Pragmatics faced challenges in proving its relevance thirty years ago, but in the early 21st century, it has become a well-established field that draws many linguists and philosophers of language. Despite being an interdisciplinary and open area, some of its core concepts remain contentious, with implicature being a particularly debated term. Coined by Grice during his William James lectures at Harvard University in 1967, implicature refers to what is hinted at but unspoken.
In 1975, Grice introduced the concept of conversational implicature in his article Logic and Conversation. Although subsequent researchers in pragmatics have attempted to improve upon Grice's original framework, I believe that their efforts have been unsuccessful. The numerous exceptions to the rules within the Gricean framework and other principle-based theories proposed by his followers lead me to conclude that
...Grice's theory of implicature is inherently flawed.
It appears that the criticisms made so far have not had much influence, possibly due to their fragmented delivery. This has led to a scenario where we have to choose between either a comprehensive and strongly-backed theory or a minor yet stubborn piece of evidence, resulting in the belief that the issue is trivial and will eventually be elucidated. To put it simply, these criticisms are akin to the stones used for fixing an aged castle. Nonetheless, according to Davis(1998), they can be compared to battering rams utilized for demolishing the castle and have proven to be quite efficient.
Grice's maxim advocate may encounter a predicament when striving for their universal application in dialogue to ensure their effectiveness, as there will always be cases where exceptions exist. The principle of charity suggests being as informative a
necessary for the purpose of the conversation. Grice's philosophy, similar to Occam's Razor, supports the idea of not multiplying senses beyond necessity. Grice(1975) identifies six qualities of conversational implicature.
In summary, conversational implicatures can be calculated and are cancelable.
Non-detachable4 and non-conventional5 elements are not intrinsic to the meaning of the expressed utterances. Rather, they are conveyed through the act of saying them.
6. Indeterminate.Explicatures As previously stated, most pragmatists who work within the Gricean framework adopt the viewpoint that any aspect of interpreting an utterance that is determined pragmatically, excluding disambiguation and reference assignment, can be considered an implicature. In order to achieve a desired outcome that can only be accomplished through speech, a speaker who is rationally ideal will select a speech act that they believe will be the most effective and efficient method to reach their goal. This principle of linguistic activity is known as the Rationality Principle and is assumed to apply to every ordinary speaker. Grice's philosophy of language asserts that, for a significant number of utterances, one can distinguish between what is communicated explicitly through the total signification versus what is implied.
According to Grice's theory, speech is a form of purposeful and rational behavior. This theory includes the Cooperative Principle (CP), which is believed to be followed by speakers: "Make your conversational contribution such as is required, at the stage at which it occurs in which you are engaged." It has been demonstrated that Grice's conversational supermaxims and maxims can be derived from the Rationality Principle (RP) rather than the uncertain Cooperative Principle used by Grice himself. Under some natural assumptions, some of Grice's supermaxims and maxims, such as Quantity,
can be easily derived from RP. However, demonstrating that all of them can be derived in this way is more complicated. For supermaxims like Quality and Manner, intermediate principles have been utilized based on RP and assumptions about human nature.
It is possible to derive related maxims using intermediate rationality principles. These conversational principles are not limited to language and can be seen in other areas due to general rationality principles. Analogous principles have been found in interpretations of paintings, which are consequences of general and intermediate rationality principles similar to Grice's supermaxims and maxims. The epistemological status and internal ranking of Grice's maxims have been discussed by many authors since their original formulation in 1967. Sperber and Wilson (1986) propose that all mental processes involved in communication stem from the principle of relevance, which guarantees relevance when expressing something physically and conveys intention through the "Principle of Relevance".
(b) To overcome the semantic incompleteness and vagueness of messages encoded linguistically, it is necessary to have contextual information. During the inferential interpretation process, including disambiguation, reference assignment, and semantic enrichment, recipients will opt for the context that requires the least processing effort while providing the most relevance due to the relevance guarantee.
According to the Principle of Optimal Relevance, an utterance is selected if it is sufficiently relevant to the recipient, and is the most relevant stimulus that the communicator can use to express their assumptions. When communicating physically, each act implicitly conveys its own optimal relevance, which in turn implies everything that the recipient can gather from the context and their prior knowledge with less effort than explicit prompting. The more implicatures that the communicator leaves
implicit, the higher the mutual understanding assumed between the parties involved.
- Age Of Enlightenment essays
- Ethos essays
- Time essays
- Acceptance essays
- Meaning Of Life essays
- Reality essays
- Natural Law essays
- Political Philosophy essays
- Utilitarianism essays
- Existence essays
- Free Will essays
- Good And Evil essays
- Confucianism essays
- Relativism essays
- Conscience essays
- Environmentalism essays
- Empiricism essays
- Epistemology essays
- Ethics essays
- Existentialism essays
- Human Nature essays
- Individualism essays
- Metaphysics essays
- Philosophy Of Life essays
- Transcendentalism essays
- Truth essays
- Destiny essays
- Determinism essays
- Fate essays
- Functionalism essays
- Philosophers essays
- Pragmatism essays
- Future essays
- Child Observation essays
- Critical Reflection essays
- Teaching Philosophy essays
- Personal Philosophy essays
- Action Speak Louder Than Words essays
- Can Money Buy Happiness essays
- Values of Life essays
- Ethical dilemma essays
- Normative Ethics essays
- Virtue Ethics essays
- Belief essays
- Deontology essays
- Moral essays
- Virtue essays
- Work Ethic essays
- Henry David Thoreau essays
- Carl Jung essays