Pierre Hadot. Chapter 11. Philosophy as a Way of Life. and The City of God (Augustine) – Flashcards

Unlock all answers in this set

Unlock answers
question
1. Explain what "ataraxia" (peace of mind), "autarkeia" (inner freedom) and cosmic consciousness are.
answer
• Ataraxia • Autarkeia • Comic consciousness ○ More transformational, transform the person, not always learn more ○ These three don't pursue knowledge in itself, but pursue the transformation of the philosopher • The three of them are interconnected, they are what are at the heart of the philosopher • They are what helps the philosopher become Atopos, independent thinker • Three aspects of becoming a philosopher, the opposite of these 3 things would be the theoretical approach • Wisdom brings these three things, shows philosophy as therapeutic
question
2. Explain the difference between "discourse about philosophy" and "philosophy itself."
answer
• Discourse about philosophy ○ The parts of philosophy - physics, ethics, and logic ○ When it comes to teaching philosophy, it is necessary to set forth a theory of logic, a theory of physics, and a theory of ethics ○ The exigencies of discourse, both logical and pedagogical, require that these distinctions be made • Philosophy itself ○ No longer a theory divided into parts, but a unitary act which consists in living logic, physics and ethics ○ We no longer study logical theory, we simply speak well ○ We no longer engage in theory about the physical world, we contemplate the cosmos ○ We no longer theorize about moral action, but we act in a correct and just way
question
3. Why are "attention" and "to live in the present" so important for Stoics, Epicureans and philosophy in general?
answer
• Philosophizing was a continuous act, permanent and identical with life itself, something that had to be renewed at each instance • Exercises were necessary ○ Intense meditation on fundamental dogmas ○ Ever-renewed awareness of the finitude of life ○ Examination of one's conscience ○ Specific attitude toward time • Live in the present, the present sufficed for happiness • Recognizing the infinite value of each instant, wisdom is just as perfect and complete in one instant as it is throughout an eternity • We not only can but we must be happy right now • Had a sharp awareness of the infinite, incommensurable value of existence
question
4. In what moment in history and in what institution was philosophy transformed from being a Way of Life into a theoretical and abstract activity?
answer
• End of the 18th century onward, philosophy would be indissolubly linked to the university • Philosophy reduced to the philosophical discourse, developed from this point on in a university environment much different from ancient philosophy • No longer a way of life
question
1. From the perspective of the "City of God" what is the highest or "Supreme Good" and "Evil"? Compare this to the positions of Plato and Aristotle.
answer
• Supreme good is eternal life • Supreme evil is eternal death Do obtain eternal life we must live righteously
question
3. What is the end of the "City of God"? Is it achievable on earth? Why or why not?
answer
The end of the "City of God" is beatitude and eternal life and peace. - Not achievable on the earth because things are only temporary and God is not present - You need God, God is constant and last forever - You cannot have beatitude nor eternal life on earth
question
2. What is Augustine's understanding of virtue? Is his view similar to the Greek conception? Why or why not?
answer
• Augustine compares well to Plato and Socrates • Virtue is intellectual, like Socrates says virtue is a kind of wisdom • For Augustine, virtue has to do with the intellect • The only difference is the ultimate goal. ○ Augustine it is peace and eternal life which can only be achieved in the City of God and it can only come from order, cannot be achieved on Earth ○ Augustine's view of the ultimate goal differs 100% from Greek philosophers because Augustine is a Christian philosopher and he believes in God § Everything in the Earthly city has to aim towards God ○ Platos' is contemplation of the forms and The Good, which can be achieved while on Earth
Get an explanation on any task
Get unstuck with the help of our AI assistant in seconds
New