A Minor’s Right to Confidentiality

essay A

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

In August of 1996 Congress passed the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act ( HIPAA ) patients began to see an betterment in the entree and consistence of the wellness insurance coverage. It was non until April 14. 2003 that the privateness part was passed protection personal wellness information. Many provinces have single Torahs that were already in topographic point to protect the wellness information of patients. HIPAA was non intended to extinguish the province jurisprudence but to cover that which was non addressed by province Torahs. The province jurisprudence will predominate supplying it is more rigorous than the HIPAA policy. In general. the passing of the HIPAA gave patients extra information and greater entree to personal medical information while protecting that same information from inappropriate revelation. Some of the protected information that has raised controversial concerns is sing a minor’s right to privateness and parental entree.

Minor’s Rights versus Parental Rights

HIPAA regulations regulate the authorised persons that lawfully can obtain a person’s private wellness information. HIPAA recognizes parents and defenders as “personal representatives. ” which permits mandate and entree as appropriate with the ordinances. The guidelines provide that individual that has legal authorization over another grownup or emancipated minor shall be considered the personal representative and afforded such authorization as relevant to the jurisprudence. The 2nd portion references unemancipated bush leagues and parents or defenders. shall be regarded as personal representation and give the appropriate authorization for determinations sing a patients PHI ( Mary Beth Kirven & A ; Daniel J. Hall. 2003 ) . There are exclusions as with any regulations and those exclusions are as follows:

1. The minor consents to such wellness attention service ; no other consent to such wellness attention service is required by jurisprudence. regardless of whether the consent of another individual has besides been obtained ; and the child has non requested that such individual be treated as the personal representative. 2. The child may legitimately obtain such wellness attention service without the consent of a parent. guardian or other individual moving in balmy parentis. and the child. a tribunal. or another individual authorized by jurisprudence consents to such wellness attention service. 3. A parent. guardian. or other individual moving in balmy parentis acquiescences to an understanding of confidentiality between a covered wellness attention supplier and the minor with regard to such wellness attention service ( Mary Beth Kirven & A ; Daniel J. Hall. 2003 ) .

These exclusions provide for a minor. the ability to maintain merely specific wellness information as confidential from any person which the child chooses. In the province of Michigan. this information is protected merely if for intervention of gestation. HIV or genital disease and substance maltreatment ( FindLaw. 2011 ) . Benefits could be made by adding contraceptive method to the protected information in the HIPAA policy every bit good in an attempt to protect bush leagues that reside in provinces that have no Torahs or public policy that address such issues. Teenss have a right to hide medical information merely sing gestation or infection of a sexually familial disease or actively addicted to drugs. which will so let the privilege of privateness. This teaches adolescents that hapless determination devising will be rewarded with the chance to do more determinations.

Promiscuous Adolescent Behavior

Since the early 1970’s adolescent sexual activity has been in the public oculus. the existent rate of activity had non changed. it merely become more obvious. The mean age of matrimony was increasing along with the estimated life anticipation. The population was merely waiting longer to acquire married but non waiting to hold sex. The media have placed these subjects to the forepart of this state with the assorted narratives that seem to romanticize both sex and adolescent gestation. The United States is a state that has sex everyplace. most amusement media and many selling tools use gender to pull the consumer and sell the merchandises.

Society needs instruction and handiness to counter balance the exposure that is forced upon them from sellers in an attempt to maintain the sexual content to a lower limit and to hold the ability to see beyond the sexual nature of the existent products’ utilizations and its benefits’ . Guess is that the consciousness created through these controversial telecasting series ( Teen Mom. 16 and pregnant ) has contributed to the lessening in adolescent gestation. Harmonizing to Women’s Health and Health Care Reform. “The United States continues to hold the highest adolescent gestation rate of developed states ( Chavkin. Rosenbaum. Jones & A ; Rosenfield. 2010 ) . ” The option is that striplings may experience more comfy with the ability to obtain appropriate supplies and instruction. both of which have become more accessible because of province and federal Torahs.

Legal Webs

Unfortunately. a recent effort was made by Indiana Republican Representative Mike Pence. offering an amendment to extinguish the Title X plan. This “Pence Bill” is an effort to forestall plans such as Planned Parenthood from obtaining federal financess for any ground ( Miller. LaVaute & A ; Heritage Media. 2011 ) . The primary focal point of this amendment was the usage of pro-life tax-payers money to fund and promote abortion. A argument over this is still ongoing now at the national degree. yet here locally there are still wellness clinics supplying the necessary services to many striplings. including antenatal attention when needed ( Miller. LaVaute & A ; Heritage Media. 2011 ) . The contention over the abortion service is the chief factor in the effort to take the support. “According to Planned Parenthood. abortions that are performed in its clinics make up less than 3 per centum of its services. There were 332. 278 abortion processs performed in 2009. There were besides 830. 000 chest test. and about 4 million were tested and/or treated for sexually transmitted diseases ( Miller. LaVaute & A ; Heritage Media. 2011 ) . ”

Public Policy

Public policy is the lone protections that striplings have to depend on. It will let protection from both diseases and unwanted gestation. and this is limited to merely specific bush leagues in the State of Michigan. HIPAA does non pre-empt this policy as it is more rigorous in some provinces than the HIPAA jurisprudence. this is one restriction to the policy. An extract in the Guttmacher Institute study on public policy indicates. “Although the populace remains ambivalent. professional organisations familiar with the scientific grounds uniformly back up the proviso of generative wellness attention to bush leagues on a confidential footing. Public policy developments at the province and federal degree. nevertheless. suggest that teenagers’ entree to confidential services will stay under onslaught in the months and old ages to come ( 2005 ) . ”


History has proven that kids will go on to hold sex and contract disease and go pregnant ; hence Torahs protecting the privateness of generative wellness can really decrease the barriers and increase entree to protection for many patients. Planned Parenthood has played an intricate function in supplying entree to instruction and protection for 1000000s of striplings. Removing the support for plans such as this besides reduces entree to instruction. intervention and supplies. ensuing in increased diseases and additions in unwanted gestations that later lead to a higher poorness rate. Ideally abstention is the preferable method to forestall unwanted gestation and disease. nevertheless. world shows that this is by and large non the adept method. Protection for striplings is needed in all societies to advance duty and growing for every person. It is a mature and responsible determination to prosecute the protection and instruction that is needed even when entree is limited. Laws are passed to protect world. non grownups or parents or any one population ; Torahs are created to protect any individual that needs protecting. including bush leagues.

Chavkin. W. . Rosenbaum. S. . Jones. J. . & A ; Rosenfield. A. ( 2010 ) . Women’s wellness and wellness attention reform [ The cardinal function of comprehensive generative wellness attention ] . Retrieved from
hypertext transfer protocol: //www. mailmanschool. org/facultypubs/womenshealthcarereform. pdf FindLaw. ( 2011 ) . Michigan medical records jurisprudence. Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //law. findlaw. com/state-laws/minors-and-the-law/michigan/ . hypertext transfer protocol: //law. findlaw. com/state-laws/minors-and-the-law/michigan/ Guttmacher Institute. ( 2005. November ) . Teenagers’ entree to confidential generative wellness services [ The Guttmacher study on public policy ] . Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. guttmacher. org/pubs/tgr/08/4/gr080406. hypertext markup language Mary Beth Kirven. E. . & A ; Daniel J. Hall. ( 2003. June ) . Health insurance portability and answerability act of 1996 [ Applicability to the tribunals: an initial appraisal ] . Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. ncsconline. org/WC/Publications/CS_PriPubHIPPA96Pub. pdf Miller. J. . LaVaute. G. . & A ; Heritage Media. ( 2011. March ) . Washtenaw county: Young and pregnant [ Part 1: Prevention ] . Retrieved from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. heritage. com/articles/2011/03/01/life/doc4d6d5ec57105e610360187. txt? viewmode=fullstory

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member