Case Study Analysis Example Essay Example

peers, and making inappropriate comments to classmates. Consequently, his educational program was reduced to half-days.

Smith was suspended for 5 days and recommended for expulsion after making lewd comments to female students. His grandparents filed a lawsuit on his behalf and his case joined Doe’s. The district court ruled in favor of both students, but the school and state appealed to the Court of Appeals. Court decisions regarding the Education for All Handicapped Children Act and public school discipline have sparked numerous questions. Expulsion and long-term suspensions of handicapped students present legal challenges, particularly in light of a recent Supreme Court ruling on the matter.

John Doe, who is now 24 years old, no longer falls under the protection of the law that defines age limits for disabled children between ages 3 and 21. This decision is based on respondent Smith's eligibility for EHA educational services. At present, Smith is 20 years old and still attending high school, which means he remains under the jurisdiction of the Court due to a reasonable likelihood of future deprivation of his rights mandated by EHA. Smith has not provided any evidence regarding his social functioning or ability to overcome behavioral issues. Thus, it is reasonable to anticipate aggressive and disruptive behavior from him in the classroom. Consequently, placing him in future educational programs without expecting disruptions would be unreasonable.

References

1. Honig V. Doe, 484 U. S. 305 (1988)
2. Bartlett, Larry, Exceptional Children, Jan. 1989
3. Yudof, Mark, Educational Policy and the Law, 4th edition Essex, Nathan L.

, School Law and the Public Schools,