Gehart Chapter 5: Structural Family Therapy – Flashcards
Unlock all answers in this set
Unlock answersquestion
Structural therapy is primarily associated with the work of who?
answer
Salvador Minuchin
question
What is the general approach of structural therapists in helping their clients?
answer
They map family structure—boundaries, hierarchies, and subsystems—, then they restructure the family, realigning boundaries and hierarchies to promote growth and resolve problems.
question
Structural family therapists hold an attitude of what?
answer
Strengths--never seeing families as dysfunctional but rather as people who need assistance in expanding their repertoire of interaction patterns to adjust their ever changing developmental and contextual demands.
question
Boundaries
answer
rules for managing physical and psychological distance between family members, for defining the regulation of closeness, distance, hierarchy, and family roles
question
Although boundaries may sound static
answer
they are organic, living processes.
question
Structural therapists identify three basic types of boundaries
answer
Clear Boundaries, Diffuse Boundaries, and Rigid Boundaries
question
Clear Boundaries
answer
"normal" boundaries that allow for close emotional contact with others while simultaneously allowing each person to maintain a sense of identity and differentiation.
question
Diffuse Boundaries
answer
lead to relational enmeshment. Families with overly diffuse boundaries do not make a clear distinction between members, creating a strong sense of mutuality and connection at the expense of individual autonomy
question
When talking with an enmeshed family, therapists typically see family members doing the following:
answer
â– â– Interrupting one another or speaking for one another â– â– Mind reading and making assumptions â– â– Insisting on high levels of protectiveness and over concern â– â– Demanding loyalty at the expense of individual needs â– â– Feeling threatened when there is disagreement or difference
question
Rigid Boundaries
answer
these type of boundaries lead to relational disengagement. Autonomy and independence are emphasized at the expense of emotional connection, creating isolation that may be more emotional than physical. These families have excessive tolerance for deviation, often failing to mobilize support and protection for one another.
question
Therapists working with disengaged families notice the following:
answer
â– â– Lack of reaction and few repercussions, even to problems â– â– Significant freedom for most members to do as they please â– â– Few demands for or expressions of loyalty and commitment â– â– Consistently using parallel interactions (e.g., doing different activities in the same room) as substitutes for reciprocal interactions and engagement
question
systemic reframing
answer
It usually involves removing the blame from one person (the identified patient) and "spreading" blame equally by describing how each person's response contributes to the problem dynamic. Once this is done, blame becomes a moot point.
question
How to Generate Systemic reframes
answer
• assess broader interactional patterns (complementary relationships, hierarchy, boundaries, etc.) • redescribe the problem (use interactional patterns to describe the problem in a larger context).
question
Boundary making is
answer
a special form of enactment that targets over- or underinvolvement to help families soften rigid boundaries or strengthen diffuse boundaries
question
Boundary making may involve several different directives:
answer
• Asking family members to change seats • Asking family members to move seats further or closer together or turn toward one another • Having separate sessions with individuals or subsystems to strengthen subsystem boundaries • Asking one or more members to remain silent during an interaction • Asking questions that highlight a problem boundary area (e.g., "Do you always answer for your son when he is asked a question?") • Blocking interruptions or encouraging pauses for less dominant persons to speak
question
Challenging the family's worldview and unproductive assumptions typically involves
answer
verbally questioning operational assumptions in the family system, whether overtly spoken or covertly acted upon
question
Common assumptions that create problems for individuals, couples, and families include the following:
answer
• "Kids' needs come first." • "It's better to keep the peace than start conflict." • "It is easier to sacrifice my needs than ask for what I want." • "If I give here, you should give there." • "It's better for the kids for us to stay in this unhappy marriage."
question
Intensity and crisis inductions are interventions that
answer
use affect to create structural shifts in hierarchy and boundaries, especially when the family is having trouble "hearing" the therapist with other interventions
question
Intensity involves
answer
turning up the emotional heat by using tone of voice, pacing, and word choice to break through rigid and stuck interactional patterns.
question
An example of intensity would be
answer
example, a therapist may say to a couple who claims to have no time for a weekly date because of their children's numerous after-school activities, "Do you think your children would prefer to be in soccer and have divorced parents or to have fewer activities and an intact family?"
question
crisis induction in structural therapy is used with families who
answer
chronically avoid a conflict or problem
question
The point of using a crisis induction is
answer
So The therapist can then help the family develop new interactions and patterns.
question
An example of a crisis induction would be
answer
in families with anorectic children, the therapist may bring the symptom into the room by staging a meal and having the family deal with it. Similarly, with alcohol or substance abuse issues, the therapist often induces a crisis so that the family will acknowledge and finally address the problem.
question
When is unbalancing used?
answer
for more extreme difficulties in hierarchy or when the identified patient is being scapegoated. This intervention is used to realign boundaries between subsystems
question
explain how a therapist might use unbalancing in session
answer
Therapists use their expert position to temporarily "join sides" with individuals who are being scapegoated or with subsystems that need to develop stronger boundaries by arguing their cause or helping to explain their perspective to others.
question
When working with a highly rigid family structure, structural therapists directly challenge these beliefs and realities in order to do what?
answer
expand the family's functioning in new directions.
question
Describe one possible way a therapist could use to expand a family's rigid worldview:
answer
Rather than introduce an entirely foreign concept, the structural therapist takes the family's fundamental premise that has been supporting the problem and redirects its logic to support an alternative set of behaviors and interactions, allowing the family to maintain its core beliefs but use them in new ways.
question
Compliments are used to
answer
bolster behaviors that support families in moving toward their goals, and shaping competence involves noticing small successes along the way to reaching goals.
question
Minuchin and Fishman strongly recommend that therapists take what type of approach or view to psychopathology?
answer
therapists should identify and accentuate family strengths and positive interaction patterns, and therapists should augment and reinforce the family's natural positive patterns and strengths.
question
Harry Aponte, a structural therapy proponent, has been a leading voice in the field of family therapy on issues of
answer
spirituality, race, and poverty.
question
What kind of approach does structural family therapy take?
answer
employs an active, engaged approach in which the therapist often takes an expert stance in relation to the family, an approach that often fits with the values of traditional cultures.
question
Jose Szapocznik and his colleagues at the Center for Family Studies developed which form of therapy?
answer
brief strategic family therapy (BSFT) which is an evidence based structural family approach
question
Brief strategic family therapy is based on three central concepts:
answer
systems, structure (patterns of interaction), and strategy.
question
Brief strategic family therapy has two goals:
answer
• Reduce or eliminate child drug use • Change family interactions that are supporting the problem behaviors (youth drug use)
question
Ecosystemic structural family therapy (ESFT), an empirically supported adaptation of structural family therapy (Minuchin, 1974), was developed by
answer
Marion Lindblad-Goldberg and her colleagues at the Philadelphia Child and Family Training Center (formerly the Philadelphia Child Guidance Clinic)
question
Ecosystemic structural family therapy (ESFT), an empirically supported adaptation of structural family therapy (Minuchin, 1974), was developed to treat
answer
children and adolescents with severe emotional or behavioral problems and their families within the context of their communities
question
Ecosystemic structural family therapy is a bio/developmental/systemic trauma-informed clinical model that examines
answer
the biological and developmental influences of family members as well as current and historical familial, cultural, and ecological influences.
question
Ecosystemic structural family therapy therapists are guided by five interrelated constructs:
answer
• Family structure • Family emotion regulation • Individual differences (historical, biological, cultural, developmental) • Affective proximity (emotional attachment between parent and child and between parents) • Family development
question
The primary targets of therapeutic change in Ecosystemic structural family therapy are the following:
answer
• Parental executive functioning • Child coping skills • Co-parent alliances • Nonadaptive emotional attachment patterns • Emotional regulation • Extrafamilial supports to family members
question
Minuchin (1974) identifies three main phases of structural therapy:
answer
1. Join the family and accommodate to its members' style (build an alliance) 2. Map the family structure, boundaries, and hierarchy (evaluate and assess) 3. Intervene to transform the structure to diminish symptoms (address the problems they identified in the assessment)
question
Who Attends Therapy?
answer
To be able to assess the system, structural therapists prefer to begin therapy with the entire family, but they do not insist on it. However, once the family system has been assessed, the therapist often meets with specific subsystems and individuals to achieve structural goals.
question
Structural family therapists have a unique term for the therapeutic relationship:
answer
joining
question
accomodating
answer
Therapists "join" the system in the sense that they accommodate to its style: how people talk, what words they use, how they walk, and so forth. This technique is used in building the therapeutic alliance.
question
The attitude of joining requires
answer
(a) a strong, clear sense of connection and affiliation (e.g., curiosity, openness, sensitivity, acceptance) and (b) an equally clear sense of distance and differentiation (e.g., questioning, dissenting, promoting change).
question
Therapeutic spontaneity
answer
Structural therapists strive to cultivate this and it refers to the ability to flow naturally and authentically in a variety of contexts and situations.
question
How does a therapist cultivate therapeutic spontaneity?
answer
is cultivated and shaped through the training process, which increases therapists' repertoire for "being natural" in a wide range of clinical situations.
question
Therapist's use of self
answer
According to Minuchin, therapists must use themselves to relate to the family, varying from being highly involved to professionally detached.
question
Making it happen
answer
According to Minuchin, it is the therapist's job to do (almost) whatever it takes to help a family make the desired change. Therefore, a therapists' roles can vary widely: they can be the "producer" who ensures conditions that make therapy possible, the "stage director" who pushes the family toward more functional patterns, the "protagonist" who directly uses himself/herself to alter stuck family interactions, or the "narrator" or "co-author" who collaboratively helps the family revise their script. Thus therapists need to be open to playing whichever role will be most beneficial for a particular family in a given session, rather than being wedded to their own favorite roles.
question
Structural family therapists conceptualize and assess the following factors:
answer
• role of symptom in the family • Subsystems • Cross-generational coalitions • Boundaries • hierarchy • Complementarity • Family development • Strengths
question
Structural therapists identify three possible relationships between the symptom and the family system
answer
1. Family as Ineffectual Challenger of Symptom: The family is passive. In order to maintain a highly enmeshed or disengaged family structure, it fails to challenge the symptomatic member. 2. Family as "Shaper" of Individual's Symptoms: The family structure shapes the individual's experience and behaviors. 3. Family as "Beneficiary" of the Symptom: The symptom performs a regulatory function in maintaining the family structure.
question
How does a structural therapist view the identified patient in the family system?
answer
He or she is never seen as the sole source of the problem, and instead the family interaction patterns are targeted for intervention.
question
subsystems
answer
Some subsystems can be found in almost every family: couple, parental, sibling, and each individual as a separate subsystem. In addition, in some families other influential subsystems develop along gender lines, hobbies, interests (sports, music), and even personalities (serious versus fun loving). When assessing a family, generally the most important subsystem issues to consider are (a) whether there is a clear distinction between the parental and couple subsystems and (b) whether there is a clear boundary between the parental and child/sibling subsystems.
question
Define cross-generational coalitions
answer
A problematic subsystem that forms between a parent and child against the other parent or other key caretaker.
question
The goal of this model is to prevent unhealthy sequences from repeating, by
answer
interrupting the family hierarchical structure This includes the distribution of power shifting to others to by changing the style of interaction.
question
When working with reported problems in child behavior, therapists must first assess the parental hierarchy so
answer
they know how to intervene
question
There are three basic forms of parental hierarchy:
answer
effective, insufficient, excessive
question
effective parent boundaries
answer
When the parental hierarchy is appropriate and effective, parents can set boundaries and limits while still maintaining emotional connection with their children.
question
insufficient parent boundaries
answer
When the parental hierarchy is insufficient, parents are not able to effectively manage the child's behavior and often adapt a permissive parenting style.
question
examples of insufficient parent boundaries illustrated
answer
This style is easy to identify in the therapy office: the parents are not able to keep younger children from tearing up the waiting room and office, or their teens act as though they have the right to set their own curfews and rules. Often the parents hope that the therapist will "teach" their children to listen, but this often requires intervening more with the parents than the children.
question
Excessive parental boundaries:
answer
When there is excessive hierarchy, the rules are developmentally too strict and unrealistic and consequences are too severe to be effective. In this situation, there is almost always a rigid boundary between children and parents. These parents need assistance in developing age-appropriate rules and expectations and in developing a stronger emotional bond with their children.
question
Minuchin and Fishman (1981) identify four major stages in family development:
answer
1. Couple formation 2. Families with young children 3. Families with school-age or adolescent children 4. Families with grown children At each stage, the members need to renegotiate boundaries to define the levels of closeness and differentiation that will support individual members' growth needs. Families often get stuck transitioning from one stage to another if they fail to renegotiate boundaries and hierarchy as the family develops.
question
Structural therapists target similar goals for all families
answer
• Clear boundaries between all subsystems that allow for connectedness and differentiation congruent with the family's cultural contexts. • Clear distinction between the marital/couple subsystem and the parental subsystem. • Effective parental hierarchy and the severing of cross-generational coalitions. • A family structure that promotes the development and growth of individuals and the family.