differentiated instruction
“shaking up” what goes on in the classroom so that students have multiple options for taking in information, making sense of ideas, and expressing what they’ve learned
general principles of DI (3)
1. respectful tasks
2. flexible grouping
3. ongoing assessment and adjustment
differentiated instruction IS… (7)
1. proactive – plans a variety of ways ‘to get’ at and express learning
2. more qualitative than quantitative – adjust the nature rather than the quantity of an assignment
3. rooted in assessment – ongoing
4. student -centred – provide appropriate challenging learning experiences for all students
5. multiple approaches to content, process, and product – what how and how to demonstrate learning
6. blended of whole class, small groups, individual instruction – whole: establishes common understanding, small/individual: most effective
7. organic – is evolutionary, and dynamic – continually learning
teachers with differentiated classrooms use (5)
1. convos with individuals
2. classroom discussion
3. observation
4. examine student work
5. formal assessment
learning takes place most effectively in classrooms where: (5)
i. knowledge is clearly organized
ii. student highly active in learning process
iii. assessments are rich and varied
iv. students feel sense of safety and connection
v. learning experience pushes learner a bit beyond his or her independence level
rational for DI (3)
i. the image above standard — issue student is comfortable it denies what we know about the wide variance that inevitably exists with any group of learners
ii. no substitute for high quality curriculum and instruction in classrooms
iii. even with high quality instruction and curriculum we will fail in helping each learner be successful unless we build bridges between the learner and the learning
advanced learners may not achieve their full potential because they… (5)
i. become mentally lazy
ii. become ‘hooked’ on the trappings of success
iii. become perfectionists
iv. fail to develop a sense of self -efficacy
v. may fail to develop study and coping skills
gifted
remember faster, have special hobbies/interests that you’ve learned lots about, learning is easier
teaching struggling learners (7)
1. look for positives in learner
2. don’t let what’s broken extinguish what works
3. pay attention to relevance
4. go for powerful learning
5. teach up
6. use many avenues for learning
7. see with eyes of love
accomodation
changing HOW a student is taught and how he or she is assessed (i.e hearing impaired student has an interpreter)
modification
changing WHAT a student is taught and how he or she is assessed (i.e student works on multiplication, while others do long division)
content
the input of teaching and learning
what we learn
differentiated content
goal: to offer approaches to ‘input’ (info ideas and skills) that meet students where they are and vigorously support forward progress
differentiated content can be thought of in 2 ways:
1. can adapt what we teach
2. we can adapt or modify how we give students access to what we want them to learn
how can content be differentiated?
1. response to students interests learning profile or readiness
2. response to any combo above
interest differentiated of content
involves including the curriculum ideas and materials that build on current student interests or extend students interests
learning profile differentiated of content
implies ensuring that a student has a way of ‘coming at’ materials and ideas that match their preferred way of learning
readiness differentiated of content
goal is to match the material or information students are asked to learn to a students capacity to understand it
strategies for differentiated content (6)
i. concept-based teaching
ii. using varied text and resource materials
iii. learning contracts
iv. mini lessons
v. curriculum compacting
vi. varied support systems
curriculum compacting (3 stages)
stage 1: teachers identifies students who are candidate for compacting and assesses what they know and do not know about a particular topic
stage 2: teacher notes any skills or understandings covered in the study in which the student did not demonstrate mastery; and then lays out a plan to make certain that the students learn those concepts/skills
stage 3: teacher and student design an investigation or study for the student to engage in while others are working with the general lesson
concept – base teaching
emphasizes key concepts and principles
learning contracts
can contain both ‘skills’ and content components and the components of a contract can vary with a student’s needs
mini lessons
reteach a part of the lesson to students
find another way of teaching a group of students
meet with groups to extend their understanding
varied support systems (5)
1. note-taking organizers
2. highlighted print materials
3. design of key ideas
4. peer and adult mentors
5. reading partners and audio/video recorders
process
sense making or opportunity for learners to process the content or ideas and skills to which they’ve been introduced (HOW)
product
help students rethink, use and extend what they have learned over a period of time
4 categories for learning profile factors
1. intelligence preference
2. culture – influenced preference
3. gendered-basesd preferences
4. combined preference
intelligence preference
brain-based dispositions we all have for learning
combined preference
combo of gender and culture will create unique constellations of learning preferences in individuals
4 strategies for differentiated instruction in response to student’s learning profile
1. complex instruction
2. entry points
3. 4 – MAT
4. varied approaches to organizing ideas
complex instruction
emphasizes teachers studying their students to determine which intellectual strengths each student brings
4 MAT
varied learners would prefer:
1. mastery of information
2. understanding of key ideas
3. personal involvement
4. creating something new related to a topic
foundational to transformational
Foundational: basic and presented in ways that help them build a solid foundation of understanding
Transformational: stretch and bend ideas and see how it interacts with other ideas to create a new thought
ex. 1 kid may benefit from a foundational task related to classifying animal by body covering; while another may be ready for a transformational task of how environment affect body covering
concrete to abstract
concrete: need to become familiar with key information or material about an area of study
abstract: look at its implications, meanings or interrelationships
ex. idea of plot (concrete) leads to investigations of theme (more abstract)
simple to complex
simple: big picture of a topic ‘skeleton’
complex: add ‘muscle, bones, and nerves’
single facet to multiple facets
single facet: involve only a few steps or solutions to complete
multiple facets: more challenging by following complicated directions
small leap to great leap
small leap: taking what they learned and applying it
great leap: taking what they learned and apply it on a bigger scale
more structured to more open
more structured: well laid out and not many decisions to make
more open: discover and make more decisions
scaffolding
process that enables a student to solve a problem, carry out a task, or achieve a goal which would be beyond his or her unassisted efforts
purpose of scaffolding (5)
i. not to aid the student in completing a task, but to aid the handover of the skills needed to complete the task
ii. the teacher and student jointly perform the task to develop the student’s subsequent ownership of the skill
iii. distinction between handover and helping
iv. focus MUST be on the student’s active participation in the task
v. enables kid to acquire knowledge about task goals, actions and strategies that will lead to increased in subsequent occurences with the task
2 zones of development
1. zone of proximal development
2. zone of actual development
zone of actual development (ZAD)
when a student can do a task unassisted
zone of proximal development (ZPD)
the space in which instruction and new learning can take place
-needs help
-support learning
3 characteristics of scaffolding
i. interaction must be collaborative
ii. must operate within learners ZPD
iii. gradually withdrawn as learner becomes more competent
4 phases of scaffolding
i. modelling
ii. application
iii. scaffolding fading
iv. mastery
phase 1: modelling
teaching behavior that shows how one should feel, think or act within a given situation
3 types:
1. talk aloud
2. think aloud
3. performance
talk aloud modelling
verbal demonstration of the task
involves verbalizing the steps you would take
think aloud modelling
verbalization of the thought processes used to complete a task or solve a particular problem
performance modelling
physical demonstration of the task to be completed
phase 2: application
must constantly assess student understandings by:
-observing performance
-paying attention to error
-offer assistance and feedback
phase 3: scaffolding fading
offers progressively less assistance and feedback as they begin to master the new content &/or process
challenges of scaffolding (4)
1. requires teachers to give up some control
2. may not be properly implemented
3. requires planning and needs to be dynamic
4. taught with ZPD
task analysis
includes a detailed description of the:
1) steps and skills (physical, cognitive, and linguistic)
2) task complexity
3) environmental conditions
4) necessary equipment/materials
5) unique factors
*how the task is accomplished
shaping
discrete skill introduction involves breaking down the final desired activity into a series of individual tasks
they’re then taught and fully mastered
move on to the new task once mastery of other task is completed
UDL (universal design of learning)
learning approach that designs curricular materials and activities that have the flexibility to match learners strengths and needs so that they can reach their learning goals
2 key elements of UDL
1. flexibility – works with learners strengths
2. not one size fits all
where does UDL originally come from?
from the field of architectural studies
focus: on planning for accessibility in the need for retrofitting when a person with accessibility needs arrives
(CAST) Center for Applied Special Technologies
non-profit research and development organization that works to expand learning opportunities for all individuals, especially those with disabilities
CAST’s definition of UDL
a set of principles for curriculum development that gives all individuals equal opportunities to learn
Recognition Network
perceives information in the environment and transform it into useable knowledge.
-includes: how we gather facts & categorize what we see, hear and read.
-includes: identifying letters, words or an author’s style
is the WHAT of teaching and learning
(ties with multiple means of representation)
Strategic Network
plan, organize and initiate purposeful actions on the environment
-involves: planning & performing tasks and how we organize and express our ideas
includes: writing an essay, or solving a math problem
HOW you are going to go about things
(ties in with multiple means of action and expression)
Affective Network
monitor our internal and external environments to set priorities and to motivate our learning and behavior. How learners get engaged and stay motivated.
WHY
(ties in with multiple means of engagement)
UDL vs. DI
UDL – looks at breaking down barriers before students arrive in the classroom (curriculum)
DI – looking at the groups of students (student level)
3 UDL environments:
1. physical
2. social
3. academic
4 components of a UDL curriculum are:
i. goals
ii. materials and resources
iii. methods
iv. assessment
hidden curriculum
consists of a wide variety of social skills and strategies including teacher-pleasing behavior, peer interactions and group dynamics
Dr. David Rose
developmental neuropsychologist and educator
focus: development of new technologies for learning
cofounded CAST in 1984
3 concepts that help teachers insure education for all are:
1. UDL
2. DI
3. Progress monitoring
Progress monitoring
the pyramid represents both the time and intensity of instruction needed to meet the needs of particular students
Dominant themes for inclusive ed for exceptional students are
1. change
2. inclusion
3. accountability
an approach to progress monitoring is:
response to intervention (RTI)
response to intervention (RTI)
a tier 2 instructional support for students ho continue to struggle or make progress faster receiving classroom instruction that incorporated UDL and DI principles
students are provided instruction which is more intense and of a longer duration or possibly a different type of instruction
PYRAMID (for progress monitoring)
Tier 3 (at top)
Tier 2
Tier 1 (at bottom)
Tier 1
classroom instruction -incorporates UDL and DI principles
includes:
-DI
-delivered by general ed teacher
-uses evidence-based core curriculum
-effective for 80-85% of all students
Tier 2
represent changes to both the type, intensity and duration of instruction
includes:
-those who don’t respond to tier 1 instruction
-uses strategic, evidence-based interventions
-help students who need a bit more help
-delivered in small groups within general ed (support provided to teacher)
-offered to approx 15% of all students
-continue to participate in general tier 1 instruction
-don’t replace core curriculum, they supplement it
Tier 3
represent changes to both the type, intensity and duration of instruction
includes:
-uses intensive evidence-based interventions
-individuals or small groups
-direct instruction extended
-supplement instruction provided in tier 1
-only 5% need it
1950-1970
formation the Canadian Association for retarted kids
1958
learning disabilities association of Canada
1963
parents lobbied for education of kids with exceptional needs
inclusion
embrace people with exceptionalities as part of the mainstream of society and all its institutions from birth onwards
ableism
societal world view that able-bodied individual are the norm and individuals with disability must strive to become normal
– disability seen as a failure rather than a simple consequence of human diversity
pathognomic perspective
kids fault, teacher has no part
a set of beliefs that emphasizes the internal attributes of a person as an explanation for how they learn and behave
ex. ‘students with disabilities don’t belong in my class’
a set of unexplored assumptions
interventionist perspective
see disability as created in part by social conditions holding that society creates barriers that prevent people who are outside the mainstream of society’s privileges
-many UDL and DI perspectives evolved from this
-teachers believe they can make a difference
naked independence
exults the performances abled-bodied individuals and devalues the performance of others whose performance is aided by external devices or tools