The Tragedy of the Commons by Garrett Hardin’s
Garrett Hardin offers an in-depth analysis of issues surrounding humanity’s common resources. There are various common resources alluded to by the author, prominent among them are the geographic commons (the wilderness areas), air waves for telecommunication, public spaces that carry hoardings, the air that we breathe, rivers and oceans, etc. As citizens of a nation, we are all entitled to utilizing the commons for our individual good, albeit respecting certain limitations. One such right to a common resource is the right to procreate. While this might appear at first to be an individual right, seen in terms of its broader consequences, it is akin to the commons. By procreation, an adult couple locks up a portion of the common resources for the sustenance of the child. This includes the air, water, food and other material necessities that the child would require for survival. But people don’t aspire to merely survive – they want to ‘enjoy’ life’s comforts. So, the process of procreation also locks up more valuable natural resources for the child. Hence, the population problem is a core issue concerning the commons.
Published first in 1968, Hardin’s essay displays foresight and identifies an emerging
The idea of receiving government sanctions for having a child might come across as too radical an idea to most. But it has already been implemented by China, where the “one couple, one child” policy found widespread success. It is high time that regulation with respect to utilizing/consuming the commons is enforced. Already, the environment has degraded drastically and global warming is threatening sweeping destruction. To be able to thwart off these dangers, regulated access and use of the commons is the way to go forward. Garrett Hardin’s powerful arguments should embolden us toward this goal. But it should be remembered that Hardin’s recommendation is not greater privatization, which might ensure protection of the resource but not its equitable distribution among the population. Indeed, in the era of globalization, even erstwhile common resources like water are under private commercial usurpation. If this trend continues, it will lead to tragic social conflicts. Hence prudent government regulation is the ideal option.
Society, Ethics and Technology, Fourth Edition Morton E. Winston and Ralph D. Edelbach, pp. 352.
Wu Jianren’s 1906 novella ‘Sea of Regret (originally titled Hen Bai) is a masterpiece of modern Chinese literature. The book is rich in themes of morality and the challenges of modernity and patriotism. Adopting a tone of sentimentality that is essential to the Chinese literary aesthetic the novella deals also with concepts such as chivalry in the Chinese milieu of early twentieth century. This essay will argue how the tragedies in the lives of the two central female characters – Dihua and Juanjuan – are shaped largely by their own personal choices as opposed to external compulsions.
It is interesting to begin by trying to understand the choice of metaphor that constitutes the title. Sea of Regret is taken from an ancient Chinese myth that is well known to the Chinese public. The myth concerns the daughter of a feisty Emperor, who, after drowning in the ocean off the East coast, returns as the mythical bird Jingwei. This bird spends the rest of her life flying .