Short Story Comparison Essay

essay A

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

After reading “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst and “Raymond’s Run” by Toni Cade Bambara. there are some similarities and differences that stood out. Both narratives include handicapped brothers. Besides. both narratives include characters that act out of pride. The narratives have different scenes and have characters with different motivations. The chief lesson of this essay is non to allow plume take over your character.

There are a few similarities the two narratives portion. First. both narratives involve a character with disablements. In “The Scarlet Ibis” Doodle’s disablements are described. “The physician said he mustn’t acquire to excited. excessively hot. excessively cold. or excessively tired and that he must ever be treated gently. A long list of don’ts went with him…” In “Raymond’s Run” Squeaky describes Raymond. “But as any sap can see he’s much bigger and he’s older excessively. But a batch of people call him my small brother cause he needs looking after cause he’s non rather right. ” These two quotation marks show a similarity in the two narratives by explicating the disablements with each character. Doodle and Raymond. Another similarity the two narratives portion has to make with pride. In both narratives. the chief character’s actions are derived from pride.

In “Raymond’s Run” Squeaky explains. “There is no path meet that I don’t win the first topographic point medal…The large childs name me quicksilver cause I’m the swiftest thing in the neighborhood…In the first topographic point. no 1 can crush me and that’s all there is to it. ” In “The vermilion Ibis” the storyteller explains. “When scribble was five old ages old. I was embarrassed at holding a brother of that age who couldn’t walk. so I set out to learn him…I did non cognize so that pride is a fantastic. awful thing. a seed that bears two vines. life and decease. ” These two quotation marks show us a similarity because they explain how both characters act and feel they manner they do because of pride. As you can see. there are some similarities the two narratives portion.

In add-on to similarities. the narratives are besides different. First. the scenes are different and have different affects on the narratives. In “The Scarlet Ibis” . the scene is more country-like ; “…Someone to roost with at the top fork of the great pine behind the barn where across the Fieldss and swamps where you can see the sea. ” In contrast. “Raymond’s Run” has a scene in the metropolis ; “I’m standing on the corner look up toing the conditions and about to take a amble down Broadway so I can pattern my external respiration exercisings. and I’ve got Raymond walking on the interior near to the buildings…” These two quotation marks show a difference in the narratives by explicating how different the scenes are. Since there are different scenes. each scene has its ain tone and affects the manner we feel about the narratives and pride. Following. there is a difference in the manner the two narratives represent pride.

In “Raymond’s Run” Squeaky is frequently sort to Raymond. and helps him for his interest. In the choice Squeaky explains. “All I have to make in my life is mind my brother Raymond. which is enough…But a batch of people call him my small brother cause he needs looking after cause he’s non rather right. ” In “The Scarlet Ibis” the storyteller explains why he helps his brother ; “When Doodle was five old ages old. I was embarrassed at holding a brother of that age who couldn’t walk. so I set out to learn him. ” These two quotation marks exemplify a difference because they explain why each character acts the manner they do. It explains that Squeaky helps Raymond because he needs it and explains that the storyteller merely helps Doodle for his ain pride. In decision. there are a few thoughts that separate the two short narratives.

After reading these two narratives. I learned a really of import life lesson. This lesson was non to allow your ain pride return over your character. Although there were different ways of demoing it. the lesson was one that every homo should seek to populate up to.

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member
unlock