The objective of this study is to show the relationship between experiencing separation from parents and having learning disabilities or difficulties in children in a community based sample. In this study the children who were studied were separated from parents for varying reasons. These reasons ranged from divorce, parental illness, adversities, and child welfare issues (where the child is placed in foster care or with other family members). The researchers in this study tested how parental separation affects the learning potential of children. Analysis of Learning Disabilities among Children
While analyzing the study done by A. Jee, S.H., Conn, K. M., Nilsen, W. J. Szilagyi, M. A., and et al. one must consider each author’s educational background and qualification, the he or she must research and validate the methods and results. Once all is validated one can discuss
...his or her views on the subject matter at hand. Author Qualifications
Dr. Sandra H. Jee, M.D., M.P.H. primary area of study is disparities for underserved children. She works mainly with psychosocial issues for children, and health needs for children in foster care. Her current research interests include children in the child welfare system and mental health needs for children in foster care. In the past she has received funds for data collection studies examining quality of care and devotion to clinical standards in foster care to conduct data analysis using samples to study child welfare issues. Dr. Jee has experience as a diagnostician for fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and she has been an invited keynote speaker for local and statewide topics (Jee, 2009).
Dr. Wendy J. Nilsen is a practicing “clinical child psychologist” who graduated with her doctorate fro
Purdue University (Nilsen, 2009). Dr. Nilsen’s research is primarily on help for children and families involved in the court system (Nilsen, 2009). She “engaged in the child welfare system and domestic violence court” (Nilsen, 2009). Her clinical efforts include working with “children, adolescents, and their families” (Nilsen, 2009).
. Dr. Moria Ann Szilagyi, M.D., Ph.D is nationally recognized for her work in foster care health (Szilagyi, 2009). Dr. Szilagyi edited the national health care standards: “Fostering Health: ‘Health Care for Children and Adolescents in Foster Care’ published by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).” (Szilayi, 2009). Dr. Szilagyi is vice Chair of the Healthy Foster Care America Coalition and the Task Force on Foster Care of the Averican Academy of Pediatrics Association, the Child Welfare League of America, and the National Association of Family Court Judges in shaping the national foster care agenda. (Szilagyi, 2009). Dr. Szilagyi “funded research focuses on improving comprehensive primary care for children in foster care and enhancing timely identification and appropriate management of behavioral and mental health conditions for children and youth foster care” (Szilagyi, 2009).
Dr. Emma L. Jones Forbes earned her MA and PhD in Clinical Psychology at the University of Rochester and BA in Psychology at Barnard College and practices psychology in Rochester, NY (Forbes-Jones, 2009). Dr. Jill Suzanne Halterman, M.D., M.P.H.’s primary interests include: “asthma and improving the quality of care” (J. S. M.D. M.P.H., 2009). Dr. Halterman is currently participating in four projects. The first project is Asthma and prematurity intervention. The second is preschool and school-based asthma screening programs. The third is office-based asthma screening programs, and the last is pilot work to reduce secondhand smoke
exposure.
Considering the extent of each of the researcher’s educational background and the experience each has with research one is lead to think that these researchers are more than qualified to produce a valid research project. Methods
“The data was obtained through a cross-sectional survey of children entering kindergarten in 2003 in the Rochester city School District in Rochester, New York. All parents or caregivers of children entering kindergarten complete a detailed s health and developmental survey called the Parent’s Appraisal of Children’s Experiences (PACE) Survey” (Jee, et al., 2008). This survey was used to screen parental perspectives to include: the child’s skills in different areas, health status, family situations, and other experiences. The analysis was limited to children between ages four and six at the time the survey was done.
The parents or caregivers were asked to complete the PACE survey to help the school district assess the needs of the children, and the survey was part of the enrollment process. The response rate of this study was 80% among 1619 children (Jee et al., 2008). This survey included “demographic data about participation in preschool and day care programs, general health information, and assessment of the child’s development skills in a variety of areas” (Jee et al., 2008).
“Cross-sectional research involves the comparison of two or more groups of participants during the same, rather limited time span” (Smith& Davis, 2010). This type of research allows the researcher to examine a test group that shares certain characteristic such as educational level. In this study, cross-sectional research fit quite well. Results
According to the study, the sample included 1619 children with a response rate of 80%. The mean age was 5.1
years, and 51% were boys. Also according to the study, 16% of the children were white, 61% were African American, and 23% were Latino. The study stated that nearly 60% were Medicaid recipients, and 65% had a mother who had completed at least a high school degree (Jee et al., 2008). According to the results, it was noted that the children experienced increased learning difficulties during times when they were dealing with parental separation, when compared to children who did not experience parental separation (Jee et al., 2008). It is also reported that children who were separated for shorter periods of time experienced some difficulties, but they became more pronounced after two months of separation (Jee et al., 2008). Discussion
This study shows that separation from parents is common in many urban settings; however does it show that there is a common link between parental separations and learning difficulties? Although these researchers are thoroughly qualified scientists they have and are capable of producing valid proof, their research may not have proven their hypothesis. Although parental separation may be a factor for learning difficulties there may be other factors which may cause these difficulties.
In conclusion, when analyzing the works of a researcher there are many factors to consider. One must first wonder about his or her qualifications then research his or her methods and results and validate the findings. Once all of that has been done one is able to discuss all factors involved.
- Anatomy and Physiology essays
- Addiction essays
- Biodegradation essays
- Dental Care essays
- Disease essays
- Disorders essays
- Health Care essays
- Intelligence Quotient essays
- Nutrition essays
- Olfaction essays
- Public Health essays
- Women's Health essays
- World health organization essays
- Cancer essays
- Infectious Disease essays
- Lung Cancer essays
- Neurology essays
- Physical Exercise essays
- Medicine essays
- Sex essays
- Inquiry essays
- Disability essays
- Poison essays
- Action Potential essays
- Nervous System essays
- Childbirth essays
- Puberty essays
- Blood essays
- Kidney essays
- Neuron essays
- Body essays
- Glucose essays
- Sense essays
- Heart essays
- Skeleton essays
- Human Physiology essays
- Eye essays
- Immune System essays
- Muscle essays
- Skin essays
- Brain essays
- Central Nervous System essays
- Human Skin Color essays
- Digestive System essays
- Common sense essays
- Respiration essays
- alcoholism essays
- Smoking essays
- Casino essays
- Tobacco essays