James Fils-Aime The Handmaid's Tale Fact or Fiction
The Handmaid's Tale is a dystopian novel that presents an apparently absurd and implausible world. It illustrates the enslavement of women for reproduction, religious cult-like control over the population, and the expulsion of an entire race. Despite seeming fictional, these aspects are actually based on real-life events and historical precedents. Atwood incorporates both historical occurrences and societal/political trends from the 1980s to create the society of Gilead. Through referencing politics and history, Atwood shows that Gilead was not as unrealistic as it initially seems. She specifically examines Colonial America, which had a religious foundation and functioned as a theocratic society in the 1700s.
The Puritans, seeking religious freedom, migrated from Europe to establish their society in the Americas. New England specifically lacked religious freedom and imposed cou
...rt punishments on individuals who did not adhere to the prevailing religious requirements. Non-Christians were regarded as heathens, and the societal rules imposed by the male leaders were influenced by their biblical interpretations.
The text suggests that early Puritans believed they were chosen by God to govern the country according to Biblical principles, while later on their control diminished. However, in the South, the enslavement of and racism towards black individuals persisted. In both cases, male leaders in society promoted injustice and oppression for their own benefit. Margaret Atwood's novel also touches on issues of race, illustrating how those who didn't conform to a specific form of Christianity or had a different skin color were sent to the colonies or killed. In the novel, the "children of Ham," representing black descendants according to the Bible, are relocated outside of Gilead. Furthermore, Gilead's setting resembles
early America, particularly Boston, Massachusetts, known as a center for Puritans.
In Atwood's novel, the society of Gilead is portrayed as a world controlled by men who crave power, employing religion as a tool for control. Atwood draws attention to the oppression of Jews during the Holocaust within her narrative. During Hitler's reign, approximately 6 million Jews lost their lives, while numerous others were subjected to mistreatment in concentration camps at the hands of their captors. In The Handmaid's Tale, Jewish individuals were relocated to reside outside the boundaries of Gilead.
The Gilead colonies were akin to the concentration camps of WWII, imprisoning individuals who either opted or were coerced into inhabiting deplorable conditions. Both societies also dehumanized homosexuals. In the fictitious Republic of Gilead, homosexuals frequently faced execution and were displayed on the Wall. Similarly, during WWII, Hitler commanded the extermination of all homosexuals.
Atwood includes references in her book to illustrate the widespread prevalence of extreme oppression. Through these references, she cautions readers about the potential and existing realities of such oppression. The Handmaid's Tale was penned during the Reagan era, wherein the novel subtly hints at Reagan's influence on America. With his assumption of office in 1981, Reagan initiated a shift towards conservatism in the nation.
Reagan emphasized the importance of families embracing traditional roles and openly expressing his religious beliefs to Americans. He urged Congress to ensure that children could engage in voluntary prayers in schools, just as Congress starts each session with an opening prayer. The religious right fully supported Reagan's position, desiring a return to traditional values after the morally permissive decades of the 60s and 70s. They longed for a society centered
on faith, reminiscent of early American history, particularly the puritanical era. Conservative members of the Republican party even actively opposed legislation promoting gender equality. In 1980, opposition from Republicans contributed to the failure of ratifying the Equal Rights Amendment, causing it to lose support. Reagan strongly believed that religion and morals should form the foundation of a great nation.
In Gideon, religion is depicted as a tool used by commanders to suppress women and establish a better society under their control. Simultaneously, the United States continued its ongoing involvement in Middle Eastern affairs.
Women's rights in countries like Afghanistan, Iran, and Saudi Arabia were gaining global attention due to the harsh treatment they were enduring. This prompted women worldwide to become more aware of their struggles. In September 1996, a Pakistani court ruled that women could not marry without guardian approval. Saudi Arabian women face even stricter limitations as they are prohibited from driving or participating in government affairs. Religion is often used to oppress women in these nations, demonstrated by a religious cleric condemning any opposition to male guardianship as an affront to God's teachings and advocating punishment against those responsible. Margaret Atwood was well-informed about the obstacles faced by women in certain countries.
In various nations, women are solely esteemed for their capacity to bear children. In the society of Gilead, the most highly prized aspect of existence is the ability to deliver a healthy child without abnormalities. Offred gains greater awareness of the plight faced by these women when she overheard a conversation: "Go to the colonies," Rita suggested, "They have the choice. With the unwomen, and starve to death and Lord knows
what all?" replied Cora (pg13). Women who were unable to conceive were not regarded as true women and were sent away to live in dreadful conditions. The events portrayed in the book strongly reflect this historical era.
Both the attempt to assassinate Reagan and the government-sanctioned killings depicted in the book serve to highlight how society can dangerously resemble Gilead, and how easily significant changes can occur. Reagan supported bringing prayer back into schools as a way to strengthen the nation's connection with God. He stated, "Prayer has been a source of support during times of crisis, a source of empowerment during challenges, and a guiding force in our daily lives since the early settlers arrived on this continent. Our ancestors did not come here solely for riches, but mainly for God and the freedom to worship in their own way" (5). The handmaids were required to participate in prayers and subjected to ceremonies known as "prayvaganzas," where they were married off. Religion was imposed on these women as a means of maintaining their submission.
Atwood's intention in writing The Handmaid's Tale was to highlight the potential consequences of extreme conservative beliefs if no action is taken to promote equality. By examining the book, its historical context, and current society, we can see the negative social patterns discussed by Atwood. She wrote in this manner to emphasize the need for change. The world is not as far removed from the dystopian society of Gilead as many might think, therefore it is up to the reader to determine their role in preventing these conditions from arising and ultimately reversing them.
Bibliography:
"Reagan, Ronald W(ilson)," Microsoft Encarta Online Encyclopedia 2004
accessed on: December 30 2005
- Euthanasia essays
- Assisted Suicide essays
- Censorship essays
- Gun Control essays
- Empowerment essays
- Civil Rights essays
- Capital Punishment essays
- Death Penalty essays
- Human Trafficking essays
- Sex Trafficking essays
- Gay Marriage essays
- Affirmative Action essays
- Child Labour essays
- Privacy essays
- Speech essays
- Child Protection essays
- Corporal Punishment essays
- Police Brutality essays
- Gun essays
- Death Penalty Pros And Cons essays
- Is The Death Penalty Effective essays
- The victim essays
- Public Speaking essays
- Freedom Of Speech essays
- Free Speech essays
- Persuasive Speech essays
- Gettysburg Address essays
- Informative Speech essays
- Puritans essays
- Afterlife essays
- Buddhism essays
- Christianity essays
- Deism essays
- Faith essays
- God essays
- Hinduism essays
- Islam essays
- Jews essays
- Judaism essays
- Monotheism essays
- New Testament essays
- Ritual essays
- Sin essays
- Soul essays
- Theology essays
- Confession essays
- Devil essays
- Miracle essays
- Monk essays
- Revelation essays