Immigration: Shaping and Reshaping American Politics Essay Example
Immigration is a complex and divisive issue in American politics, with various problems arising from current policies and practices. These issues involve a large number of undocumented immigrants living in the country and the difficulties faced by illegal immigrants. The effects of immigration go beyond international competition and national security, greatly impacting many individuals and families. Additionally, it raises important questions about American identity, citizenship, and how America is viewed globally.
The immigration system in America has been acknowledged by President Obama, President Bush, and previous administrations as flawed and in need of a complete overhaul. Currently, there are over 12 million unauthorized immigrants living in the United States, with an average of around 500,000 new entrants each year over the past decade. Roughly two-thirds of these unauthorized immigrants enter through the U.S-Mexico border, while 30-40 percent obtain tempor
...ary entry visas but stay in the country even after their visas expire. The economic recession has temporarily slowed down the growth of this unauthorized population. Prior to the elections in August, the Republican Party adopted an immigration platform that includes employers verifying their workers' legal status and denying federal funding to universities offering lower in-state tuition rates for immigrants. This platform also supports stricter border enforcement and is against amnesty for illegal immigrants. Mitt Romney's platform endorses compassionate procedures to encourage self-deportation or voluntary return among illegal immigrants. Despite his previous stance, Mitt Romney attempted to moderate his position before the 2012 elections by expressing openness to considering a "Dream Act" specifically for undocumented immigrants serving in the military.In June of this year, President Barack Obama implemented a new policy that allowed undocumented immigrants who arrived i
the United States as children to avoid deportation for two-year periods and obtain work permits. This program, operated by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services agency, began accepting applications on August 15th. It was President Obama's most ambitious action on immigration after Congress failed to pass the Dream Act that he supported. While its main goal was to appeal to Latino voters, it successfully accomplished that objective. The aim was to regain support from disillusioned Latino voters who were unhappy with his administration's deportation of around 1.2 million immigrants over three years, mainly Latinos.
However, only 72,000 individuals had applied for temporary relief one month after launching the program—much lower than officials' expectations of 250,000 applicants. Many young immigrants couldn't afford the $465 application fee or lacked necessary documentation.
The question remains: why hasn't Congress passed immigration reform when leaders from different political backgrounds agree on it? The answer lies in Washington's partisan divide. Both President Obama and Republican Mitt Romney have differing opinions on immigration, which is a common disagreement between Democrats and Republicans.The formation of a coalition to support reform is further complicated by internal conflicts within each party.The US economy has benefited from the presence of low-cost, low-skilled foreign labor through illegal immigration, which has boosted productivity. However, US employers who have benefited from this situation are hesitant to support reform and rely on Congress for improvement. The role of public finance also plays a part in immigration politics, as seen in California and Texas' histories. In the mid-1990s, both states had fiscally conservative Republican governors - Governor Pete Wilson for California and Governor George Bush for Texas. These governors were potential Presidential
candidates facing challenging fiscal situations specific to their states. California dealt with a severe recession caused by reduced defense spending after the Cold War while Texas faced repercussions from the savings and loan crisis along with fluctuations in oil prices. Both states experienced an increase in immigrants settling there, but Bush and Wilson had differing views on immigration despite initially seeming to have similar political beliefs supporting free trade like NAFTA.While Wilson supported Proposition 187 in California, a measure that sought to restrict public services for undocumented immigrants, Bush took a different stance and embraced the immigrant community in Texas. In fact, he actively pursued Latino voters and even campaigned in Spanish. This strategic approach proved successful as Bush secured 49 percent of the Latino vote (and 69 percent overall) during his victorious gubernatorial campaign in 1998 - an unprecedented feat for a Republican candidate running statewide among Hispanics (Varsanyi 296).
- Appeal essays
- Revenge essays
- Corporate Governance essays
- Public Service essays
- Income Tax essays
- Supply essays
- Red Cross essays
- Democracy essays
- State essays
- Liberty essays
- Absolutism essays
- Reform essays
- Republic essays
- John Marshall essays
- Bourgeoisie essays
- Developed Country essays
- Elections essays
- International Relations essays
- Left-Wing Politics essays
- Monarchy essays
- Political Corruption essays
- Political Party essays
- Political Science essays
- Sovereign State essays
- United Nations essays
- World Trade Organization essays
- Contras essays
- Dictatorship essays
- Foreign policy essays
- Monarch essays
- Corruption essays
- Foreign essays
- Democratic Party essays
- European Union essays
- President Of The United States essays
- John Stuart Mill essays
- Terrorism essays
- Military essays
- Social Security essays
- Federalism essays
- Gentrification essays
- Hillary Clinton essays
- Public Transport essays
- Health Insurance essays
- Life Insurance essays
- Emergency Management essays
- Insurance essays
- Aviation essays
- Transportation essays
- Presidential Elections essays