Please enter something
Home Page Government Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Mischief Rule Essay Example
Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Mischief Rule Essay Example
Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Mischief Rule Essay Example

Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Mischief Rule Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
Topics:
Government, Social Issues, Weakness, Women'S Rights
View Entire Sample
Text preview

A strength of the mischief rule is that it helps to avoid absurd or harsh results. This is good because someone can be charged with something but if the literal rule was applied they could get away, but if the mischief rule is applied then the judge can change the meaning of the word and they wouldn’t get away with it. This happened in Smith v Hughes when prostitutes were soliciting men from a balcony but the act said they couldn’t do it from the street.

The judge changed the law so they prosecute them. Another strength of the mischief rule is that it is flexible because judges can decide what Parliament intended. A case which uses the mischief rule and shows that it has flexibility is Royal College of Nursing V DHSS. The wording of the Abortion Act s

...

tated that pregnancies must be terminated by a medical professional, which didn’t include nurses, but nowadays with modern technology nurses can actually do one of the processes in an abortion.

But the mischief rule does come with its disadvantages. A disadvantage of the mischief rule is that it gives too much power to judges because judges shouldn’t make law, it is up to Parliament. A case which uses the mischief rule and shows that judges have too much power because they are making law is Smith V Hughes. Under the street offences act it was an offence to solicit in the street or a public place. So prostitutes solicited men from their balconies.

But they judge changed the act so that the prostitute could be prosecuted – This shows their power.

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

The final disadvantage is that the mischief rule can be difficult to find in an case. How can judges decide what parliament intended when they weren’t present when the Act was made. This means that the judges won’t know what parliament intended when they interrupted the act so they have to take a guess and interpret the act themselves and so this could lead to them interpreting the act incorrectly.

Related assignments
Popular Essay Topics
Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New
Get unstuck with AI assistant right now
  • Enter your topic/question
  • Receive an explanation
Pro tips to get quality response
  • Ask one question at a time
  • Enter a specific assignment topic
  • Aim at least 500 characters
Question
What is the right structure for an essay
Answer
A paragraph is a related group of sentences that develops one main idea. Each paragraph in the body of the essay should contain:
  • a topic sentence that states the main or controlling idea
  • supporting sentences to explain and develop the point you’re making
  • evidence from your reading or an example from the subject area that supports your point
  • analysis of the implication/significance/impact of the evidence finished off with a critical conclusion you have drawn from the evidence.