Argumentative Analysis Essay Example

but is quite soon forgotten after it is over.

In another recent article, a man that had continually speed raced through a shopping area in Florida was made to wear a sign saying "Don' street race" for fifty consecutive Sundays form 1 A. M. To 2:00 A. M. Near the shopping Center that he raced.

How many people actually saw this man at this late time was not mentioned in the article. The 24 year old, Riviera, himself even dated "no Problem" when asked to do it. He was thankful for this punishment rather than getting automatically sent back to jail. It's more of a public humiliation than a public service," said Kimberly Lavender, a spokeswoman for the American Civil Liberties Union, Florida, in Miami. I'. Wouldn't it serve the community better if this person was doing community service in a hospital? " (Associated Press, March 2 2005) The community service would have actually accomplished something towards doing good for others in that community.

Making a real difference to someone else is all part f the paying back and tying to make up for the wrong doings that people make.

Community service is a great example of how retribution is more effective form of punishment than is public humiliation. One might still say that public humiliation is worth a shot in today's society with all of the social problems, high crime rates, etc. Etc.

. At the very least a person may be able to relate to the judges, in cases mentioned here, using these unconventional and old school ways to try and keep people from repeating these types of crimes because nothing else seems to

stop some individuals' behaviors. On the other hand though, is it really making a difference long term?

Is there any real evidence or research to support that using this type of public humiliation is reducing the number of these types of crimes? The answer is no. Individuals who take similar actions with their loved ones are similar to those included in the sentences given by judges in many articles.

One last example of this type of humiliation is in an article about a wife in Virginia who found out that her husband was cheating on her by reading messages on his cell phone. Taylor, of Centralize, Virginia, said his fife wanted him to stand with the sign on the road daily for a week.

He began his punishment the first day at 9:00 A. M. On the busy highway intersection, but after a couple of hours he received a call from his wife to say his punishment was over. He told a local TV station in Virginia that he thought his wife was joking when she suggested the idea "l thought she was kidding, but she was serious," he said.

(Thompson, August 28,2009) Really? How serious was Tailor's wife? She told him, at first, when she was really angry, that he would have to stand there for a week. Then, when he actually greed and did what she asked him to do, she caved in after only two hours and told him he could come home.

Mr..

Taylor got away with adultery and his wife took him back after he stood on a street corner with a sign that said, " I cheated" for two

hours. That is pretty lame as far as punishment goes. In this case it does not appear that public humiliation worked either. It is quite evident, as shown in all of these examples of modern day public humiliation, that this form of punishment has no real lasting effect. Individuals cited in these articles do not seem to find it that unpleasant to be UT out in public with signs of guilt hung around their neck for all the world to see.

The man who was caught speed racing in the shopping center stated out loud that he would be happy to attend out on the street with a sign that get sent back to jail.

Mrs.. Lavender, from the American Civil Liberties made an excellent point when she expressed the fact that humiliating the offender in that case did nothing to better anyone else and that community service would be a much better choice than public humiliation. Maybe our society is ATA point where we are so self-absorbed, pre-occupied, stressed out, or worried bout our own problems that no one really pays that much attention to others around us.