An Evaluation of the Performance of the United Nations
An Evaluation of the Performance of the United Nations

An Evaluation of the Performance of the United Nations

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 15 (7788 words)
  • Published: July 28, 2017
Text preview


The United Nations is the most dominant international governmental organisation in the universe. Having been formed with the chief aim of forestalling war instantly after World War II. so far it appears to hold had small success in making so. Yet there are many jobs that are planetary in nature and therefore depend on the United Nations to turn to them. This has prompted examination into the activities and personal businesss of the United Nations with the purpose of measuring the strengths and failings of the organisation. This survey takes a critical expression into the constructions and duties of the political and security variety meats of the United Nations with the purpose of placing failings and doing proposals on how better on the public presentation of the organisation.

Chapter I – Introduction

Introductory paragraphs

The challenge of insecurity in international dealingss remains one of the biggest menaces confronting the universe today. Despite legion spirited attempts by states throughout the universe to procure the international system from the of all time skulking dangers of international wars. the rule of corporate security remains every bit elusive as of all time.

Since the formation of the United Nations ( UN ) in 1945. the international system has obviously been characterized by legion security challenges that have peculiarly been defined by events during the Cold War. after the Cold War and after the September 11 2001 terrorist act onslaughts upon the United States. With the foundation of the United Nations holding been solidly ba


sed on the rules of corporate security. there are increasing concerns as to whether the United Nations is populating up to its charge.

Past events have clearly demonstrated that the United Nations lacks equal capacity and authorization to implement the rule of corporate security. Harmonizing to Goldstein ( 2003 ) . “The UN Charter establishes a mechanism for corporate security – the stria together of the world’s states to halt an attacker ( p. 267 ) . Chapter 7 of the Charter explicitly authorizes the Security Council to utilize military force against aggression if the usage of non-violent agencies as captured in chapter 6 fail. Harmonizing to the UN Charter. the United Nations may step in domestically in a province that commits Acts of the Apostless of aggression or airss menaces to security.

However. this rule is normally enforced selectively. Analysis by Roberts & A ; Kingsbury ( 1994 ) showed that because great states possess veto powers. the UN can non sharply stop aggression by ( or supported by ) a great power. Therefore. Chapter seven was used one time during the Cold War – in the Korean War when the Soviet deputation foolishly boycotted the Security Council proceedings ( p. 61 ) .

“The U. S. flew the U. N. flag in change by reversaling the North Korean invasion of South Korea in 1950 and the invasion of Iraq in 1990. and both misdemeanors were a misdemeanor of the international jurisprudence under the UN charter” ( Roberts & A ; Kingsbury. 1994. p. 63 ) . Goldstein ( 2003 ) notes that it was under Chapter 7 of the Charter that the UN authorized the usage

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay
View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

of force to change by reversal Iraq aggression against Kuwait in 1990 ( p. 269 ) .

To the surprise of many. “the United Nations ne’er intervened militarily in similar illegal Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 and the Israel invasion of Lebanon in 1982” ( Roberts & A ; Kingsbury. 1994. p. 68 ) . These were clear indicants that the United Nations is limited by the demands of power political relations in the international system. Kochler ( 2002 ) emphasizes that the international system is basically lawless. with the great powers still ruling the international system and the United Nations itself” ( p. 6 )

Purpose of the survey

Merely as the League of Nations grew out of the World War I. the United Nations grew out of the World War II. Like the League of Nations. The United Nations did non basically challenge national sovereignty. it did non change the bing distribution of power among nation-states. and it institutionalized the dominant place of the great powers – specifically the winning powers in the World War II. The United Nations did non derive the monopoly on the legitimate usage of force. which would be necessary to go a universe authorities and to enforce order through superior force and authorization. Therefore. the intent of this survey is to measure the cardinal abilities of the United Nations in prosecuting and accomplishing the rule of corporate security in the international system.

Research Question

The of all time increasing menaces to the province of security in the universe have prompted a stopping point examination on the United Nation’s nucleus map of corporate security. As a modern-day international governmental organisation ( IGO ) . the United Nations surely does non represent a universe authorities with absolute power and authorization to enforce peace on the universe. Yet. this does non intend the United Nations is powerless or undistinguished.

While the United Nations faces legion hurdlings in implementing the international jurisprudence due to the sovereignty statues of provinces and nation-states. the organisation can still act upon the behaviour of provinces and supply forums for communicating and interaction that would be considered more orderly than implied by the construct of lawlessness. Therefore the research inquiry involves a critical expression into the public presentation of the United Nations relation to its chief map of continuing the rule of corporate security in the international system.


The nucleus empirical research hypothesis of this survey states that the United Nations has non succeeded in continuing the rule of corporate security in the international system.

Significance of the survey

The United Nations Charter is based on consolidative rules that serve as the drive force for the organization’s enterprises. One of the cardinal rules of the United Nations Charter is the acknowledgment of the autonomous equality of all member provinces. As such. all member provinces are considered to be every bit autonomous over their several districts. Each member province has one ballot in the General assembly. yet they are non equal in wealth and power. Furthermore. merely five major powers have lasting seats on the Security Council.

Critics and supporters likewise point out that the United Nations institutionalizes international inequality due to

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay