Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 11 (5582 words)
  • Published: November 8, 2018
Text preview


Understanding the Narcissistic Phenomenon

The so called narcissistic personality disorder is a complex and often misunderstood

disorder. The cardinal feature of the narcissistic personality is the grandiose sense of self

importance, but paradoxically underneath this grandiosity the narcissist suffers from a

chronically fragile low self esteem. The grandiosity of the narcissist, however, is often so

pervasive that we tend to dehumanize him or her. The narcissist conjures in us images of

the mythological character Narcissus who could only love himself, rebuffing anyone who

attempted to touch him. Nevertheless, it is the underlying sense of inferiority which is

the real problem of the narcissist, the grandiosity is just a facade used to cover the deep

feelings of inadequacy.

The Makeup of the Narcissistic Personality

The narcissists grandiose behavior is designed to reaffirm his or her sense of

adequacy. Since the narcissist is incapable of asserting his or her own sense of adequacy,

the narcissist seeks to be admired by others. However, the narcissists extremely fragile

sense of self worth does not allow him or her to risk any criticism. Therefore,

meaningful emotional interactions with others are avoided. By simultaneously seeking

the admiration of others and keeping them at a distance the narcissist is usually able to

maintain the illusion of grandiosity no matter how people respond. Thus, when people

praise the narcissist his or her grandiosity will increase, but when criticized the

grandiosity will usually remain unaffected because the narcissist will devalue the

criticizing person.

Akhtar (1989) as cited in Carson & Butcher, 1992; P. 271 discusses six areas of

pathological fu


nctioning which characterize the narcissist. In particular, four of these

narcissistic character traits best illustrate the pattern discussed above.(1) a narcissistic

individual has a basic sense of inferiority, which underlies a preoccupation with fantasies

of outstanding achievement; (2) a narcissistic individual is unable to trust and rely on

others and thus develops numerous, shallow relationships to extract tributes from others;

(3) a narcissistic individual has a shifting morality-always ready to shift values to gain

favor; and (4) a narcissistic person is unable to remain in love, showing an impaired

capacity for a committed relationship.

The Therapeutic Essence of Treating Narcissism

The narcissist who enters therapy does not think that there is something wrong with

him or her. Typically, the narcissist seeks therapy because he or she is unable to

maintain the grandiosity which protects him or her from the feelings of despair. The

narcissist views his or her situation arising not as a result of a personal maladjustment;

rather it is some factor in the environment which is beyond the narcissists control

which has caused his or her present situation. Therefore, the narcissist expects the

therapist not to cure him or her from a problem which he or she does not perceive to

exist, rather the narcissist expects the therapist to restore the protective feeling of

grandiosity. It is therefore essential for the therapist to be alert to the narcissists attempts

to steer therapy towards healing the injured grandiose part, rather than exploring

the underlying feelings of inferiority and despair.

Differential Psychological Views of Narcissism

The use of the term narcissism in relation to psychological phenomena was first

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay
View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay


by Ellis in 1898. Ellis described a special state of auto-erotism as Narcissus like, in

which the sexual feelings become absorbed in self admiration (Goldberg, 1980). The

term was later incorporated into Freuds psychoanalytic theory in 1914 in his essay On

Narcissism. Freud conceptualized narcissism as a as a sexual perversion involving a

pathological sexual love to ones own body (Sandler & Person, 1991). Henceforth,

several psychological theories have attempted to explain and treat the narcissistic

phenomenon. Specifically, the most comprehensive psychological theories have been

advanced by the psychodynamic perspective and to a lesser extent the Jungian

(analytical) perspective. Essentially, both theories cite developmental problems in

childhood as leading to the development of the narcissistic disorder. The existential

school has also attempted to deal with the narcissistic problem, although the available

literature is much smaller. Existentialists postulate that society as a whole can be the

crucial factor in the development of narcissism. The final perspective to be discussed is

the humanistic approach which although lacking a specific theory on narcissism, can

nevertheless be applied to the narcissistic disorder. In many ways the humanistic

approach to narcissism echoes the sentiments of the psychodynamic approach.

The Psychodynamic Perspective of Narcissism

The psychodynamic model of narcissism is dominated by two overlapping schools of

thought, the self psychology school and the object relations school. The self psychology

school, represented by Kohut, posits that narcissism is a component of everyones

psyche. We are all born as narcissists and gradually our infantile narcissism matures into

a healthy adult narcissism. A narcissistic disorder results when this process is somehow

disrupted. By contrast the object relations school, represented by Kernberg, argues that

narcissism does not result from the arrest of the normal maturation of infantile

narcissism, rather a narcissism represents a fixation in one of the developmental periods

of childhood. Specifically, the narcissist is fixated at a developmental stage in which the

differentiation between the self and others is blurred.

Kohuts Theory of Narcissism

Kohut believes that narcissism is a normal developmental milestone, and the healthy

person learns to transform his or her infantile narcissism into adult narcissism. This

transformation takes place through the process which Kohut terms transmuting

internalizations. As the infant is transformed into an adult he or she will invariably

encounter various challenges resulting in some frustration. If this frustration exceeds the

coping abilities of the person only slightly the person experiences optimal frustration.

Optimal frustration leads the person to develop a strong internal structure (i.e., a strong

sense of the self) which is used to compensate for the lack of external structure (i.e.,

support from others). In the narcissist the process of transmuting internalizations is

arrested because the person experiences a level of frustration which exceeds optimal

frustration. The narcissist thus remains stuck at the infantile level, displaying many of

the characteristics of the omnipotent and invulnerable child (Kohut, 1977).

Kernbergs Theory of Narcissism

Kernbergs views on narcissism are based on Mahlers theory of the separation-

individuation process in infancy and early childhood. Mahlers model discusses how the

developing child gains a stable self concept by successfully mastering the two forerunner

phases (normal autism and normal symbiosis) and the four

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay