David, the man depicted in the Bible, is destined to become Israel's second King. One of his renowned stories is when he defeated the Philistine giant, Goliath, using a sling and a stone. Numerous artists during the Renaissance created sculptures of this biblical figure.
These artists - Donatello, Verrocchio, Michelangelo, and Bernini - all created sculptures of David in their own unique style. Donatello was the first artist to create a sculpture of David. His David was the first life-size nude statue since classical times. Donatello's creation combined Classicism and realism, portraying David as a realistic figure resembling an Italian peasant boy but in the form of a classical nude figure.
Donatello's creation of David deviated from the traditional depiction of a Greek youth in his prime. Instead, Donatello opted for a portrayal of an adolescent boy who appeared somewhat
...weak due to his lack of muscle and minimal definition. After David's triumph over Goliath, he decapitated the Philistine. In Donatello's sculpture, the head is positioned under David's foot while a large sword rests by his side.
Despite the boy's small size, the sword appears disproportionately large, almost making one question David's ability to lift such a heavy weapon. The sheer size of the sword creates the impression that the task he just accomplished was impossible. David seems unsure of his own achievement, evident in his downward gaze toward his own body. However, David's intelligence likely compensated for his lack of physical strength.
(Fichner-Rathus 331-332) Verrocchio, who also designed a sculpture of David, was an imaginative sculptor in the mid-1400s. His depiction of David, a treasured and famous work of its time, shows a connection to Donatello's David. However,
there is a contrast rather than a similarity. Verrocchio portrayed David as a brave and somewhat older figure, devoid of pride and self-confidence, unlike Donatello's dreamy and disbelieving gaze (Fichner-Rathus 334).
Donatello and Verrocchio had different approaches to portraying David. Donatello combined realistic elements with an idealized, Classically inspired torso. In contrast, Verrocchio aimed for absolute realism in the smallest details. The technique used in each sculpture also differed. Donatello's David, referred to as a closed form sculpture, featured an S-curve stance that brought balance to the entire sculpture. Verrocchio, however, opted for an open approach when creating David.
The Verrocchio's David is distinguished by its bared sword and projecting elbow, which deviate from the central core. According to Fichner-Rathus, Donatello's graceful pose in his David was replaced by a jaunty contraposition in the Verrocchio version, accentuating David's self-confidence (334). Michelangelo, another brilliant artist, also sculpted a David. He established his reputation as a sculptor at the age of twenty-seven with this work. It is commonly believed that Michelangelo carved David from a block of marble that was considered difficult to work with.
Michelangelo's creation of David diverged from those of Donatello and Verrocchio. Rather than depicting David after he has already slain his foe, Michelangelo's sculpture presents him as a "most beautiful animal preparing to kill - not by savagery and brute force, but by intelligence and skill" (Fichner-Rathus 345). This version of David is portrayed with a sling draped over his shoulder and holding a stone in his right hand. The muscular details, including the veins, convey David's readiness and preparedness for battle.
The David sculptures by Donatello, Verrocchio, Michelangelo, and Bernini each portray a male figure
in their own unique way. Donatello and Verrocchio depict David as a young male who has just reached manhood and possesses great potential. This portrayal aligns with the classical tradition. Similarly, Michelangelo's David also represents a young man capable of accomplishing anything. Like Donatello's sculpture, Michelangelo's David is a closed sculpture revolving around a central axis.
In contrast, Bernini's David deviates from earlier representations by Donatello, Verrocchio, and Michelangelo. Bernini's sculpture presents a man in full maturity rather than a young boy or man. The sculpture depicts David fully engaged both psychologically and physically. He is shown in the process of slinging a stone with his left hand that ultimately brings down Goliath.
When we observe the creation, we sense a strong urge to step aside as if Goliath is standing directly behind us. This confrontation is intensified by the anticipation of violent action and the temporary halt of David's hidden power (Fichner-Rathus). Bernini's sculpture encompasses three of the five distinct characteristics of art from the Baroque era: motion, an unconventional approach to space, and the introduction of the concept of time. On the other hand, Verrocchio and Donatello opted to depict David after he had achieved his momentous triumph.
In contrast, Michelangelo's David depicts the figure before the battle, with dynamic energy coursing through his muscles. On the other hand, Bernini's David captures the moment during the fight, resulting in a distinct artwork. Unlike other sculptures, Bernini's work incorporates the element of time, encouraging viewers to imagine the completion of David's action. Moreover, the positioning of David also introduces a novel concept of space, as he no longer remains static in a Classical contrapposto pose but extends
into the surrounding space away from a vertical axis.
This movement away from a central core compels the observer to consider both the form and the space amidst and encompassing the forms to fully grasp the entirety of the composition (Fichner-Rathus 360). To grasp this artwork, we must scrutinize it from numerous perspectives, rather than just one. By doing so, we can witness the sculpture undergo transformation. It is evident that the sculptures crafted by Donatello, Verrocchio, Michelangelo, and Bernini diverge. Donatello portrayed David as a young boy who appeared nearly inept and in awe of his own accomplishment.
Verrocchio's David, although young, appears slightly older and more confident than Donatello's version. Meanwhile, Michelangelo's David, having just transitioned into manhood, exudes a powerful aura suggesting he could defeat Goliath. In contrast, Bernini's David is depicted as a fully matured individual, with immense strength and bravery, leaving no doubt about his ability to slay Goliath.
- Creativity essays
- Art History essays
- Theatre essays
- Pastoral essays
- Visual Arts essays
- Postmodernism essays
- Symbolism essays
- ballet essays
- Color essays
- Modernism essays
- Mona Lisa essays
- Work of art essays
- Body Art essays
- Artist essays
- Cultural Anthropology essays
- Ethnography essays
- Aesthetics essays
- Realism essays
- Heritage essays
- Harlem Renaissance essays
- Concert Review essays
- Voice essays
- Theatre Of The Absurd essays
- Playwright essays
- Scotland essays
- Tennessee williams essays
- Design essays
- Graffiti essays
- Graphic essays
- Typography essays
- Painting essays
- Photography essays
- Sculpture essays
- Architecture essays
- Interior design essays
- Arch essays
- Area essays
- Tattoo essays
- Pablo Picasso essays
- Vincent Van Gogh essays
- Michelangelo essays
- Frida Kahlo essays
- Professor essays
- Should College be Free essays
- Should college athletes be paid essays
- College Education essays
- College Tuition essays
- Graduation essays
- College Goals essays
- Personal Statement essays