How Augustine accounts for the existence of evil Essay Example

sin also caused the world to be distanced from god.In this new ad damaged environment, remote from god, moral evil flourished and spread.

Both types of evil are interpreted as a punishment; 'all evil is either sin or punishment for sin. ' Augustine made the essential point that all humans, including innocent babies, deserve to suffer as all humans were present 'in the loins of Adam'. This reflects the ancient belief that every generation was seminally present in Adam, and therefore that every generation is guilty because they inherit his guilt for disobeying god.Augustine concluded this theodicy with a reminder of god's grace if god was simply just every one would go to their rightful punishment in hell. Through his grace however, god sent his son to die on the cross so that some might be saved and go to heaven. This shows that god is merciful as well as just.

Augustine's view that evil is the result of human free will rather than god's will can be supported. For example, we can argue that if god gives human beings genuine free will this necessarily entails the possibility of moral evil.Augustine's theodicy successfully accounts for the existence of natural evil as a result of the introduction for moral evil into the world. We can also support Augustine's assumptions that free will is so valuable that it justifies the risk of evil. Because of its compatibility with, and reliance upon, the genesis account of creation, Augustine's theodicy appeals to Christians who accept the authority of the bible as the word of god. Some weaknesses of the theodicy are that it has been argued that his theodicy

contains; logical errors, scientific errors, and moral errors.

Augustine's appeal to the free will defence poses a logical difficulty within the specific framework of his theodicy. It is hard to see how, in a perfect world, where there was no knowledge of good and evil, there could possibly be freedom to obey or disobey god, since good and evil would be unknown. The fact that god's creatures chose to disobey him seems to suggest there was already a knowledge of evil which only could have come from god. The scientific difficulties stem from Augustine's reliance upon the creation and fall stories in genesis.As a result, much of the arguement rests upon ancient and scientifically controversial Judaeo-Christian theology. One problem is Augustine's idea that the world was made perfect by god and then damaged by humans.

This contradicts evolutionary theory which asserts that the universe has continually been developing from an earlier stage of chaos. The second major weakness concerns Augustine's assumption that each human being was seminally present in Adam. This theory must be rejected on biological grounds which mean that we are not in fact guiltily for Adam's sin.This means that god is not just in allowing us to suffer for someone else's sin.

One moral difficulty in Augustine's theodicy concerns his concept of hell. Hell appears to b part of the design of the universe. This means god must have already anticipated that the world would go wrong - and have accepted it. Finally, although Augustine argued that god's selection of some people for heaven shows his mercy, other would argue that it displays irrational inconsistency, further questioning god's goodness.

The combined effect of

these criticisms leads most people to concluded that Augustine's theodicy does not work.