In his book Leonardo's Sfumato, Alexander Nagel begins with a French quote by Paul Valery that emphasizes the significance of Leonardo da Vinci's work in guiding our spiritual practice and attention towards the ideas he transmitted. Leo Steinberg shares Nagel's perspective on the study of Leonardo's art.
Steinberg and Nagel both emphasize the importance of thorough examination and meticulous attention to detail in art. They also share an understanding of the significance of the relationship between art and ambiguity. Steinberg views ambiguity not only as multiple meanings and moments condensed within Leonardo's work, but also as a determining factor of the entire mural, from the structure of space to each individual painterly mark. The key question is whether this ambiguity is a deliberate feature planned by the artist or a property of interpretation and critics' analysis. In his essay "Critique of Formalism," Stein
...berg suggests that when approaching unfamiliar art practices, critics should hold their criteria and taste in reserve since these were formed upon yesterday's art and may not be suitable for today's art.
According to Steinberg, comprehending the objectives of new art should not exclude or judge anything as irrelevant. He believes that understanding art is a process, and that studying ambiguity rewards us the most. Nagel investigates Leonardo da Vinci's accomplishments through his article titled "Leonardo's Sfumato". The term sfumato points to an uncertainty in the relationship between objects' actual properties and the visual aspects they present to the eye. This uncertainty describes the ambiguity within the painting technique, blending tones and colors in imperceptible gradations, and producing softness and delicacy.
In this article, Alexander Nagel examines the practical and theoretical foundations of sfumato and
evaluates its implications. Sfumato mainly involves how shadows affect object perception. According to Leonardo, "shadow is the means by which bodies and their forms are displayed."4 Therefore, using shadows became crucial in visual perception.
Leonardo's study on shadows revealed his comprehension of painting with vagueness and lack of clarity. He stated that it is not advisable to make transferred work shadows definite or clear as it may result in a wooden appearance. For drawing a figure in sfumato, Leonardo described it as "neither part of the body nor part of the air surrounding that body". Nagel asserts that this ambiguous style of drawing and absence of definition was a technique Leonardo sought to perfect and master.
Leonardo da Vinci painted Madonna of the Carnation in Florence, Italy in 1478, showcasing his examination of sfumato. A reflection of Leonardo's early artistry, the painting manifests his adeptness in composition and painting techniques. The sacred characters interact with each other in a moving and balanced manner. The Madonna, portrayed in modern apparel, shares a flower with her son. Both the flower and the crucifix in the child's hand symbolize the beginning and end of Christ's life, implying the flower signifies his birth while the crucifix represents his demise on the cross.
This painting showcases one of Leonardo's unique traits - his exploration of shadow and sfumato. By ingeniously manipulating shadows, the painting's light source seems to originate from a heavenly place above the viewer's shoulder. Mother and child are depicted with halos, denoting their purity and divinity. The Virgin's face is round and radiant, similar to his previous pieces.
Leonardo's work was unique compared to that of his
contemporaries, as demonstrated by the winsome and fresh expression of the Madonna depicted in his paintings. One such painting is the Portrait of a Musician, an oil on wood composition created in Milan, Italy in 1490. Notably, this is the only portrait of a man that Leonardo ever painted. The subject stands in a three-quarter stance while grasping a partition sheet, with the background left in shadow and the musician gazing beyond the audience's view. Once again, Leonardo expertly incorporates shadow into his work.
The musician appears to be looking towards an unknown light source, as evidenced by the shadows behind them. The artist pays meticulous attention to facial bone structure, resulting in a highly detailed depiction of the model's face. The shadows enhance the musician's facial lines and overall complexion. In contrast, the tunic, red hat, and hair are portrayed as unremarkable and lacking in vibrance.
Using sfumato, the viewer's attention is drawn to the subject's face in the 1485 painting Lady with an Ermine by Leonardo da Vinci. The painting features Cecilia Gallerani, who was the mistress of the Duke of Milan, and shows a background shrouded in shadow as Leonardo explored light and ambiguity. The Renaissance painter employed geometric proportions and the mathematical principles of ancient Greeks, typical in his art. Notably, the painting design lacks any straight lines.
The woman's portrait is comprised of predominantly curved lines, which guide the viewer's gaze from her head, downwards and to the right, across the ermine and back up towards the opposite sleeve. The sinuous form of the animal imitates the woman's movements as she appears to contort in space. The
graceful curve of her hand mirrors that of the ermine's raised paw, while her wrist, bent at an angle, perfectly corresponds with the animal's motion. The sole exceptions to these undulating lines are the rectangular neckline of her dress and the band adorning her head.
In Leonardo's art piece, there exists a synergistic connection between animal and human, depicted through their interlocked movements. This symbiosis gives rise to a rhythmic composition that animates both forms. The presence of the ermine in the painting holds multiple meanings. It may be a representation of high social status, owing to the association of ermines with aristocracy. Alternatively, it can be interpreted as a symbol of purity and chastity. The Lady with an Ermine is a remarkable work of art that oozes sophistication and showcases Leonardo's artistic brilliance.
Leonardo da Vinci's artwork displays the use of sfumato and ambiguous lines and shapes, contributing to his reputation as a highly esteemed philosopher and artist. Despite the ongoing debate and study surrounding his genius, Leonardo's art remains some of the most critiqued and appreciated forms of art both during his time and today. However, it is universally acknowledged that Leonardo's work will never be fully understood or appreciated, serving as the main reason why his artistry continues to impress critics and students alike.
- First person essays
- American Literature essays
- Between The World and Me essays
- Book Report essays
- Book Review essays
- Book Summary essays
- Books essays
- Character essays
- Coming of Age essays
- Dante's Inferno essays
- Everyday Use essays
- Flowers for Algernon essays
- Genre essays
- Greek Mythology essays
- Incidents in The Life of a Slave Girl essays
- Letter essays
- Literary Criticism essays
- Literary devices essays
- Literature Review essays
- Metaphor essays
- Myth essays
- Play essays
- Plot essays
- Poem essays
- Poetry Analysis essays
- Protagonist essays
- Reader essays
- Reason essays
- Rhetoric essays
- Rhetorical Question essays
- Rhyme essays
- Simile essays
- Tragic Hero essays
- Translation essays
- Understanding essays
- Utopia essays
- Villain essays
- Writer essays
- Aldous Huxley essays
- Alice Walker essays
- Amy tan essays
- Anne Bradstreet essays
- Anton Chekhov essays
- Arthur Miller essays
- Augustine essays
- Bertolt Brecht essays
- Booker T Washington essays
- Carol ann duffy essays
- Charles Dickens essays
- Charlotte Perkins Gilman essays