Hamlet vs All My Sons Essay Example
Hamlet vs All My Sons Essay Example

Hamlet vs All My Sons Essay Example

Available Only on StudyHippo
  • Pages: 2 (949 words)
  • Published: October 24, 2017
  • Type: Essay
Text preview

There have been many adult females in history who are known today by their different features. For illustration Beverly Allitt. known as the “Angel of Death” a paediatric nurse who killed 4 kids and injured 5. Queen Victoria supported an act of parliament 1938 which abolished bondage in the settlements of the British Empire. This goes to demo that although people may believe adult females are all likewise. they are most decidedly non. Kate Keller of Arthur Miller’s All My Sons and Gertrude of Shakespeare’s Hamlet are both really different characters who portion but really few similarities throughout the two dramas. Ones cognizing of their partner’s offense committed. one’s action of lying. and their different degrees of intelligence. all prove that the two adult females are both different.

Incorporated in both Hamlet and All My Sons. are enigmas. In Hamlet of class. is the enigma of Hamlet’s father’s decease. Who murdered him? Claudius. we know. However Gertrude did non cognize. There is no grounds that she had any thought of it. although Hamlet does impeach her. at one event in the drama. of cognizing that Claudius is a slayer. Whereas Kate from All My Sons knows everything about what her hubby Joe. has done. She knows he is guilty of the deceases of the pilots.

It is apparent from the beginning of the drama that Kate is in fact guilty of something. When Ann shows up. her behavior towards her is unusual. and of class. she acts this manner because she is afraid that Ann may cogniz


e something that will convey the truth out. She will non allow travel of the possibility that Larry is alive. which brings in foreshadows. For illustration when she says to Joe. “You above all have got to believe. you…” ( 1. 309-312 ) Ann’s brother George goes by the house shortly after Ann arrives. He had merely visited their male parent in prison. and has come full of fury. Kate notices. and rapidly lures him in with her appeal. and motherly features to do him about bury why he was angry. to protect her and Joe from the secret they have been maintaining. This is a large factor which differentiates the two characters. Gertrude and Kate. One knew of the offense committed. and the other did non.

Kate from All My Sons seems to be a really cagey adult female. In fact. she is highly intelligent. She is cognizant of everything that could travel incorrect. She is really careful in what she says and does. and she knows how to manage any bump in the route. She does so. throughout the drama. like when Ann’s brother George arrives. However. her being intelligent does non do her a really rational character. 3 old ages after the disappearing of her boy Larry. she still hopes to believe he is alive. She clings to that thought. She believes in any given “sign” or superstitious notion. Like for illustration the whole state of affairs of the horoscope. Gertrude from Hamlet is less intelligent.

She is more nescient. She is taken in by Claudius’ expressions and personal appeal. and rapidly marries him. You

View entire sample
Join StudyHippo to see entire essay

would believe she must hold known about Claudius being her husband’s liquidator. jumping in to a matrimony with her brother in-law so rapidly. However. she knows nil. It was no act of naughtiness. merely an act of ignorance. demoing she may non hold even loved Hamlet’s male parent at all. or really small. Hamlet besides acts unusual around Gertrude. He is disgusted by his mother’s actions. Gertrude does non hold a hint as to why he acts that manner. until he tells her. Merely so does she recognize her actions were been incorrect.

Kate is a adult female known to hold a big capacity for love. She loves her household. obviously. She does nevertheless hold an even larger capacity for lying. She knows that Joe sent out the chapped cylinder caputs out. and caused the decease of several pilots. She and Joe both keep the secret. She hopes and prays that her boy Larry is still alive to non hold to cover with the fact that his ain male parent was the cause of his decease. She states. “As long as you live that male child will be alive. that male child is alive. God does non allow a boy be killed by his male parent. ” Gertrude on the other manus does non lie the manner Kate does. Yes. she does lie to herself about the possible effects of her hapless actions. but I wouldn’t see it as peculiarly lying. I see it more as ignorance. Simply. she is declining to believe the truth. Therefore. Kate Keller is a prevaricator. while Gertrude is non.

You may state that both Kate and Gertrude portion the same motherly features. They both have strong connexions with their boies. Nevertheless. Kate seems to hold a more echt love for her boy. Gertrude is more selfish. She hurries in to a matrimony shortly after Hamlet’s male parent dies. and does non believe of the injury it will make to her boy. Kate. although she does lie. shows that she truly loves her boies. and that she ever wants the best for Chris.

It is clear that Gertrude of Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Kate Keller of Arthur Miller’s All My Sons are two really different characters. Gertrude is guiltless. in non cognizing the offense Claudius has committed. where Kate Keller does cognize the offense her hubby has committed. Both adult females have different features. Kate being smarter than Gertrude is one of them. And in conclusion. portion a different love for their boies. proprietor