Effects on children of witnessing domestic violence Essay

essay A

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all the help you need with your essay and educational goals.

Get Access

This thesis will analyze the grounds for the claim that witnessing domestic force causes serious and permanent injury to kids. As it would non be executable to carry on primary research on this subject at the research worker ‘s current degree of preparation, given the important ethical issues involved in working with kids and households in this context, it will dwell of an extended critical reappraisal of the literature on this subject. This organic structure of grounds will be consistently reviewed to set up the current province of cognition regarding:

aˆ? The strength of the nexus between exposure to domestic force and kids ‘s

aˆ? Trauma symptoms

aˆ? Development

aˆ? Social operation

aˆ? Internalising ( eg. depression )

aˆ? Externalising ( eg. aggression, riotous behavior )

aˆ? Academic public presentation

aˆ? The being of interceding or chairing factors finding the degree of harm caused by witnessing domestic force, including

aˆ? Disposition

aˆ? Social support

aˆ? Genetic factors

aˆ? The prevalence of exposure to domestic force in childhood.

Preliminary reappraisal of the literature

The prevalence of childhood exposure to domestic force

Intimate spouse force is disturbingly common in the UK: an analysis of recent informations gathered by the NHS for assorted intents found a lifetime prevalence rate of some experience of domestic force of 13-31 % among the general population of British adult females ( Feder et al, 2009 ) . In the US, Dong et Al found ( 2004 ) that 24 % of respondents ( n = 2,081 ) indicated that they had been exposed to domestic force while under the age of 18. These figures indicate that a high proportion of kids will, at at least some point, witness Acts of the Apostless of force between ( most normally ) their parents or health professionals in the place or another household puting. However, the utility of lifetime prevalence figures like this in measuring the existent impact of domestic force on kids is instead questionable: these consequences do non separate adequately between persons who witnessed a individual incident, or really infrequent “ mild ” force, and those who were repeatedly exposed to serious force. More elaborate informations is required to turn to the inquiry of how common drawn-out exposure truly is.

A farther job with the analysis of informations for the prevalence of kids ‘s exposure to domestic force is the high degree of accompaniment with other signifiers of ill-treatment. A big US survey ( 3,777 males and 4,411 females ) found that 12.3 % of work forces ( n = 482 ) and 15.9 % of adult females ( n = 703 ; qis square of difference 15.9, P & lt ; 0.0001 ) had witnessed “ maternal banging ; ” nevertheless, merely 3.7 % of work forces ( n = 139 ) and 3.8 % of adult females ( n = 168 ) had merely witnessed force and non suffered physical and/or sexual maltreatment as good ( Edwards et al, 2003 ) . This suggests that it may be difficult to place the specific consequence of witnessing force entirely ; it is intuitively obvious that places in which there is force between spouses are likely to be 1s in which there is an atmosphere contributing to other signifiers of maltreatment, and the parents ‘ orientation to the kid is extremely likely to be debatable.

Witnessing parental aggression: its effects on kid development

There is strong grounds that aggression and force between the kid ‘s parents or health professionals can hold serious negative effects even if the kid is “ excessively immature to understand: ” in peculiar, it has been suggested, really moderately, that domestic force negatively impacts the quality of maternal attention as hapless direction of emotions and struggles may reassign from the twosome relationship to the mother-infant 1 ( eg. Krisknakumar & A ; Buehler, 2000 ) . Indeed, adult females who are in violently opprobrious relationships may even show more negative ascriptions about their unborn kid while pregnant ( Theran, Levendosky, Bogat, and Huth-Bocks, 2005 ) , making the conditions for an emotionally distant parenting manner which can take to a hapless fond regard between female parent and baby. Of four surveies of kids aged 3-6 reviewed by Wolfe et Al ( 2003 ) , all but one found centrist to strong effects on internalizing and projecting symptoms as a effect of witnessing domestic force ; Levendosky et Al. ( 2002 ) besides found a important degree of post-traumatic emphasis upset ( PTSD ) symptoms in a similar population, and Bogat and her co-workers described clinically important injury symptoms in one-year-old babies exposed to household force ( 2006 ) . Interestingly, nevertheless, in a sample of 7865 British kids aged 5-16, Meltzer and his co-workers found that “ Witnessing terrible domestic force about tripled the likeliness of kids holding behavior upset but was non independently associated with emotional upsets ” ( 2009:491 ) . The image is yet farther complicated by the determination that at least some female parents who suffer domestic force in fact appear to counterbalance for this in ways which increase their handiness to their kids, demoing “ heightened sensitiveness and reactivity ” ( Letourneau, Fedick and Willms, 2007:649 ) .

Domestic force and stripling results

Given the complexness of the image of the consequence of witnessing domestic force ( and of holding a health professional who is a victim or culprit of it ) which has already emerged, it is to be expected that the impact of this signifier of ill-treatment on the eventual results of kids who are affected by it will besides be far from easy to find. High degrees of behavior upset and other accommodation and attitudinal jobs in the adolescent kids of beat-up adult females have been extensively described ( Fantuzzo et al, 1991 ; Holden and Ritchie, 1991, and legion ulterior surveies ) ; these behavior jobs have, nevertheless, bee N found to be conformable to intercessions to better female parents ‘ ain support, and direction of their kids ( eg. Jouriles et Al, 2001 ) . McFarlane and her co-workers found, worryingly, that in a sample of 330 kids ( including black, white and Hispanic ethnicities ) , “ the mean internalising behaviour mark for boys 6-11… every bit good as misss and boys 12-18… of abused female parents were non significantly different from the clinical referral norms ” ( 2003:202 ) , proposing that the impact of witnessing serious domestic force is adequate to take to clinically important symptoms – including suicidality and self-harming behaviors – in striplings. This indicates that, although the mechanisms by which it causes such great harm are as yet ill-defined, witnessing domestic force which is either serious or drawn-out demands to be treated as a major traumatic incident in a kid ‘s life. However, the prevalence of exposure like this is so great that step ining in the huge bulk of instances where injury is being caused would be impossible ; we are, moreover, larning of all time more about the factors which determine whether or non these experiences take a lasting toll, both biological and societal.

Domestic force and the biological science of injury

While merely a little fraction of the kids who suffer ill-treatment are, as it were, “ fortunate ” plenty merely to witness domestic force and non be capable to other signifiers of ill-treatment, even in these instances grounds has been found that “ both [ hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal ] axis and sympathetic nervous system working were found to differ between kids exposed to domestic force and comparing kids ( Saltzman, Holden and Holahan, 2005 ) , proposing that exposure to this signifier of injury has enduring biological every bit good as emotional effects. While the exact consequence of the sorts of alterations which Saltzman and his co-workers found on later operation is unknown, findings like this spring cause for serious concern that exposure to domestic force in early life may hold effects which include functional, peculiarly societal, damages which are hard ( although non impossible ) to get the better of. They may, excessively, have long term wellness effects: the drawn-out effects of biological emphasis responses observed in PTSD sick persons have been linked to a assortment of serious chronic unwellnesss ( Boscarino, 2008 ) , proposing that kids who witness force may be at hazard of sick wellness long after their exposure itself has ended. Future research seems likely to corroborate that the hypersensitivity to verbal struggle displayed by the one-year-old ( ie. pre-verbal ) babies studied by DeJonghe and her co-workers ( 2005 ) has a nervous footing ; this high degree of sensitiveness may itself predispose persons who were exposed to domestic force as immature kids to exposing high degrees of rousing in struggle state of affairss, lending to the outgrowth of aggression and behavior jobs in ulterior life.

Rationale for set abouting this research

It is clear from the preliminary reappraisal of the literature which has been presented above that exposure to domestic force is a serious kid public assistance issue: it affects a big figure of kids, is often combined with other signifiers of ill-treatment, and has been shown to hold long-run negative effects on both psychosocial operation and, more tentatively, on physical wellness. As such there is an obvious principle for measuring the current province of research into this subject: there is now a big volume of work on this issue, although it has merely been explored through empirical observation since the 1980s, and new techniques such as the usage of biomarkers and neuroimaging continue to add dramatically to our apprehension of the hazards and mechanisms of injury associated with witnessing domestic force. Producing a wide systematic reappraisal of the facets of this subject of greatest relevancy to societal policy and professional societal work pattern will assist to inform responses to this grave menace to the well-being of 1000s of kids in the UK, and contribute to the preparation of effectual responses to the challenges which household force airss today.

Outline research scheme

As has been mentioned above, the research scheme which will be adopted here is that of a critical reappraisal of the literature, based on a structured hunt of major diary databases. This scheme is the most appropriate one due in portion to the challenges of carry oning experimental or experimental research in households where domestic force occurs ; given the research worker ‘s deficiency of preparation in pull offing the attention and public assistance of vulnerable kids and grownups, a methodological analysis of this sort would non be appropriate. As such, an attack which does non present these ethical and practical jobs has been adopted.

A structured literature hunt methodological analysis will be used to seek the PUBMED, OVID and Web of Science databases ; the footings used will be selected in order to place literature which deals chiefly with exposure to force without the copresence of other signifiers of ill-treatment. Due to the wide range of this reappraisal, a meta-analytic attack would non be appropriate: where appropriate, meta-analyses of surveies on this subject will be included, along with treatment of the single surveies included in them. Particular attending will be given to critical analysis of the effectivity of the surveies ‘ efforts to except the consequence of confusing variables, including exposure to other signifiers of ill-treatment and verbal aggression in the place, societal factors and other issues.

Chapter lineation

Chapter 1: Introduction

The debut will put the job of domestic force and kids ‘s exposure to it in context. This chapter will besides put out the construction of the thesis and the subjects it will turn to.

Chapter 2: Domestic force: how common is it, and do kids witness it?

This chapter will analyze the prevalence of domestic force, with a focal point on the UK. It will besides see the grounds for how likely kids are to be cognizant of interpartner force.

Chapter 3: Emotional cicatrixs, physical alterations: the effects of witnessing force

This chapter will analyze the strength of the grounds for the psychological and physical effects of witnessing force, including pathological symptoms and other countries of map.

Chapter 4: Hazard and resiliency: why does witnessing violence injury some more than others?

This chapter will analyze the grounds for why witnessing force has a more serious consequence on some kids than others.

Chapter 5: Analysis

The overall strength of the grounds for a nexus between witnessing domestic force and the impacts considered will be discussed.

Chapter 6: Decisions



Agenda of undertakings to be undertaken and awaited timetable


Begin literature hunt procedure

Complete and subject this research proposal by the due day of the month of 4th Novembers

Continue to place relevant literature


Continue literature hunt

Identify high-quality, relevant articles

Collate surveies relevant to subjects


Begin analysis of identified articles

Complete bill of exchange of chapter 1


Further analysis of literature

Complete bill of exchange of chapter 2-3


Complete bill of exchange of chapter 4

Submit stuff completed to day of the month to project supervisor for reappraisal and remark ( at least three chapters )


Complete chapters 5-6

Complete bibliography and look into referencing


Proof reading

Submit concluding bill of exchange of to project supervisor with all relevant signifiers etc.


Submit finished work following university policies

Get instant access to
all materials

Become a Member