Idealistic vs. Pragmatic Leadership – Flashcards

Unlock all answers in this set

Unlock answers
question
Two fundamental motivations for engaging in an activity
answer
Extrinsic Intrinsic
question
Extrinsic Motivation
answer
Instrumental - earn reward or avoid punishment. Ex: Benefits, pay, security, praise from managers Evaluation, surveillance, rewards, competition reduce creativity.
question
Intrinsic Motivation
answer
Internal - performing an activity for it own sake. Ex: Learning new things, developing skills, accomplishing something worthwhile, feeling good about oneself. Pleasure, enjoyment, fulfillment of the task enhances creativity.
question
Extrinsic Incentive Bias
answer
People predict that others are more motivated than themselves by extrinsic incentives and less motivated by intrinsic incentives.
question
Why do we have the "extrinsic incentives bias?"
answer
External factors (pay) are traditionally very salient (most noticeable/important) in employee-employer relationships.
question
Implications of Extrinsic Incentives Bias
answer
Managers may cater to extrinsic motivations but fail to cater to intrinsic motivations. Lead to offering inappropriate "deals" to employees.
question
How do Millenials around the world prioritize values in life?
answer
To spend time with family To grow and learn new things To have a successful career To live a long and healthy life To have time to enjoy my hobbies To work for the betterment of society To have many good friends To be wealthy
question
Extrinsic vs. intrinsic motivations affect performance example
answer
Cadets with strong Intrinsic (train as leader in U.S. Army) vs. Extrinsic ( get good job) motivations were: More likely to graduate and become commissioned officers. More likely to do better in military (early promotion recommendations). More likely to stay in military after 5 years mandatory service.
question
Mixed Motives example
answer
Cadets with strong intrinsic and extrinsic motivations for attending West Point performed worse on every measure than those with strong intrinsic/weak extrinsic. Less likely to graduate, less outstanding as military officers, less committed to staying in military. Crowing Out Effect.
question
How to cater to people's intrinsic motivations?
answer
1. Lead by vision and values 2. Increase contact with beneficiaries 3. Increase task significance
question
Lead by vision and values
answer
Employers inject meaning into daily grind, connecting profit-driven endeavors to grand consequences for mankind. But too many values can lead to Analysis Paralysis. Performance is boosted when large amounts of imagery are combined with small number of values --> triggers shared sense of purpose.
question
Increase contact with beneficiaries
answer
Introduce employees to end users of their work. Does not take a lot of time, effort, money. Highly effective.
question
Increase contact with beneficiaries example
answer
Ex: Call center workers interacted with scholarship students who were recipients of school's fundraising. They worked harder and better.
question
Increase task significance
answer
Make employees aware of the impact their jobs have on others. Particularly important for employees who are high in prosocial values and low in conscientiousness.
question
High in prosocial values
answer
Agree to such statements as "It is important for me to respond to the needs of others."
question
Low in conscientiousness
answer
Those who are not very thorough, careful, or vigilant. People high in conscientiousness will work hard whether or not their labors are beneficial.
question
Increase task significance example
answer
Ex: Lifeguards who read stories on saving lives (vs. personal benefits from work) increased job dedication and helping behaviors.
question
Task significance and drone operators in U.S. Air Force
answer
Drone pilots more prone to PTSD and anxiety than normal combat soldiers because experience Hellfire missiles day-in and day-out - get immediate feedback. Treated as second class citizens who play games.
question
How to motivate drone operators
answer
Increase task significance: Show concrete evidence - statistics on number of lives saved. Provide validation - value, duty to protect nation. Air force try to pay more, extend funding but it's not working.
question
Employees' two orientations towards their jobs
answer
Job as a Calling Job as a Job
question
Job as a Calling
answer
Work is inseparable from life. Works for the fulfillment that doing the work brings to the individual.
question
Job as a Calling statements
answer
I would choose my current work life again if I had the opportunity. I enjoy talking about my work to others. My work is one of the more important things in my life. My work is a chance to give back to the community. My work makes the world a better place.
question
Job as a Job
answer
Only interested in the material benefits from work and do not seek or receive any other type of reward from it. Work is a means to acquire resources needed to enjoy time away from job.
question
Job as a Job statements
answer
When I am not at work, I do not think much about my work. I never take work "home with me." My main reason for working is financial - to support my family and my lifestyle.
question
Downsides to having Job as a Calling (Zookeeper example)
answer
Zookeepers felt strong moral duty to the animals. Were willing to sacrifice pay, personal time, and comfort for their work. (Working two jobs, working in the middle of the night)
question
The dirty work of being a leader
answer
1. Laying off employees 2. Dealing with public scrutiny 3. "Saving face" during corporate scandals
question
Laying off employees
answer
At the most extreme end, can result in expensive, high-profile lawsuits. Not only affect people being laid off, but also the "survivors."
question
Layoffs affecting survivors
answer
1. Can reduce commitment to their jobs 2. Can resort to organizational theft to reduce feelings of inequity (inputs not equal to outputs). 3. Can dissuade prospective employees from joining the organization.
question
When do survivors reduce commitment?
answer
1. When they see their jobs as less intrinsically fulfilling after the layoffs. 2. When they see the layoffs as unfair. 3. When they see other survivors reacting negatively.
question
When survivors see their jobs as less intrinsically fulfilling
answer
They see reductions in job characteristics (job variety, autonomy, feedback). Management's anxieties may lead to greater restrictions and controls being placed --> reduce perceived autonomy and discretion. vs. Some survivors might be asked to take on more and different responsibilities --> increased variety.
question
Two ways survivors see layoffs as unfair
answer
Distributive unfairness Procedural unfairness
question
Distributive Unfairness
answer
Little concrete assistance to the layoff victims in the form of severance pay or help in finding a job elsewhere.
question
Procedural Unfairness
answer
Organization failed to provide clear and adequate explanations of the reasons for the layoff. When procedural unfairness is high, survivors react more negatively to distributive unfairness. Low, more likely to accept.
question
When survivors see other survivors react negatively
answer
Others wondering and worrying whether more layoffs are likely to occur and whether their jobs or career prospects will be affected adversely. In uncertain or stressful situations, people take cues from relevant others to determine how they should think, feel, and act.
question
Public scrutiny of leaders
answer
1. Persistent attention devoted to the leader. 2. Close and persistent performance monitoring and evaluation. 3. Constant questions about what has happened, is happening, will happen, and why.
question
Consequences of public scrutiny
answer
Attention and effort are devoted toward symbolic activities of keeping the public "at bay" and away from substantive efforts to engage in learning and creativity.
question
Leaders overreact to events to demonstrate being "responsive" examples
answer
1. U.S. Army respond to IED ("roadside bomb")-related accidents/deaths by creating different projects that didn't work. 2. The Accredition Council for Graduate Medical Education's respond to errors being made by limiting number of hours a resident could work --> actually limiting number of learning opportunities. 3. Police departments respond to events in Ferguson, Brooklyn, and Cleveland by pouring money into body-worn camera programs though questions of effectiveness, citizen privacy, limited vantage point.
question
"Accountability Ping-pong"
answer
Intelligence analysts become more tolerant of "false-positive" errors when an attack occurs, but switch to more tolerant of "false-negative" errors when predict threat and got it wrong.
question
Accountability Ping-pong example
answer
False negative error - 9/11 False positive error - Weapons of mass destruction (WMD)
question
Saving face in midst of scandals
answer
Potential "damage" of violation depends on "core" or "non-core" Public apology must convey sincerity and guilt.
question
Core
answer
Central to the very foundations of one's work and constitutes a factor on which people give their trust Ex: Brian Williams exaggerating facts/lying
question
Non-core
answer
Peripheral to one's work Ex: Bill Clinton cheating on HIlary
question
Effective apologies
answer
1. Happen very quickly after incident. 2. Candid, "comes clean," admit wrongdoing. 3. Pay penance - punishment. 4. Demonstrate commitment to change for the future - prevent future happenings, not repeat mistakes.
Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New