Occupational Therapy Models for Cognitive Intervention – Flashcards
Unlock all answers in this set
Unlock answersquestion
What are the three models for cognitive intervention?
answer
Cognitive Retraining Model Neurofunctional Approach Dynamic Interactional Approach
question
Who created the Cognitive Retraining Model?
answer
Noomi Katz
question
CRM is appropriate for use with?
answer
adolescents and adults with neurologic and neuropsychological dysfunction (secondary CVA, TBI, learning difficulties)
question
Emphasis of CRM?
answer
first remedial, then adaptive
question
What theories is the CRM grounded in?
answer
neuropsychological, information processing theory, and developmental theory
question
Neuropsychological Rationale
answer
-Cortex is described as a network of fibers -Interdependency of cortical regions exists, such that every normal act is the result of a dynamic balance among all brain structures -Injury disrupts the balance, thus...a lesion in one area can disintegrate the entire functional system -Intervention aims to re-establish a balance in order to improve function
question
Neurobiological Rationale
answer
Neuroplasticity - cortical circuits may be modified following brain injury through experience and learning
question
Cognitive retraining OT rationale
answer
the purpose of cognitive retraining is to (1) improve cognitive deficits and (2) facilitate ability to transfer and generalize these capacities toward the performance of purposeful activities Providing opportunities to learn and experience --> improve ability to evaluate and become aware (metacognition) --> increased independence within any task/context
question
What does ot's rationale say about cognitive retraining?
answer
cog deficits are the primary cause of dysfunction. Functional deficits are caused by cog deficits. Cog retraining would *automatically* result in improved function
question
What does the research say about cog retraining?
answer
There is a relationship between cognitive processes and function An improvement in a cog process does not necessarily predict improvement in function
question
How can attentional performance be improved?
answer
By focusing on attention-dependent specific ADLs (ie, driving)
question
Secondary benefits to starting with the remediation approach?
answer
1. Facilitates patient's initial acceptance that a problem exists and promote awareness. 2. Promotes satisfaction with treatment outcome. -Makes it "okay" to choose adaptive compensatory alternatives because you have "tried to fix the problem" first.
question
How have cognitive retraining goals changed?
answer
They have moved from specific cognitive skills to function
question
Old model
answer
Deficit-specific FOCUS: Increase attention Increase memory Increase organization Increase orientation
question
Current model
answer
More holistic FOCUS: Functional outcomes Self-esteem Self-management skills Functionally-oriented cognitive skills
question
Evaluation Components
answer
1. Interview for history and future goals: -Pre-morbid occupational functioning -*Pre-morbid cognition or learning patterns* -Preferences & plans for the future 2. Observe functional ADL 3. Assess sensorimotor functioning -Strength, sensation, coordination, balance 4. *Assess general and specific cognitive-perceptual skills*
question
6 specific cognitive-perceptual evaluation areas
answer
Attention Memory Visual perception Spatial perception Visuo-motor organization Thinking operations
question
General Cognitive Assessment Instruments
answer
-Dynamic Loewenstein Occupational Therapy Cognitive Assessment (DLOTCA) -DLOTCA-Geriatric -Loewenstein Occupational Therapy Cognitive Assessment-Functional
question
Skills tested by DLOTCA
answer
Orientation, Visual and Spatial Perception, Praxis, Visuomotor Organization, Thinking Operations, Logical Questions
question
Skills tested by DLOTCA-geriatric
answer
Same as above but shorter and with enlarged items. Memory subtest added.
question
Skills tested by Loewenstein Occupational Therapy Cognitive Assessment-Functional
answer
Planning and following directions on a map, organizing tools in a box, and planning a daily schedule
question
Specific Cognitive Assessment Instruments
answer
-Rivermead Behavioral Memory Test - extended -Test of Everday Attention -Behavioral Inattention Test -Behavioral Assessment of Dysexecutive Syndrome -Self-awareness of Deficits Interview
question
Rivermead Behavioral Memory Test - Extended
answer
memory
question
Test of Everyday Attention
answer
attention (selective, sustained, switching, and divided)
question
Behavioral Inattention Test
answer
unilateral spatial neglect
question
Behavioral Assessment of Dysexecutive Syndrome
answer
executive functions
question
Self-Awareness of Deficits Interview
answer
awareness of deficits, disabilities, and ability to set realistic goals
question
Graded cognitive exercises
answer
Present targeted exercises and activities that gradually increase demands on the information processing system. Simple to complex Ability to respond to external environment Ability to manipulate the internal environment
question
Tabletop activities
answer
Worksheets to address specific cognitive skills "Drill and Practice" -repetition and rehearsal are critical -homework is required
question
Computer-based exercises
answer
Benefits: -Optimizes the ability to provide repetition and consistency of administration of cognitive stimuli -Useful for evaluation and measuring treatment outcomes -Can be done at home
question
Ultimate goal of intervention
answer
Improve metacognitive abilities so as to become independent in everyday life
question
Underlying assumptions of cognitive intervention
answer
1. Enhance remaining cognitive abilities 2. Restore/remediate cognitive skills 3. Develop strategies to adapt to environment
question
Goals of cognitive retraining model
answer
-Strengthen remaining cognitive abilities -Create new alternative strategies to process information
question
Outcome measure of cognitive retraining model
answer
- Decreasing activity limitations and enhancing participation in everyday activities
question
Neurofunctional approach
answer
The focus of this approach is on *retraining real-world skills* rather than retraining specific cognitive processes
question
Who developed NFA?
answer
Gordon Giles
question
Who is NFA appropriate for?
answer
clients with cognitive impairments from TBI, stroke, anoxia, or infection
question
Is NFA remedial or adaptive?
answer
can be both
question
What was the development of NFA grounded in?
answer
Learning theory and social psychology
question
Occupation-based model of NFA?
answer
"targets function, not impairment" (addresses real-world skill over retraining cognitive processes) "Learning by doing" (highly planned and structured activities; occupation as means and the end) "Improved cognitive function can only occur within the context of specific activities".
question
Assumes generalization ___________(does/does not) readily occur from one situation to another and ________(should/should not) be taken for granted
answer
Assumes generalization does NOT readily occur from one situation to another and should not be taken for granted.
question
Underlying assumptions
answer
From continuously practicing a task, over-learning will occur and progress to the point of automaticity
question
Why doesn't improvement in cognitive skill predict improvement in functional ability?
answer
Depends on functional resilience of the patient -occupational history -self-awareness -capacity for behavioral self-regulation -life experiences
question
What kind of model is the NFA?
answer
PEO model - the therapeutic process attempts to match the contextual demands to the person's capacity to meet them
question
NFA: Primary evaluation
answer
Unstructured/structured observation of occupational performance in contexts closely related to d/c disposition "The therapist's observation skills are most important in identifying the client's problems" (Unsworth, 1999, p. 31).
question
NFA: Secondary
answer
-Standardized tests may supplement if necessary. (A-ONE) -Affective, sensory, motor, perceptual, & cognitive skills are also considered
question
A-ONE
answer
-Arnadottir OT-ADL Neurobehavioral Evaluation -Performance-based tool that uses structured observations of UE and LE dressing, grooming, hygiene, feeding, transfers, mobility, and communication -Requires specific training
question
Training should be attempted in ___________________ (different ways/the same way) across functional domains so that _______________(maximal amount/minimal amount) of new learning is required
answer
Training should be attempted in the same way across functional domains so that only a minimal amount of new learning is required
question
NFA Integrates use of what?
answer
Reinforcement & skill building Task analysis Chaining Prompts Practice Errorless learning Shaping Antecedent control Over-learning Debriefing
question
Reinforcement aids __________
answer
learning
question
Primary reinforcement
answer
tangible
question
Secondary reinforcement
answer
intangible
question
Variance in # of cues related to a client's ability to ___________________
answer
control behavior
question
Components of task analysis may be converted to _______________ prompts
answer
visual and/or verbal
question
Chaining
answer
functional tasks are complex stimulus-response chains whereby one tasks sets the stage for the next
question
What method of chaining is most successful with severe TBI?
answer
whole task method
question
Backward chaining
answer
Therapist provides substantial assistance, even hand-over-hand guidance, through the initial steps in the task analysis ...until reaching the last step that the client can't do independently.
question
Benefit of backward chaining
answer
BENEFIT - hardest work at learning a new step occurs near the end of the chain, and leads immediately to the reinforcers associated with completing the whole chain
question
Forward chaining
answer
Therapist teaches the initial step first, with conditioned reinforcement following that first link...and then the therapist usually guides the client through the rest of the tasks.
question
Benefit to forward chaining
answer
Client learns steps in order
question
Whole task chaining
answer
Variation of forward chaining, but with the addition of supplemental reinforcers after each step
question
During whole task chaining, which reinforcer should be the strongest?
answer
Terminal reinforcer should be the strongest (Get points or stickers for each step accomplished, but Disney world is the ultimate reward!)
question
What should be faded over time?
answer
supplemental reinforcers
question
prompts/cues
answer
events that facilitate behavior
question
types of prompts/cues
answer
environmental verbal visual physical gestural
question
Cueing hierarchy
answer
No VC required Non-directive or open-ended cue Directed cue Full cue (answer provided)
question
Practice
answer
Repetition --> Over-learning --> Automaticity --> Integration
question
Errorless learning
answer
Errors are prevented from occuring through cues, guidance, etc. Different from trial and error learning where errors are corrected once they occur
question
Who is errorless learning best for?
answer
those with severe memory impairments
question
Shaping
answer
reinforcement of closer and closer approximations to the desired behavior
question
Antecedents
answer
way of controlling behavior by changing cueings events in the environment -alters chances that a desired behavior will occur examples: - checklists or to-do lists - sequenced instructions - other types of cues to inhibit or facilitate behavior
question
NFA Goals
answer
Improve real-world functioning or quality of life Re-establish habits and routines
question
NFA Outcome measurement
answer
decreasing activity limitations and enhancing participation in everyday activities
question
Dynamic Interactional Approach (DIA)
answer
Cognition is not static, stable, or fixed; it *changes with our interactions with the external world*; thus it is modifiable under certain conditions
question
Who developed the DIA approach?
answer
Toglia
question
Who was DIA developed for?
answer
TBI, but applied to all populations
question
Is DIA remedial or adaptive?
answer
both
question
What is DIA grounded in?
answer
Information-processing theory and cognitive psychology
question
What type of model is DIA?
answer
PEO model - the therapist should investigate dynamically the underlying conditions and processing strategies that influence performance
question
Define cognition
answer
Capacity to *acquire* and *use* information to *adapt* to environmental demands
question
What skills does cognition require?
answer
- Information processing skills - Learning - Generalization
question
Acquisition
answer
taking in, organizing, assimilating, & integrating new information with that previously learned *(information processing skills)*
question
Adaptation
answer
using information to plan and structure behavior for goal attainment *(learning)*
question
Application
answer
applying what has been learned to a variety of situations *(generalization)*
question
Summarize cognitive dysfunction
answer
Summarized as representing core *deficiencies* in the ability to -acquire (unable to organize new info) -adapt (unable to access previous knowledge when needed) -apply (cannot flexible apply knowledge and skills to a variety of situation)
question
Static Assessment: Quantitative or Qualitative?
answer
Quantitative
question
Dynamic Assessment: Qualitative or Quantitative?
answer
Qualitative
question
Static or Dynamic Assessment? Answers...Is there a problem? What is it? How severe is it?
answer
Static
question
Static or Dynamic Assessment? Answers...Can performance be changed? What cues or task alterations increase or decrease symptoms?
answer
Dynamic
question
What does a static assessment evaluate?
answer
deficits and degree of severity
question
What does a dynamic assessment evaluate?
answer
process of change and most optimal performance
question
Static assessment tells you how a patient performs ______________________
answer
in comparison to norms
question
Dynamic assessment tells you how a patient performs _______________
answer
when test conditions change
question
What does static assessment examine?
answer
independent performance (examiner is neutral and unbiased)
question
What does dynamic assessment examine?
answer
change with guided assistance or task alteration
question
Examples of static standardized assessments
answer
Line crossing test Star cancellation test Picture scanning test Object search task
question
Dynamic investigative assessments
answer
-Toglia Contextual Memory Test -Dynamic Visual Processing Assessment -Toglia Category Assessment
question
Questions to assess client's self-awareness/ self-perception of abilities PRIOR to task performance
answer
Since your stroke, do you often have trouble finding all the items in a drawer...closet...on a table? Do you tend to miss things on the left side? Do you think your ability to do this sort of activity has changed in any way since your stroke/injury?
question
Ways to facilitate change in performance DURING assessment, while assessing self-awareness
answer
If client has difficulty during an evaluation task, the OTR attempts to facilitate performance by -*Providing a series of cues* (are you sure you found all of the A's on the page?...There are still some remaining, can you find them?) -*Teaching strategies* (Go slower and use your finger to point at each letter) -*Reducing activity demands* (covering up part of the display; providing a perceptual anchor in left margin)
question
Questions for investigating client's self-perception of performance ; strategy use DURING ; AFTER task performance
answer
-How do you think you are doing? - Did you encounter any difficulty while doing this task? Tell me why... - I noticed you began to use your finger to point to each letting in the middle of the task - can you tell me why?
question
Dynamic Visual Processing Assessment
answer
Examiner provides *guidance, encouragement, and feedback* in an attempt to elicit the patient's best performance
question
What is the Dynamic Visual Processing Assessment based on?
answer
Vygotsky's zone of proximal development (diff people can have the same baseline on a static test, but differ in the extent to which they can profit from instruction) AKA "zone of rehabilitation potential"
question
Zone of rehabilitation potential
answer
The difference in what one can do without help vs with help
question
If client's performance is NOT facilitated through repetition and practice, then...
answer
Try adaptive approach -Modify the task or environment. -Train specific functional skills
question
If client's performance is facilitated through repetition and practice, then....
answer
Try remedial approach -Train in efficient strategy use -Practice strategies in multi-contexts
question
In this approach, what do we think about the transfer of learning?
answer
it is not assumed! -practice in multiple situations -focus on effective strategy use -incorporate metacognitive training
question
What approach does treatment incorporate?
answer
Multicontextual approach -The *same processing strategy* is practiced across activities ; situations that gradually change. -An emphasis on *self-monitoring ; self-evaluating* performance is embedded throughout treatment. Targets areas that show some evidence of self-awareness ; responsiveness to cues.
question
Generalization
answer
Ability to apply what has been learned in therapy to a variety of NEW situations ; environments Involves a process of decontextualization
question
Decontexualization
answer
Moving from a context-dependent state to a context-independent state example: Using memory notebook for acute rehab schedule sessions and then use it at home for daily school schedule
question
Transfer of learning
answer
Included within the concept of generalization but is narrower in scope Refers to the ability to apply specific strategies to a related task NOT all-or-none; instead, conceptualized on a horizontal continuum that reflects different degrees of transfer of learning
question
The transfer continuum
answer
Represents activities/situations that remain at a similar level of complexity but gradually differ in physical or superficial similarity and provides a guide for the sequence ; progression of treatment activities, based on activity analysis Near --> intermediate --> far --> very far transfer activities
question
Near-transfer activities
answer
appear very similar to each other
question
Intermediate-transfer activities
answer
appear somewhat similar to original activity
question
Far and very far-transfer activities
answer
appear very different from the original activity
question
Near transfer
answer
Occurs when previously acquired knowledge is transferred to new situations that are closely similar to, yet not identical, to the initial learning situation Example: transferring experiences associated with driving a car (manual transmission) to driving a truck (manual transmission)
question
Near transfer learning
answer
Ability to apply strategy across activities that are similar
question
Far transfer
answer
Entails the application of learning to situations that are entirely different to the initial learning Example: Learning about logarithms in algebra class ; applying when assessing growth of bacteria in microbiology class
question
Far or very far learning
answer
ability to apply strategy use across activities that are *very different* in appearance represents far or very far learning (generalization) Example: learning about logariths in algebra class and applying when assessing growth of bacteria in microbiology class
question
Awareness training
answer
Clients will move beyond the cued condition only if they have internalized the ability to *self-monitor ; regulate* performance. *Responsibility* of cueing ; structuring activities is gradually transferred from therapist to client. Need to provide a *non-threatening environment*; convey a positive message rather than a negative one.
question
Clients will move beyond the cued condition only if they have internalized the ability to ______________________________________
answer
self monitor and regulate performance. -Responsibility of cueing ; structuring activities is gradually transferred from therapist to client. -Need to provide a non-threatening environment; convey a positive message rather than a negative one
question
Goal Rating Scale
answer
Reliance on others 1. relies on others for info *majority* of time 2. Relies on others for info *frequently* (~50%) 3. Relies on others for info *some* of time (~25-33%) 4. Relies on others for info *occasionally* (;25% of time) 5. Does not rely on others for info at all
question
Cognitive dysfunction represents core deficiencies in
answer
- information processing strategies - self-monitoring skills
question
The extent to which the core deficiencies are observed depends on what?
answer
Person Environment Task/Occupation
question
Goals
answer
Facilitating optimal skill performance by changing the activity, environment, or person's use of processing strategies for maximizing functional capacity
question
Outcome measurement
answer
Decreasing activity limitation and enhancing participation in everyday activities
question
Limitations of DIA
answer
Cannot be used to measure change over time Requires a high level of expertise from the therapist Needs further research to examine effectiveness of metacognitive training
question
In an ideal world, rehab would look like...
answer
Intensive deficit-specific cognitive retraining using specialized training tasks + Intensive behavior-training in training settings followed by --> intensive generalization training in natural settings with personally meaningful tasks and routines
question
Advantages and disadvantages: Focus on mastering specific deficits until patient is ready to apply this to real-world skill
answer
Maximal repetitions promote neuroplasticity Lack of evidence to support - Does "mental muscle building" translate to everyday functional activities?
question
Advantages and disadvantages: Focus on learning within the real-life context assuming the patient will learn better this way
answer
Highly concrete routines help organize behavior (this does not necessarily mean that is how the patient is dependent on it forever) Difficult to do enough repetitions needed for learning in a natural context