The people you interact in your live influences who you become. In Budge Wilson's short story "The Metaphor" two characters named 'Miss Hancock' and 'Charlottes Mother' are both important role models for Charlotte, who is the main character. These women have very different personalities, with a few similarities.
Miss Hancock and Charlotte's mother have a few similarities. One characteristic is that they are both important role models in Charlotte's life. At school, Charlotte idolizes Miss Hancock. At home Charlotte doesn't idolize her mother like she does for her teacher, but she is an important figure all the same. Charlotte's personality blooms off of both. She is in love with literature; but she also shares the neat and controlling trait from her mother, when she cleaned after herself immediately in the kitchen after she made herself a meal (p 64
...). Another similarity that Miss Hancock and Charlotte's Mother share is that they are both working women. They are around the same age, eccentric and independent.
Besides their similarities, Miss Hancock and Charlottes mother are so different that they contrast each other. Miss Hancock is unmarried woman who encourages Charlotte to be expressive. On the other hand, Charlotte’s Mother doesn’t support or care much about Charlotte’s enthusiasm for the subject. As a child, playing with toys wasn’t allowed because it made a mess “A toy ceased to be a toy once it left the toy cupboard” (p 65). Miss Hancock loves teaching children, so if she were Charlotte’s mother, she would tell her to make as much of a mess as she wants. Miss Hancock and Charlotte’s mother are an example of character foil.
Based on Budge Wilson's descriptions, these
women look nothing alike. Miss Hancock dressed exuberantly. She would wear "Colorful beaded and embroidered blouses", and her makeup could "... keep a student interested for half an hour if she or he were bored with a grammar assignment" (p 65). In the story, Charlotte's Mother liked to keep the house clean and spotless. Her hair and makeup is conservative and put together. In Charlotte's metaphor for her mother, she described her as "flawless", whereas Miss Hancock was described as a "cake frosted by someone unschooled in the art of cake decoration" (p 80). They look like two completely different people.
Aside from personality or looks, the influence they have on Charlotte is unalike. In the story, Miss Hancock is a better mother than Charlotte's own biological mother. She educates Charlotte to express herself through literature. Charlotte's Mother, however, ridicules Miss Hancock. She calls her "Overdone, too much enthusiasm. Flamboyant. Orange Hair." (p 71), which squashes what her daughter loves and enjoys in her teacher. She didn't understand why Charlotte was so devastated when Miss Hancock died, and told her she was not being sensible. Miss Hancock was actually the one who showed concern and asked Charlotte questions after Charlotte's first metaphor.
Miss Hancock and Charlotte's Mother share a few things in common, but are very different. They are important role models in Charlotte's life. Although they are strong, contrasting characters, the influence they have on Charlotte will last forever.
- American Literature essays
- Between The World and Me essays
- Book Report essays
- Book Review essays
- Book Summary essays
- Books essays
- Character essays
- Coming of Age essays
- Dante's Inferno essays
- Everyday Use essays
- Flowers for Algernon essays
- Genre essays
- Greek Mythology essays
- Incidents in The Life of a Slave Girl essays
- Letter essays
- Literary Criticism essays
- Literary devices essays
- Literature Review essays
- Metaphor essays
- Myth essays
- Play essays
- Plot essays
- Poem essays
- Poetry Analysis essays
- Protagonist essays
- Reader essays
- Reason essays
- Rhetoric essays
- Rhetorical Question essays
- Rhyme essays
- Simile essays
- Tragic Hero essays
- Translation essays
- Understanding essays
- Utopia essays
- Villain essays
- Writer essays