Plato and Immigration Essay Example
Plato and Immigration Essay Example

Plato and Immigration Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 3 (663 words)
  • Published: April 3, 2017
  • Type: Essay
View Entire Sample
Text preview

Plato Module Today, we live in a world that has come a long way and is in a constant state of evolution. Every day, our nation leaders are constantly battling to come up with or refine policies and regulations that will, they hope, improve or sustain our current lifestyle. While the amount of polices is vast, the one in particular that I will be focusing on will be immigration, more specifically, the immigration policy that allows for case-by-case decision making in regards to immigrant deportation.

I chose this case because it seems highly controversial and raises many questions, considering there are so many “gray areas” to take into account, as is the case with many policies. What I set out to explore in more detail is in regards to illegal immigrants who get to stay and are apart of the U. S. workforce,

...

but consequently take away jobs from America citizens. If Plato were alive today, he would be probably be disappointed with how society has turned out, but not surprised.

Our democratic government is something Plato has seen in his lifetime and is not fond of it. He has seen the unstable manner of democracy, and knows that it lacks leaders with proper skills and morals. Leaders, according to Plato, must be groomed from birth. They must be molded and shaped from young children through intense training and education to become “expert” rulers. In essence, they must “know” the “forms of good. ” It is only these individuals who have reached this prestigious level of expertise that would be qualified to make judgment and decisions.

How Plato, or a Platonist, would approach this issue of immigration is

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

something that must be looked at far deeper than the surface level. Since experts, those who know the good, are the only ones who should be allowed to make decisions, Plato would say to consult them on the matter. However, finding an expert in immigration can prove troublesome. If finding an expert on immigration were not possible, Plato would advise to look elsewhere for some type of expert that can govern on such matters. Since the policy deals with currency, a potential candidate to look to for guidance could be an expert economist.

The economist however cannot have family ties to the situation for that would lead to a governance through emotion, an approach Plato would completely dismiss. The economist should be rational and make decisions based on the greater good, that is what is “just”. Despite the individual who would make the final decision, the judgment should be made to benefit the society as a whole. With the case of immigration, how will allowing the illegal immigrants to stay, or forcing them to be deported affect the rest of the community is something to take into account.

Instead of what is “right” or “wrong”, the decision for this policy should be based on what illegal immigrants are bringing to the table and what value they take away that could affect society. “[L]aw does not exist for the exclusive benefit of one class in the city. Its aim is to engineer the benefit of the city as a whole, using persuasion and compulsion to bring the citizens into harmony, and making each class share with the other classes the contribution it is able to bring to the

community” (519e). Coming to an agreement on the policy may not be an easy task.

While Plato believes that policies should be made to create harmony and efficiency within society, any type of immigration policy would increase the population. In that case, Plato would completely dismiss the policy all together, claiming that the excessive population would increase deficiency within the city. All in all, it is hard to conclude on how Plato would approach the immigration regulation. Whichever path Plato would take, it can be concluded that justice will be served. Works Cited Ferrari, G. R. F. , ed. Plato: The Republic. Trans. Tom Griffith. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2009. Print.

Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New