Beliefs of filipino women about traditional feminine gender Essay
A 2 ( US adult females vs. Filipino adult females ) X 2 ( girls vs. female parents ) ANOVA matched group design with the O’Kelly Women Beliefs Scale ( 2010 ) scores as the dependant variable was conducted to analyze irrational beliefs about traditional feminine gender scheme from a Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy ( REBT ) position ( Ellis, 1956 ) in a sample of Filipino adult females populating in the US. Results indicated important chief consequence for cross-cultural differences among the two racial groups, but no important chief consequence was found for generational differences among the groups. A Post-hoc Least Significant Difference ( LSD ) performed on the four subscale tonss of the OWBS besides showed important differences in Demand with Filipino adult females hiting higher than their US opposite numbers, and tonss of both groups in Awfulizing, Negative Self-talk/Rating, and Low Frustration Tolerance ( LFT ) were non significantly different.
Keywords: Filipino adult females, irrational beliefs, gender scheme, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, O’Kelly Women Beliefs Scale
Irrational Beliefs about Traditional Feminine Gender Schema
of Filipino Women Living in the United States
This survey evaluates the cross-cultural and intergenerational differences among Filipino adult females and US adult females populating in the United States in respect to their beliefs about the traditional feminine sex function utilizing the O’Kelly Women Beliefs Scale ( 2010 ) . Several factors of socialization greatly affect the international migration, economic globalisation, and political struggles that arise in the creative activity of multicultural societies ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) , that surveies sing this affair are indispensable in understanding it in a deeper sense.
There is a great measure of literature sing feminine subjects written within the conceptual strategy of the Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy or REBT ( Wolfe, 1985 ; Wolfe & A ; Naimark, 1991 ) . The founding practician of REBT, Albert Ellis, developed this signifier of psychotherapeutics to help his clients in the Reconstruction of how they perceive their hurt by asseverating the importance of taking it on with a more ‘philosophical ‘ mentality. When Ellis changed Rational Emotive Therapy ( RET ) to its present name of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy ( REBT ) , he acknowledged the possible odds in utilizing the term “ rational ” as thoughts refering it may change across civilizations ( Ellis, 1999 ) . Ellis ever emphasized the importance of taking his clients ‘ cultural background into consideration when analysing their point of view and attitude towards life. It has been considered that the development of the Women ‘s Belief Scale coincide with the standards described by Locksley and Colten ( 1979 ) , who highlight that the usage of a term within a questionnaire involves self-evaluations and supposes comparings of itself that were non present – like in Bem Sex Role Inventory ( BSRI ; Bem, 1974 ) in the developmental procedure of the points ; this allows a important consequence of measurings on the representation of the feminine gender that provides a distinguishable point of position of what behaviours are appropriate for females.
The position of adult female ‘s proper topographic point being in the place carry throughing their domesticity, maternity and delighting their hubbies, isolated from the public universe of work forces did non ever rule the Western civilization ( O’Kelly, 1980 ) . It was non until the rise of capitalist economy when independent business communities could afford to back up their dependent married womans and kids kept within the confines of a private place, that this position of adult females ‘s functions started to greatly act upon the modern Western civilization ( O’Kelly, 1980 ) . By the 18th century, these functions periodically spread to the less flush categories and finally became the Western ideal for adult females ( O’Kelly, 1980 ) .
In the recent old ages, with the aid of the feminist motion, dramatic alterations in the Western societal functions expected from adult females are continuously taking topographic point. Feminists insist that those customary positions of adult females ‘s functions vastly limit and restrain them from taking their topographic points as full grownups in the society ( O’Kelly, 1980 ) . However, less developed states continue to hold rigorous positions on the functions of the adult females in their society and they intend to keep their cultural beliefs sing this affair. There are barely any surveies done to analyze the influence and effects of these social functions placed on adult females from less developed states, like the Philippines, in their response to socialization and attitude towards life.
The O’Kelly Women ‘s Belief Scale was developed within the strategy of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy or REBT, reflecting the procedure of beliefs about Demand, Awfulizing, Global Rating, Low Frustration Tolerance ( LFT ) and Negative Self Rating. To develop this graduated table, 2,562 questionnaires were sent to adult females that worked in great companies. With the informations obtained of 974 questionnaires, the O’Kelly subscales were developed: Demand, Awful, Low Frustration Tolerance ( LFT ) and Rating, which are irrational atomic decisions or beliefs antecedently mentioned. Each of these graduated tables has internal consistence. The test-retest dependability and cogency have been established by the consequences of a sample that consisted of 285 adult females, wherein 37 besides completed The O’Kelly Women ‘s Belief Scale a month subsequently.
In the measuring of the irrational idea from an REBT position, old surveies ( Lega & A ; Ellis, 2001 ; Kumar, Lega, & A ; Bladiwalla, 2007 ) indicate transverse cultural and generational differences in the samples of USA, Latin America, Europe and India.
Filipino Americans are one of the fastest turning minority groups in the United States as they are the 2nd largest Asiatic American ethnic group, and the 2nd largest figure of immigrants to the United States ( Ong & A ; Loksze, 2003 ) . Recent surveies suggest that socialization, alterations in attitude or values that result from the contact of one civilization with another ( Berry, 1997 ) , may hold something to make with attitudes towards adult females ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) . Harmonizing to Berry ( 1997 ) , there are four socialization schemes: separation, marginalisation, integrating, and assimilation. Separation refers to prefering one ‘s original civilization and forbearing from interacting with the host civilization, whereas marginalisation is when 1 does non actively keep either his ain original civilization or the host civilization ( Choi & A ; Thomas, 2007 ) . On the other manus, integrating refers to prefering one ‘s ain civilization while at the same clip interacting with the host civilization, and assimilation is when one abandons his original civilization in favour of the host civilization ( Choi & A ; Thomas, 2007 ) .
The international relationship between United States and the Philippines has a rich and alone history that has made the Filipinos really good familiar to the American civilization that even allowed them to easy follow the English linguistic communication, educational establishments, democratic belief system, and religion in the “ American Dream ” ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) . Most Philippine immigrants arrive in the United States with a huge cognition about the local civilization and the English linguistic communication ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) . Filipino adult females populating in the US, largely as immigrants, seek to accommodate to their host state ‘s cultural values while endeavoring to continue their ain at the same clip. Like other persons from destitute states, particularly those who have spent most of their lives in their native states, Filipinos are besides good cognizant of how hard it can be to populate in a state of limited chances like the Philippines. However, like other immigrant groups, they besides praise the United States as a land of important economic chance but at the same time denounce it as a state inhabited by corrupt and individualistic people of questionable ethical motives ( Espiritu, 2001 ) .
Parents of first coevals Filipino kids enforce high outlooks particularly on their girls. Espiritu ‘s interviews suggest that there is an idealised impression of muliebrity based on traditional Filipino values and beliefs ( Espiritu, 2001 ) . This idealised impression of muliebrity is for a adult female to believe of her household ( corporate vs. single values ) , to derive good instruction ( in order to assist better the household ) , remain chaste, duteous, and obedient ( Agbayani-Siewert, 1994 ) . Older kids, misss in peculiar, are expected to care for their younger siblings and execute family responsibilities even at an early age ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) . Past surveies suggest that while the older female is given more duties, privileges are made easy accessible normally to males in the household. Most Philippine adult females, who participated in past surveies, besides reported that their parents treated them more purely while turning up every bit compared to their brothers ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) . As they grow older, Filipino adult females are expected to expose features of a Maria Clara, or the proper, marriage-minded, Filipino Catholic adult female with “ good ethical motives ” ( West, 1992 ) . This stereotypic representation of an ideal Filipino adult female continues to be in the present clip. Filipino adult females were taught and encouraged to be publically submissive so that it will look that work forces are the 1s in control ( Cimmarusti, 1996 ) . Almirol ( 1982 ) , a research worker who performed a qualitative survey on Filipino American farm labourers from Salinas, California, found that a higher value was placed on males over females and that adult females were discouraged to expose power in public. Scholars have shown that the Maria Clara stereotype is non merely used by certain Filipino women’s rightist patriot, but besides by first coevals Filipino immigrants ( Ignacio, 2000 ) .
Anterior research workers show that despite the high cultural outlooks enforced on Filipino kids by their parents, they appear to hold easy assimilated into the American society as the Filipino population in the US has a high rate of college alumnuss, and most of these alumnuss are immigrants from the Philippines ( Enrile & A ; Agbayani, 2007 ) .
Different positions suggest the being of alteration and differences in attitudes and involvements from one coevals to the other, every bit good as in the cross-cultural factor. This survey was conducted in the USA wherein Filipino girls and female parents, and their opposite numbers used The O’Kelly Women Belief ‘s Scale examine the differences in gender functions and the ethno-cultural strategy.
Two matched groups harmonizing to age of girls ( from 17-25 year. of age ) vs. their female parents ( 45 – 75 year. of age ) and civilization of beginning ( 70 Filipino vs. 70 USA ) life in the USA participated in the survey.
The O’Kelly Women Beliefs Scale ( O’Kelly, 2010 ) was used. The scale consists of 92 points in which the participant indicated the grade of understanding or dissension utilizing a graduated table from 1 ( strongly disagree ) to 5 ( strongly agree ) . This is divided into four subscales: Demand, Awfulizing, Low Frustration Tolerance and Negative Self Rating.
The participants completed the questionnaires separately and anonymously. It took about 45 proceedingss to finish. Participants were besides advised to forbear from replying the questionnaire with their mother/daughter.
A 2-way ANOVA ( civilization and coevals ) with entire OWBS tonss as the dependant variable showed a important chief consequence for Culture, F ( 1, 140 ) = 37.681, P & lt ; .05. No important consequences were found for chief consequence for Generation, or for the interaction between Culture x Generation ( P & gt ; .05 )
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — –
Table 1: Posthoc comparings with OWBS subscale tonss as DVs
Sums of Squares
Country * Generation
* P & lt ; .05
Posthoc ( LSD ) comparings between Filipino and US adult females for all four subscale tonss of the OWBS showed important differences, with Filipino adult females hiting higher than US adult females in Demand: F ( 1, 140 ) = 5.265, P & lt ; .05 ; tonss of both groups in: Awfulizing, Negative Self-talk/Rating, and LFT were non significantly different ( p & gt ; .05 ) . No important consequences were found for Generation, or for the interaction between Culture x Generation ( P & gt ; .05 )
As one of the fastest turning groups of Asiatic immigrants, Filipino immigrants are intentionally seeking to go portion and to develop a positive attitude towards acculturating to the host civilization, at least to some extent. However, it is apprehensible that the procedure of socialization have a distinguishable influence in the immigrants ‘ point of view and attitude towards life.
The consequences suggest that the overall entire tonss of US-Filipino compared to US adult females were higher than the latter. Recent surveies might propose that socialization may play a portion in Filipino adult females ‘s irrational beliefs about themselves. A past survey on socialization by Phinney and Flores ( 2002 ) , affirms that the two dimensions of the phenomenon ( mainstream version and cultural keeping ) can be independent and have different influences to its results. The consequences of their survey showed that the bicultural ( integrated ) person is more likely to be involved in mainstream American society every bit good as to attest sex function attitudes closely similar to that of the mainstream, and yet pull off to retain their ain racial societal webs and native linguistic communication. Later coevalss of immigrants are besides expected to be more prone to alterations associated with both dimensions of socialization ; that is, they typically retain less of their cultural civilization and be given to be more accepting of the host civilization than earlier coevalss ( Phinney & A ; Flores, 2002 ) . On the other manus, the present survey showed no important consequence for generational differences ( female parent vs. girl ) in either civilization ( US-Filipino or US adult females ) . It was expected that Filipino adult females would hit higher than their United states opposite numbers because of social outlooks and traditional gender scheme on adult females. Filipino adult females are expected to attest certain features such as capableness of constructing a household, running the family and duty for taking attention of others ‘ demand before her ain to call a few. Some research workers propose that immigrants do non merely give their old or native values for new 1s, but instead choice, and modify to accommodate to the new environment ( Choi & A ; Thomas, 2007 ; Buriel, 1993 ; Mendoza, 1989 ) . Although most Filipino immigrants finally become accustomed to their new environment, they besides retain their traditional cultural traits, beliefs, values, and mores which may ensue to a struggle in their belief system and a higher degree of irrational belief. However, when it comes to Generation, the non-significant differences between Filipino girls and female parents may be found in that the cultural outlook of both coevalss ( Filipino female parents vs. Filipino girls ) has rooted its ideals from our past coevalss ‘ belief as a corporate community as opposed to individualistic values. It is an built-in feature of the ideal Filipino household to hold kids who extremely adhere to the household ‘s values and rules and to act harmonizing to these passed on criterions. Daughters are taught to greatly exhibit the same positive qualities that their female parents ‘ exhibit and this pattern have a significant influence on the non-significant differences in the point of position of both coevalss.
In footings of posthoc comparings, where single bomber graduated table tonss were obtained for Demand, Awfulizing, Negative Self Talk and LFT, a important consequence was merely found on Demand of Filipino adult females V. US adult females. This suggests that Filipino adult females experience higher emotional emphasis than their US opposite numbers. First coevals immigrants, as they are called, sometimes experience socialization and cultural force per unit area to accommodate. Cultural version to the host state may propose struggle with the traditional civilization of the heritage state while parents try to raise their kids on both civilizations. Anterior researches show that Filipino immigrants tend to lose their traditional imposts and values as they acculturate to ways of life in the United States ( Del Prado & A ; Church, 2010 ) . Bing lacerate between adhering to their conservative cultural values and the ability to entree the chances of their modern-day American civilization can make emphasis and struggle ( Napholz & A ; Mo, 2010 ) . The Socio-cultural differences that include the Asiatic corporate civilization versus the American single civilization, extended versus dominant atomic household life style, isolative American life style, adult females ‘s functions, communicating manners, and child-rearing patterns have a huge impact on the Filipino immigrant adult females ‘s self-esteem and sense of control over their lives ( Napholz & A ; Mo, 2010 ) . As Filipino adult females become more acculturated to their host state ‘s cultural values, factors such as their beginnings, psychosocial and economic emphasis, every bit good as their conformity to traditional cultural values may hold an influence in the nature and quality of their present lives ( McBride, Morioka-Douglas, & A ; Yeo, 1996 ) . High tonss on each subscale harmonizing to the O’Kelly Women Belief Scales or OWBS ( O’Kelly, 2010 ) suggest that Filipino adult females have higher irrational beliefs on the traditional feminine gender function as their civilization may hold manifested on them over the old ages.
The Demand subscale ( component at which people reveal their musts and shoulds ) suggests that Filipino adult females need to make certain outlooks harmonizing to their civilization. A high mark in this subscale suggests that Filipino adult females, compared to US adult females strive more to make outlooks put Forth by their society as a consequence from a collectivized point of position. Almost every society has prescribed functions that adult females and work forces are expected to fulfill, nevertheless the stringency of these criterions vary across cultural societies. In the Filipino civilization, persons that belong to the society are expected to esteem and conform to the regulations of the society every bit precisely as possible. Deviating from the recognized norms and societal functions brings away unforgiving unfavorable judgments non merely from the society at big, but by one ‘s ain immediate household every bit good. A traditional Filipino household is non normally inclined to being tolerant to issues and patterns foreign to them, as they believe that everyone should act harmonizing to what is widely accepted. Therefore, the procedure of acculturating to a new civilization that has some facets that conflict with the Filipino civilization can be really confusing and nerve-racking to Filipino adult females endeavoring to develop positive attitudes toward the procedure. An illustration inquiry from this subscale was “ I must hold a kid to be fulfilled ” ; Filipinos are expected to be capable of constructing a household and both coevalss ( mother vs. girl ) must make this outlook as their society and past coevalss expects them to. This idealised impression of muliebrity is for a adult female to believe of her household ( corporate vs. person ) ( Agbayani-Siewert, 1994 ) as mentioned came from most of the Oriental civilization ‘s belief of Bolshevism vs. individuality.
In short, the outlook that Filipino adult females would hit higher than their United states opposite numbers because of social outlooks and traditional gender scheme on adult females was confirmed.