The Analysis for Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Help the Poor Essay Example

and misled the whole article to a wrong direction. First, not all the people in water need to board on the lifeboat. Some developing countries could boost their industries and business based on their own efforts, including to encourage the internal investment and to expand the domestic demand, thus their business recover gradually. Second, the full aid is not necessary; instead, the lifeboat could just send out some swim-rings or ladders to support these people partially. Underdeveloped countries need help from the privileged nations, but it is not mean that all of them should become rich countries’ dependents. On the other hand, the developed countries could support them with technology, quality control and new product development. Based on the aided information and technology, the developing countries could get better future development path. Third, the capacity of the
lifeboat is misestimated.

Although the poorer countries have larger population, rich nations obtain the majority of the world’s fortune and resources. In that case, rich nation’s supporting capacity is definitely much larger than that of the lifeboat, and these developed countries have the great ability to help more people in the world. The author discussed the purpose of the World Food Bank as well. He insists that the developing countries are associated with high birth rate; in that case, if the World Food Bank provides food and supplies to these countries, the rescued people might produce more people and double the population.

As a result, a larger number of people would need support and these countries would become even impecunious. Hardin overlooked the factor that the population gross is controlled by both birth rate and the death

rate. Some underdeveloped countries, such as Zambia and Zimbabwe lack of the major resources; therefore, people in these countries are extremely needy and poor. In addition, due to the reason of lack of technology and equipments, people could not receive the proper medical treatments, which result in relatively high death rate. In that case, the families must birth more children to ensure some of them could grow up. The World Food Bank provides food for these families could help them to relieve their pains and give them hopes for the future. For another factor, not all the poor countries are associated with the high birth rate. People’s opinion altered along with the social development. In the modern world, more people have the access for education, and the better education could change people’s idea towards family and birth.

Even though the economy is still underdeveloped, personal awareness has been evoked. They want to have fewer children and to pursue their better lives. In that case, these countries still need the aid and the World Food Bank could provide timely and effective assistance for these people. In conclusion, the author composed the article based on the logic statement, but he failed to consider the reality. The biased information twisted the audience’s persecutions to a wrong direction. The readers could classify the different messages while the reading process and try to eliminate the inappropriate information since the article contained some idea of racism and separatism. We should notice that in the modern society, countries in the world must communicate and cooperate with each other in order to achieve a prosperous and peaceful world.