Sociological Critique Of Biomedical Health Models Sociology Essay Essay

essay A+

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

Biomedicine has being in being since the stoping of the 18th century. It is the major theoretical account used by wellness practicians to observe diseases ( Nettleton, 1995 ) .This biomedical theoretical account of wellness have centred on how the human organic structure maps and how diseases can be stopped, or healed through medical intercession ( Taylor and field, 2003 ) . This theoretical account continues to be the bedrock in which foundation of wellness attention system is based in the western societies, but at that place has being a batch of questions refering its influence on the general form of wellness, since bulk of wellness determiner are societal and environmental. Arkinson ( 1988 p.180 ) claimed that the biomedical theoretical account, which as taken over the formal wellness attention system in the West since the last two decennaries view wellness along the reductionist attack. In this attack, unwellness is said to be caused by hurt or infections and there is disregard of the psychological, socio-economical and environmental influences ( Taylor and field 2003 ) .

Stryer and Clancy ( 2005 ) reported that in Britain it was estimated that around 10 % of people hospitalised undergo some sort of iatrogenisis, which is tantamount to approximately 850.000 happenings per twelvemonth. Health is said to be extremely medicalised in this theoretical account which led to a general position of human existences ( Illich, 1990 ) . Oakley ( 1976 ) and Donnison ( 1977 ) reported this fact about medical legal power by mentioning an illustration of childbearing. They accepted that this was taken off from adult females by the institute of medical specialty by guaranting that by the 1970s all kid bringing took topographic point in the infirmary ( Tew, 1990 ) .This action made pregnant adult females to be handled like a ill individual. In this regard a normal life experience was turned into a medical job, which requires the aid of the medical squad ( Martin, 1989 ) .

The theoretical account focuses chiefly on the healing procedure which is at a disadvantage to bar and wellness publicity attention closer to the public ( Taylor and field 2003, p.31 ) . Wilmott ( 2003 ) supported this position by admiting that the theoretical account is strictly negative, because it is so congested with ailment and does non explicate what wellness entails. Engel ( 1981 ) stated that biomedicine has refused to admit the fact that the human organic structure is linked with the societal environment. Nettleton ( 1995 ) reiterated that the biomedical theoretical account neglected the presence of the societal inequalities in wellness. She besides argued that for effectual intervention, the laic people experience about wellness and unwellness must be acknowledged ( Nettleton, 1995 ) .

Harmonizing to the position of Marxists, he argued that physicians encourage the production rate of the society by explicating wellness as the potency to work, he besides disseminated that “ difficult work is better than indolence ” ( Waitzkin, 1989 ) .It was emphasized that the wellness professionals are blamed of medicalisation if they consider the social influence of patient and if they ignore, the accusal still holds ( Nettleton, 1995 ) .Gilleard and Higgs ( 2000 ) besides claimed that peoples aspiration in life as become medicalised from the consequence of a survey conducted by the British Medical Journal ( BMJ ) which involve analyzing some of the non-diseases that medical practicians need to undertake ( Smith,2002 ) .

The gender prejudice within the biomedical sphere was clearly emphasized from the struggle position ( Nettleton,1995 ) .It was cited by Nettleton from the feminist point of position that sexist political orientations of the medical profession present adult females as a 2nd category citizen, compared to the work forces folks ( Scully and Bart,1978 ; Martin,1989 ) .For illustration, it was related by ( Nettleton,1995 ) that the frequent female visit to the infirmary and clinics compared to their male opposite number is because of the manner their organic structure is designed for childbirth and besides for the attention they provide for other household members.

Foster ( 1989 ) stated that there are many ways in which the women’s rightist knock how the medical practicians interact with patient. She reiterated that most of the female jobs from the medical point of position need to be questioned. She supported are grounds by mentioning an illustration of catamenial hurting among adult females. She said that some female overstretch the badness of the hurting, while most ignores it ( Foster,1989 p.339 ) .She besides mentioned that the medical practicians considers male as first category citizen in the ways they interact with them compared to their female folks.

Gendered nature of power in biomedical research and clinical pattern was related in the US Public Health Service Task Force that there was disregard in the manner adult females ‘s wellness was being handled ( Patricia and Chiloe 1999 ) .They argued that the biomedical research laid more accent on diseases that can do high hazard of mortality in work forces compared to the adult females despite that the diseases were non sex-specific like “ chest malignant neoplastic disease ” . Robert ( 1990, 1992 ) besides supported this fact by accepting that male gender still stands as a step to measure the position of wellness of both sexes, despite the clamor to broaden people ‘s cognition about adult females ‘s wellness. Different Research have demonstrated that adult females who complain about serious marks are non given thorough scrutiny to undertake the symptoms compared to the manner work forces holding the same symptoms will be handled in countries of coronary arteriogram, and catheterization ( Shaw et al.,2004 ) .Patricia and Chiloe ( 1999 ) reported that a societal policy was promulgated which brought about seting a halt to the ceaseless usage of adult females as research animate beings and to diminish the job that could happen if fetus is exposed to research. Most feminist have cited that work forces are labelled as valuable being in the society compared to adult females whose psychological well being was said to be designed in a non-valuable sphere ( Scambler,1998 ) .The women’s rightists besides suggest that in this modern yearss the subjugation female goes through was brought approximately by the power construction given to their male opposite number ( Irigaray,1985 ) .

Women ‘s wellness was endangered through abortion brought approximately by the biomedical theoretical account. This position was supported by Foster ( 1989 ) by associating that the physicians assist the male by promoting the female to undergo bass horn ligation which is a signifier of household planning that make adult females unfertile everlastingly. This action favours the male, but damaging to the female everlastingly because of their inability to be able to gestate once more in life. This shows that work forces has truly dominated the universe and do non care about the well being of adult females. The extremist women’s rightist cited by Nettleton ( 1995 ) accepted that the western medical specialty have given work forces excessively much chance compared to the adult females. This has allowed work forces to take over the adult females ‘s organic structures, because work forces have capitalised on the fact that adult females are assessed based on their ain opinion.This is in line with the fact that wellness practicians frequently judge females psychological feelings based on their organic structure conformation which is designed for reproduction ( Abbott and Wallace, 1990 ) .What about domestic force and challenges adult females faces in the society in pull offing the place and their calling? .Some societies besides accuse merely adult females of sterility without seting their hubby ( work forces ) into consideration. This shows the extent to which the medical theoretical account has labelled adult females for non acquiring pregnant. Nettleton ( 1995 ) supported this by claiming that sterility is another thing that the biomedical theoretical account brought into being by turning it to be a disease of the adult females non work forces and non including them into their intervention program.

This thought every bit changed to an extent in the developed universe, where several medical scrutinies will be carried out on both twosomes. But this is still rampant in the underdeveloped state among certain civilizations. Can we see this to be the ground why females are psychologically affected sometimes? It was suggested that this procedure can be controlled by guaranting that adult females physicians treat the ill adult females within the society that is antiracist, anti-sexist, and anti-heterosexist ( Williams,1989 ; Abbott and Wallance,1990 ) .This thought was besides argued from another point of position by the reformer that the wellness system need to be changed from within.This is to guarantee that female physicians are besides employed in greater figure and besides implementing answerability by the medical practicians ( Williams,1989 ; Abbott and Wallance,1990 ) .

Stacey ( 1988, p.252 ) claimed that the medical theoretical account was besides accused of conveying into being what is known as societal female parents ( alternate ) .This is a sort of engineering which brought about construct by guaranting fertilization of an egg cell of one adult female and replacing it back into that adult female uterus or womb of another adult female. This sort of engineering which is known as “ New Reproductive Technology ” deprives the adult females of the power of liberty when they are unnaturally inseminated by a male sperm who might non be their partner. The females are denied of their biological right by being told that the proprietor of the donated sperm is the existent biological male parent while they are merely a alternate ( non existent ) female parent ( Zipper and Sevenhuijsen, 1987, p.252 ) .Corea ( 1985 ) besides supported this position by claiming that sperm of male is seen to be more of import compared to the female organic structure that goes through the three trimesters period, phases of labor and bringing. ( Doyal, 1998 andRaine, 2000 ) stated that gender difference may strip females from some basic medical attention, which could be as a consequence of prejudice and deficiency of wealth. They pointed out that the United land was able to shut the spread of gender differences by the debut of the National Health Service ( NHS ) .They reiterated that some wellness officers still treat adult females as non-valuable being, which could take to unjust show of medical resources. Doyal ( 2001 ) suggest that if we want the favoritism in clinical surveies to halt, the policy shapers will necessitate to do attempt to endeavor all research methodological analysis takes gender issues really of import. This will help in bridging the spread of peoples view on adult females ‘s wellness. This will besides augment the quality of biomedical research and findings. Doyal ( 2001 ) proposed that wellness publicity policies need to have on a new expression by avoiding gender difference in presenting their educational messages to the public because most of the run disseminated does non ever concentrate on the wellness of adult females but on the attention adult females give to other household members.

Scambler ( 2003 ) reported that mental wellness of adult females was seen to be dominated by medical specialty because of its dependance on drug prescription that is “ medicalisation of female unhappiness ” . Ehrenreich and English ( 1979 ) wrote about the different ways by which females were assumed to be mentally weak by reasoning that they suffer from craze, which was linked to their ability to reproduce. They are ever rendered useless by being confided to an environment which might non be really contributing and forced to confer with a medical practician that dictate solution to their job.

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member