laid down so that as jobs arise. they are solved and amicably improved.

Research attempts have been conducted and they all aim to separate companies with quality attention and product’s equal information. Further research on side effects is shown in their labels as this may compromise the wellness position of an person. Through research on possible wellness conditions of those that consume the merchandise. analysis about their disposal and direction are shown suitably and harmonizing to age and gender. ( Jacques. 2002 )


Abraham. L. G. . ( 2004 ) . The Importance of Leadership and Power Beard Books

Clarence C. W. Ronald F. D. . ( 1998 ) . Education. Leadership. and Business Ethical motives: Essaies on the Work of Clarence: Springer Publishers

Grace. B. ( 2003 ) . Unequal Health: How Inequality Contributes To Health Or Illness. Rowman & A ; Little Field Publishers.

Smith M. S. & A ; Howard. A. . ( 2004 ) . Rivers of blood: consecutive slayers and their victims’ . Universal Publications

Jacques. C. ( 2002 ) . Activist Business Ethical motives: Springer Publishers.

Ronald. D. S. . ( 2004 ) Strategic Planning For Public Relations. Routledge Publishers

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member