Romanov Family Essay Example

report was to provide the British Government with an update on Russia's present state. An interesting paradox can be observed in sources B and J. While source B claims that no corpses or signs of cremation were discovered, source J mentions finding the bodies of the Royal family, contradicting source B's statement. Source C comprises a fragment from Judge Sokolov's book regarding the inquiry into the assassination of the Romanov clan.

The initial disclosure of the fate of the Romanov family's remains reveals that a truck transported them to the mine owned by four brothers where they were dismembered, burned with fuel and sulphuric acid. However, it remains unclear if these pieces were buried according to this source.

According to Source J, the bodies were initially interred in a shallow pit but were eventually moved back onto the lorry when the mine failed to cave in. The lorry later became stuck in a swamp, and it was at this location that the remains were buried. It is interesting to note that "bodies" was utilized instead of "body parts," though there is no indication as to whether these bodies were interred from the bogged vehicle or if they remained within it.

Despite discrepancies, source C contradicts both sources D and J as presented. Source D comprises interview notes with Pavel Medvedev, a white who describes the Bolsheviks' role in guarding the Romanov family at the Impatiev house. Although source J pertains to a distinct aspect of the inquiry involving Maria, a key witness, it is improbable that this would affect source D's credibility. Nonetheless, an important detail from source J concerns nine individuals entering the room where Tsar's family,

their maid, and Dr. Botkin were present.

The statement reports that the individuals were dead and located on the ground. This information does not directly conflict with source J, but it raises concerns about why the family wasn't interred together if they were all fatally shot. In 1991, a book was published that featured an excerpt from source E providing insights into Medvedev's wife's account of the killings. Source E only mentions the Tsar as a family member, offering limited points for comparison to source J.

The Basement room in the Impatiev house, where it is believed the Tsar and his family were shot, is depicted in Source F as an image. There is no significant comparison to be made with Source J. Source G, on the other hand, is an artist's rendition of the Tsar's death, based on the whites investigation. Its purpose was to provide insight into the author's interpretation of how the Tsar died. However, like sources E and F, the credibility of this source is questionable. Meanwhile, Source H presents a diagram of the supposed positions of the Romanovs and the guards during the event.

Source I is derived from the same book by Judge Sokolov as Source C, which was published in 1924. The information provided in the source does not reveal the location or method of death of the Romanov family members, nor does it specify their exact position. Additionally, the content of Source I consists of a message sent by the Ural Soviet to the Petrograd Soviet.

This source is discussing an event that took place on July 20, 1918. It is the most confusing source as it claims that

the Tsar's wife and son are still safe and alive, despite contradicting other sources. It is unclear why the Ural Soviet would lie about their survival. Ultimately, this source, labeled J, raises more questions than it answers, casting doubt on who was killed and where and when it happened.

Providing a fresh perspective on the killing of the Romanovs.