Bar Exam: Commercial Paper
Unlock all answers in this set
Unlock answersquestion
commercial paper
answer
written instruments for the payment of money
question
maker/promisor/obligor
answer
person who promises to pay
question
payee/promisee
answer
person entitled to payment
question
certificate of deposit
answer
a note issued by a financial institution where: - financial institution acknowledges receipt and - promises the payee/depositor to repay the money
question
draft
answer
a three party order to pay money; all checks are drafts but not all drafts are checks
question
drawer
answer
person ordering payment
question
drawee
answer
person making payment; also called payor bank
question
payee
answer
person to receive payment
question
check
answer
order to pay money where: - financial institution is drawee - payable on demand
question
types of checks
answer
-ordinary - certified: bank has accepted/agreed to pay - cashier's: drawer and drawee same bank; person buying check is remitter - teller's check: drawn by one bank on another bank; person buying check is remitter - traveler's check: demand instrument requiring a counter signature by person whose specimen signature is already on instrument
question
remotely created item
answer
draft not signed by drawer but created with drawer's authority so third party can get paid from drawer's account at a bank
question
negotiability
answer
refers to form of instrument at time of issuance; required to establish holder in due course
question
requirements for negotiability
answer
1. in writing 2. signed by maker or drawer 3. unconditional promise or order to pay 4. fixed amount 5. in money 6. no other undertaking or instruction 7. payable on demand or at definite time 8. words of negotiability
question
unconditional promise or order to pay
answer
presumption of unconditional promise or order promise conditional: - express condition - promise \"subject to\" or \"governed by\" another record - incorporation of rights/obligations by reference
question
fixed amount
answer
- on its face - interest stated as amount, rate or by reference to outside source okay or no rate determined by judgment - if interest not mentioned at all- no interest
question
no other undertaking or instruction
answer
instrument is not a full contract; permitted undertakings: - promise about collateral - confession of judgment clause - waiver of a law meant to benefit obligor
question
payable on demand or at definite time
answer
- expressly states on demand or \"at sight\" - if no date-> it is a demand instrument - permissible time statements: - date - fixed period after sight or acceptance - time readily ascertainable/predictable at time promise issued - changes permitted: prepayment or acceleration - permissible extensions of due date: - by holder: any time - by obligor: later definite time stated -automatic extension upon condition in instrument to later definite time stated
question
words of negotiability
answer
- must contain bearer or order language - if both bearer and order language- bearer controls - checks do not need words of negotiability to be negotiable - bearer if: - payable to bearer - payable to the order of bearer - indicates possessor entitled to payment - no payee stated - to cash or to order of cash - not payable to identified person order: \"to the order of\"
question
negotiation
answer
transfer of negotiable instrument so transfer is a holder
question
holder
answer
1. physical possession of negotiable instrument and 2. good title depends on bearer/order - bearer: possession alone for good title - order: possession plus necessary indorsements for good title (special, restrictive)
question
indorsement
answer
signature on negotiable instrument by someone other than maker, drawer or acceptor
question
blank indorsement
answer
payee signature creates bearer paper - further negotiations require only possession
question
special indorsement
answer
payee's signature plus designation of new person to whom instrument now payable - creates order paper - further negotiations require endorsement of new person
question
restrictive indorsement
answer
limits what may be done with instrument
question
identifying payee
answer
1. intent of issuer determines initial payee 2. multiple payees using \"and\" requires all payees to indorse 3. multiple payees using \"or\" or \"and/or\" requires one payee indorsement
question
transferee's right to transferor's indorsement
answer
when transferee pays value, has specifically enforceable right to transferor's indorsement
question
depositary bank
answer
becomes holder even without transferee's signature
question
misspelled payee name
answer
payee can indorse with incorrect or correct name; person giving value may require both indorsements to clear chain of title
question
payee lack of capacity
answer
indorsement still effective even if a minor, incompetent, unduly influenced
question
rights of mere holder
answer
can enforce payment
question
holder in due course HDC
answer
1. need negotiable instrument (satisfies 8 elements) 2. need to be holder: possession and good title 3. authenticity not apparently questioned 4. pays value 5. good faith: honesty in fact and observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing 6. without notice at time of instrument acquisition
question
notice
answer
- actual knowledge - also need reasonable time to act on notice - reason to know from facts and circumstances - filing of public record does NOT put person on notice
question
without notice that:
answer
1. instrument principal overdue (not interest) 2. instrument dishonored 3. uncured default on another instrument part of same series 4. unauthorized signature 5. alteration 6. any claim 7. any defense or claim in recoupment
question
shelter rule
answer
transfer of an instrument vest in the transferee the rights that transferor had; HDC can transfer HDC rights even to donee exception: person that was party to fraud or illegality affection instrument cannot take shelter
question
real defenses
answer
1. infancy 2. duress 3. lack of legal capacity making obligation void 4. illegality making oblation void 5. fraud in factum: signer lacked knowledge of instrument's character or essential terms and lacked opportunity to learn of them 6. bankruptcy 7. omission of required consumer protection language (treated like it contains language) 8. statute of limitations - note: 6 years from due date - check: earlier of 3 years after dishonor or 10 years after issue 9. payment to former holder when obligated party had no notice of transfer 10. alteration 11. unauthorized signatures or forgeries
question
personal defenses
answer
- failure of consideration - breach of warranty - fraud in inducement
question
HDC rights
answer
takes free from personal defenses, subject to real defenses and free from claims of others to instrument
question
contract liability
answer
- suit to collect the money - person cannot be sued unless they signed instrument
question
signature by agent
answer
- agent personally liable unless: principal identified and signature unambiguously shows it is made on behalf of principal - to HDC: liable unless can prove HDC had notice of representative nature - to non HDC: liable unless agent can prove original parties did not intend agent to be liable - checks: no liability if principal's name on check - if agent not authorized it is forgery and agent bound
question
signature by maker of note (liability)
answer
- liable to holder or indorser who paid instrument - must pay when due according to terms - defenses: depend on HDC status
question
signature by drawer of draft/check (liability)
answer
- liable to payee - cannot disclaim liability on checks but can on other drafts - secondary liability if: 1. presented to drawee and 2. dishonored by drawee
question
indorser of note or draft primary liability
answer
- liable to later indorsers - can disclaim liability - order of liability: liable in order of signatures 1. can sue prior indorsers for payment 2. can be sued by later indorsers for payment
question
drawee
answer
- generally, no negotiable instruments contract - liable only for conversion (payee) or not properly payable check (drawer) - can agree to pay draft by signing (acceptance/certification) but not obligated to; if they do, discharges drawer and all indorsers
question
conversion liability
answer
- drawee who pays forged indorsement liable to payee in conversion - payee must have received delivery of the instrument
question
drawer's death
answer
- drawee bank can continue to pay checks until ti knows drawer has died and has reasonable opportunity to act - can pay for no more than 10 days after death if bank knows unless someone claiming interest in account requests bank stop paying immediately
question
accommodation parties
answer
co signers, sureties and guarantors; sign instrument to lend credit to another party and does not receive any direct benefit from borrowed money
question
accommodated party
answer
principal/obligor/debor; person with bad credit
question
accommodation party
answer
suret/co signer; person with good credit
question
holder
answer
creditor/obligee; person who wants payment assured
question
liability of accommodation party
answer
presumed to be guaranty of payment and holder can collect from before attempting to collect from accommodated party unless they include express language limiting the contract to a guarantee of collection only- \"collection guaranteed only\"
question
warranty liability
answer
- off instrument created by transfer or presentment - need not be in possession of instrument (unlike contract) - survives final payment (unlike contract)
question
transfer warranties in general
answer
- made by transferor who receives consideration to immediate transferee and subsequent transferees if the transferor indorsed - in banking context- any subsequent collection bank even w/o indorsement - drawee and makers cannot sue for breach of transfer, they sue for presentment
question
specific transfer warranties
answer
1. warrantor is entitled to enforce the instrument 2. warranty of holder status (good title) 3. all signatures authentic and authorized 4. no alteration 5. no good defenses against transferor 6. no knowledge of insolvency proceedings 7. if remotely created- drawer actually authorized item note: strict liability for all but insolvency
question
disclaiming transfer warranties
answer
- checks cannot disclaim - non checks may disclaim: \"without warranties\"
question
presentment warranties in general
answer
made on presentment for payment from presenter or previous transferor to parties who pay in good faith including makers, drawees and acceptors
question
warranty when unaccepted draft presented (paycheck)
answer
1. warrantor entitled to enforce draft or obtain payment 2. no alteration 3. no knowledge of unauthorized drawer's signature 4. if remotely created, person identified as drawer authorized the item
question
other instruments
answer
warrantor entitled to enforce draft or obtain payment
question
warranty versus indorser's contract
answer
- if P is holder and payor has not paid: indorser's contract - If P is payor and payor has paid: breach of warranty
question
discharge by holder
answer
holder can discharge obligation by surrendering instrument to obligor, destroying it, canceling it, etc
question
effect of instrument on underlying obligation
answer
payment by certified check, cashier's or teller's discharges underlying obligation uncertified check/note: underlying obligation suspended - discharged if paid later - holder can sue on either instrument or obligation if later dishonored
question
failure to produce original instrument
answer
1. person not in possession must show: - person entitled to enforce when loss occurred - loss not due to transfer or lawful seizure - person cannot reasonably obtain original 2. protection for payor required: bond or security
question
overdrafts
answer
bank can charge account even if results in overdraft but does not have to
question
postdated check
answer
considered a draft; bank may pay postdated check unless customer gives notice of postdating and describes check with reasonable certainty
question
stop payment orders
answer
- in writing- effective for 6 months - oral- effective for 14 days - must describe item with reasonable certainty so reasonably prudent banker could find - must be received in time and manner that gives bank opportunity to act - banks defenses: did not comply with requirements or customer suffered no loss because would have to pay check any way for example because payee was HDC
question
cashier's and teller's check
answer
- remitter cannot stop payment - bank can but risks liability
question
wrongful dishonor
answer
- drawee dishonors properly payable check - DRAWER can bring action, payee may not - all damages caused by dishonor - banks defenses: result in overdraft or check is more than 6 months old
question
payment in full check
answer
check or accompanying communication on which drawer conspicuously indicates that cashing check acts as payment in full of existing obligation which is unliquidated or subject to dispute - operates as an accord and satisfaction if payee cashes unless: - payee returns within 90 days or - organization had notified drawer of particular place to send payment in full check
question
forged maker's signature
answer
- alleged maker not liable (unless ratifies) - forger is liable
question
forged drawer's signature (bank customer)
answer
- alleged drawer not liable - forger is real drawer so that presenter can enforce unless they KNEW unauthorized - drawee bank must reaccredit alleged drawer's account as check was not properly payable - bank can pass on loss if breach of presentment warranty or it has defense: 1. drawer's negligence substantially contributed to forgery 2. bank statement rule: if customer does not inspect statement and bank can prove loss beyond original mistaken payment, customer precluded; must report within one year 3. repeat offender rule: if same person forging, drawer must report within 30 days of statement availability or will not reaccredit for later forgeries by same person
question
forged payee's name
answer
- bearer: irrelevant - order: breaks chain of title and check not properly payable - drawer can demand bank recredit account - bank's defenses: 1. impostor rule: issuer/maker estopped from denying validity of indorsement because carelessness in issuing check contributed to forgery 2. fraudulent indorsement by employees: employer entrusts employee with respect to instrument and employee fraudulently indorses, it is effective and payee estopped
question
liability of drawee (bank)
answer
- conversion liability to payee - defenses: impostor, fraudulent indorsement by employee - not properly payable liability to drawer - defenses: drawer's negligence, failure to timely sue - drawee protected from double liability
question
liability of presenter
answer
liable to drawee bank for breaching presentment warranty of entitled to enforce
question
liability of transferor
answer
presenter who loses to payor for breach of presentment may sue for breach of transfer warranties of - entitled to enforce - all signatures authentic or authorized and - no good defenses
question
alteration
answer
- change in obligation: HDC can enforce original amount - unauthorized completion: HDC can enforce as completed - Non HDC: alteration fraudulently made by holder is total discharge of obligor - Non HDC: not fraudulently made can enforce original terms
question
not properly payable
answer
- altered check not properly payable generally - bank's defenses: 1. drawer's negligence substantially contributes to alteration (leaves space on amount line) 2. bank statement rule:
question
common bar hypo
answer
Facts: - D issues check payable to P from Bank - T steals P's check, forges and deposits in Credit Union - Credit Union presents check to Bank for payment and Bank pays - D and P discover forgery and notify Bank Liabilities: - Bank is liable to: D for cashing check not properly payable OR to P for conversion - Credit Union liable to Bank for breaching presentment warranty of entitled to enforce because Credit Union was not a holder - T is liable to Credit Union for breaching the transfer warranties of entitled to enforce, all signatures authentic and authorized and no good defenses because he forged check
question
drawer vs. holder
answer
drawer of a check is liable to pay a holder of the check according to its terms at time it was issued after holder presents it for payment and it is dishonored
question
promise of performance or to give value
answer
value given for purposes of qualifying as HDC only to extent of performance or value; if no delivery, no value given, no HDC
question
promise not conditional
answer
- statement of consideration - reference to another record \"as per\" or \"in accordance with\" - incorporation by reference of items that would not hurt HOLDER: collateral, prepayment, acceleration - limit of payment to particular fund or source - countersignature (traveler's check) - consumer protection language
question
indorser secondary liability to
answer
secondary liability if: 1. presentment within 30 days of indorsement (not liable after 30 days) 2. dishonor and 3. notice of dishonor within 30 days of dishonor
question
final payment by drawee
answer
- ends contract actions - occurs when: 1. pays item or 2. does not revoke provisional settlement by deadline (midnight of next day)