Scarlet letter:bewilderment at Essay Example
Scarlet letter:bewilderment at Essay Example

Scarlet letter:bewilderment at Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 4 (886 words)
  • Published: March 19, 2019
  • Type: Essay
View Entire Sample
Text preview

Jane Manwelyan

Bewilderment at the Hands of Sin

In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter, the quote "No man, for any considerable period, can wear one face to himself and another to the multitude without finally becoming bewildered as to which may be true" is applicable to both Arthur Dimmesdale and Hester Prynne. Arthur's deception and guilt caused him to become consumed and ultimately led to his downfall. On the other hand, Hester was forced to wear a scarlet letter on her bosom, which determined how people perceived her and influenced her self-perception. Initially, Hester did not view her sin in the same negative light as others did in Boston, but she was still compelled to portray herself as an evil doer. Both Arthur and Hester were unable to conceal their true emotions indefinitely; Arthur could not

...

bear it while Hester adjusted her inner feelings according to her guilty image.

During the court hearing, Arthur Dimmesdale pleaded with Hester to disclose the name of her secret lover. He harbored a hidden desire for his own guilt to be exposed, urging her not to withhold information out of pity or compassion for him. He acknowledged that it would be better for his guilty heart to be revealed rather than conceal it throughout his life. This plea may initially appear ironic since he is persuading his accomplice to incriminate him. However, it signifies that Arthur was not merely confused but overwhelmed to the extent that part of him genuinely wished for Hester to reveal him as the guilty party.

Regardless of intention, Arthur's speech was profoundly persuasive as it demonstrated the conflicting forces pulling at him. On one hand, h

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

desperately wanted relief from the burden of his secret sin on his conscience; on the other hand, he knew that revealing the truth would endanger both himself and the community's trust in him. Thus, preserving his facade and reputation became crucial personally and collectively, preventing him from admitting wrongdoing and being seen as a hypocrite and betrayer.

Some members of the community even began doubting their religion. If this man they considered holy and righteous could not live a sinless life, then how could they? Arthur himself started questioning this too, feeling engulfed by the weight of faithfully serving a world closing in on him.As a result, his health began to decline, unable to bear the burden and sorrow of his soul. His spirit had long been lost before his body failed. Hester and Arthur both grappled with the doubts surrounding their actions and whether they had committed a true sin. They did not simply engage in a sinful act out of lust or recklessness; they were genuinely in love. At the time, they believed their relationship held its own consecration, a sense of purity and holiness. Whether their love was genuine or fueled by passion, or a mixture of both, both Hester and Arthur faced the question of whether their actions were truly sinful. They were confronted with a difficult question, disregarding the thoughts of the people of Boston as irrelevant. Their focus was on how God viewed their supposed "consecration" and, more importantly, how they perceived their actions.

Both Arthur and Hester acknowledged that they had committed a genuine sin, recognizing its inherent wrongness. Arthur was filled with misery, guilt, and despair, convinced that they

would face divine judgement.He couldn't bear the burden of their secret sin but also couldn't fathom exposing it publicly.Consequently,his health deterioratedand his spirit weakened.He became emaciatedandhis voice carrieda melancholic senseof decayindicating his decline towards death.Hester too experienced loss ofsphere,but respondedin adifferent manner

Rather than losing hope completely, Hester accepted the justification of the people of Boston in labeling her and placing the "A" on her. Initially, she did not consider her actions with Arthur as evil; rather, she believed their act was sacred and pure. However, at some point in her life, she began to see their actions as sinful. She did not perceive herself as a bad person, nor did the townspeople view her that way when they eventually interpreted the "A" on her chest to represent "Able." Nevertheless, Hester abandoned her dreams and aspirations of revolutionizing how women and the world are perceived after internalizing the true meaning of the "A" and understanding how others saw her actions. She recognized that it would be impossible for a woman tainted with sin and shame to be entrusted with a mission of divine truth (Hawthorne 180). Hester acknowledged committing a genuine sin and subsequently felt both shame and remorse for what she and Arthur had done.

Both Arthur and Hester face an inner conflict regarding their identities. Arthur's guilt and shame over his secret overwhelm him and lead to the deterioration of his health, ultimately resulting in his death. In contrast, Hester approaches her sin differently. She acknowledges that her actions are considered sinful by society and does not attempt to deny or justify them. Instead of grappling with her identity like Arthur, she surrenders to the

prevailing beliefs of the time. Adultery is universally condemned in Boston, leaving no room for goodness or love to emerge from it. While Arthur futilely searches for answers until his death, Hester consciously or unconsciously aligns herself with mainstream views on adultery.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New